The Student Room Group

Maths Problem That I Really Should Know!

Any help much apprieciated with this differential equation problem:

Find the stationary points of the following functions determining in each case whether they are maxima, minima or saddle points:
iii) f = x^3 + xy + y^2

i said the derivitives with respect to...
fx = 3x^2 +y
fy = x + 2y

they must both equal zero for a stationary point. therefore are equal. Therefore should be able to work it out from there but my brain's gone dead!

I just need help to work out the co-ordinates. I can work out if it is max etc.

Scroll to see replies

Reply 1
3x^2 = -y = x/2
=> x(6x - 1) = 0
=> x = 0 or x = 1/6

Case 1: x = 0.
y = 0.

Case 2: x = 1/6.
y = - x/2 = -1/12.
Reply 2
Jonny W
3x^2 = -y = x/2
=> x(6x - 1) = 0
=> x = 0 or x = 1/6

Case 1: x = 0.
y = 0.

Case 2: x = 1/6.
y = - x/2 = -1/12.

ok, thanks.

so how do i find the co-ordinates?
Reply 3
Ollie
ok, thanks.

so how do i find the co-ordinates?


Surely those are the co-ords?
Reply 4
Nylex
Surely those are the co-ords?

ummm... shouldn't there be more?
Reply 5
There are stationary points at (0, 0) and (1/6, -1/12).
Reply 6
Ollie
ummm... shouldn't there be more?


Eh? How come?
Reply 7
Jonny W
There are stationary points at (0, 0) and (1/6, -1/12).

ok, thanks, i thought there might be 4.
Reply 8
Ollie
ok, thanks, i thought there might be 4.

ok, so why does this one have 4:

f = x^3 - 3x + xy^2
fx = 3x^2 - 3 + y^2 = 0 (1)
fy = 2xy (2)

2 is satisfied by x=0, y=0
x=0 into (1) give y^2 = 3 therefore y = +- root3.
therefore (0, root3) and (0, -root3) are stationery

y=0 into (1) gives x^2 =1, x = +-1
therefore (1,0) and (-1,0) are stationery

Thats what he wrote up in the example.

I'm not entirely sure whats going on!
Reply 9
Ollie
Any help much apprieciated with this differential equation problem:

Find the stationary points of the following functions determining in each case whether they are maxima, minima or saddle points:
iii) f = x^3 + xy + y^2

i said the derivitives with respect to...
fx = 3x^2 +y
fy = x + 2y

they must both equal zero for a stationary point. therefore are equal. Therefore should be able to work it out from there but my brain's gone dead!

I just need help to work out the co-ordinates. I can work out if it is max etc.


Set the partial derivatives equal to zero and solve them simultaneously:

fx = 3x^2 +y = 0
fy = x + 2y = 0 => x = -2y (*)

Substitute -2y for x in fx to obtain:

fx = 3(-2y)^2 + y = 0
fx = 12(y)^2 + y = 0 => y(12y + 1) = 0 => y=0 or y=-1/12

Substitute y values in (*) to obtain corresponding x values: x = 0 or x = 1/6

Thus, the stationary points are: (0,0),(1/6,-1/12).

As for your example, not all functions have 4 stationary points!! Some have 1, some have none, some have 4, some have 3 etc...

~Darkness~
Reply 10
now we know why you're not a moderator here :tongue:
Reply 11
elpaw
now we know why you're not a moderator here :tongue:

lol, easter's made my mind go so blank!

Yeah i know not all have 4 stationary points, but i couldn't see why the other one did.
Reply 12
Ollie
Yeah i know not all have 4 stationary points, but i couldn't see why the other one did.


Okay. Let's set the partial derivatives to zero and find the corresponding x and y values:

fx = 3x^2 - 3 + y^2 = 0 (1)
fy = 2xy = 0 (2)

As before, we want to solve these equations simultaneously. Now (2) is true (i.e. LHS = RHS) if x = 0 OR y = 0. In the case where x = 0, we can find the corresponding y value by substituting x into (1):

fx = -3 + y^2 = 0 => y^2 = 3 => y = +- sqrt3. In other words we have TWO values of y associated with this value of x, and thus two stationary points when x = 0: (0,sqrt3) AND (0, -sqrt3).

In the case where y=0, we again substitute into (1) to get:

fx = 3x^2 - 3 = 0 => x^2 - 1 = 0 => x^2 = 1 => x = +-sqrt1 = +-1. Therefore this value of y is associated with TWO x values, so we have a further TWO stationary points: (1,0) AND (-1,0).

HTH

~Darkness~
Reply 13
Darkness
Okay. Let's set the partial derivatives to zero and find the corresponding x and y values:

fx = 3x^2 - 3 + y^2 = 0 (1)
fy = 2xy = 0 (2)

As before, we want to solve these equations simultaneously. Now (2) is true (i.e. LHS = RHS) if x = 0 OR y = 0. In the case where x = 0, we can find the corresponding y value by substituting x into (1):

fx = -3 + y^2 = 0 => y^2 = 3 => y = +- sqrt3. In other words we have TWO values of y associated with this value of x, and thus two stationary points when x = 0: (0,sqrt3) AND (0, -sqrt3).

In the case where y=0, we again substitute into (1) to get:

fx = 3x^2 - 3 = 0 => x^2 - 1 = 0 => x^2 = 1 => x = +-sqrt1 = +-1. Therefore this value of y is associated with TWO x values, so we have a further TWO stationary points: (1,0) AND (-1,0).

HTH

~Darkness~

Thanks alot for this.
Reply 14
hey guys, come back round to this topic, finding it still hard to get the coordinates. I've got an answer but don't think it's right.

for example:
f(x,y) = x^2y - y + 3x^2 + 4y^2

fx = 2xy + 6x = 2x(y+3) = 0
fy = x^2 -1 + 8y = 0

now, I reckon there are 3 stationary points, where do you make them to be?
Reply 15
Ollie

f(x,y) = x^2y - y + 3x^2 + 4y^2

fx = 2xy + 6x = 2x(y+3) = 0 (1)
fy = x^2 -1 + 8y = 0 (2)

Cheat! Bouncing your thread back to the top by deleting and reposting the same thing!

I've never done partial differentiation, but:
From (2): 2y = (1 - x^2)/4
Sub into (1): x(1 - x^2)/4 + 6x = 0
x(1 - x^2) + 24x = 0
x^3 - 25x = 0
x(x+5)(x-5) = 0 so stationary points occur at x = -5,0,5
Reply 16
Ollie
hey guys, come back round to this topic, finding it still hard to get the coordinates. I've got an answer but don't think it's right.

for example:
f(x,y) = x^2y - y + 3x^2 + 4y^2

fx = 2xy + 6x = 2x(y+3) = 0
fy = x^2 -1 + 8y = 0

now, I reckon there are 3 stationary points, where do you make them to be?

f=x²y - y + 3x² + 4y²

f'x = 2xy + 6x
f'y = - 1 + 8y

f'x = 2xy + 6x = 0
2x(y + 3) = 0
x=0, y= -3
=======

x=0
==
f'y = - 1 + 8y = 0
0 - 1 + 8y = 0
y = 1/8
====

y= - 3
====
f'y = - 1 + 8y = 0
- 1 - 24 = 0
= 25
x = ± 5
=====

Stationary points are
(0, 1/8), (5, -3), (-5, -3)
================
Reply 17
Bezza
Cheat! Bouncing your thread back to the top by deleting and reposting the same thing!

I've never done partial differentiation, but:
From (2): 2y = (1 - x^2)/4
Sub into (1): x(1 - x^2)/4 + 6x = 0
x(1 - x^2) + 24x = 0
x^3 - 25x = 0
x(x+5)(x-5) = 0 so stationary points occur at x = -5,0,5

thanks, (and fermat), this agrees with my answer so have some rep :smile: for being 1st.
Reply 18
Ollie
thanks, (and fermat), this agrees with my answer so have some rep :smile: for being 1st.

Always the bridesmaid :frown:
Reply 19
Fermat
Always the bridesmaid :frown:

maybe 2mrw :smile:

Latest