The Student Room Group

~| Should I Join UKIP Or The Tories? |~

Scroll to see replies

What I had no idea UKIP was like this. It seems that they are going backwards...
Original post by RayApparently
You're against a universal definition of marriage enshrined in law? If Libertarians want freedom surely they want all people to be free to get married and have all the rights owed to them rather than be limited by the decrees of 'individual churches'. I wouldn't trust their doctrines over jurisprudents and democratically elected representatives.



Yes I am. Who owns the definition of marriage? The state? The church? No.
No one owns it. Individuals can define it however they want to.

Marriage should mean nothing legally it should be a purely social thing up to those involved. The current legal functions of marriage can easily be turned into partnership contracts if needed to.


If a church wants to define as it purely between a man and woman then so be it. A liberal church may wish to include same-sex couples in their definition. A ultra progressive liberal church may want to let 2 women, a men and a transsexual into a marriage.
Original post by Falcatas
Yes I am. Who owns the definition of marriage? The state? The church? No.
No one owns it. Individuals can define it however they want to.

Marriage should mean nothing legally it should be a purely social thing up to those involved. The current legal functions of marriage can easily be turned into partnership contracts if needed to.


If a church wants to define as it purely between a man and woman then so be it. A liberal church may wish to include same-sex couples in their definition. A ultra progressive liberal church may want to let 2 women, a men and a transsexual into a marriage.


But then is the individual not limited by the church. I'm all for freedom of individuals but what your saying sounds like freedom for churches to discriminate.

Surely the point of marriage and indeed civil partnerships is to have one's communion clearly recognised by the state. Otherwise everyone would (and a growing number of people do) just cohabit.
Original post by Allaboutthatbass
What I had no idea UKIP was like this. It seems that they are going backwards...


Which policy?
Original post by Rakas21
Which policy?


Things like not believing in gay marriage, reintroducing the death penalty and all this extreme nationalism. I feel like reading a history textbook.
Original post by Allaboutthatbass
Things like not believing in gay marriage, reintroducing the death penalty and all this extreme nationalism. I feel like reading a history textbook.


Well they technically dropped the death penalty although their DL is quite open about it and they plan to hold referenda on everything that gets a certain number of signatures which would include the death penalty and see a number of them supporting it.

Regarding stuff like gay marriage, they originated and are still dominated by the right of the Tories. Every person at the top has had links to the Tories at one point.
Original post by Rakas21
Well they technically dropped the death penalty although their DL is quite open about it and they plan to hold referenda on everything that gets a certain number of signatures which would include the death penalty and see a number of them supporting it.

Regarding stuff like gay marriage, they originated and are still dominated by the right of the Tories. Every person at the top has had links to the Tories at one point.


Still things like this kind of scare me..
"Should I Join UKIP Or The Tories?"

No, you shouldn't.
Original post by Allaboutthatbass
Still things like this kind of scare me..


Fear not, they are a symptom of current political issues. There's nothing that suggests they will ever lead the country.
UKIP
Original post by Smarter_tutor
Have you ever heard of Turkeys voting for Christmas? Why as an ethnic minority would you want to join parties that would like to see your demise? You need your head examining.


how do the tories want to see the demise of ethnic minorities? lol
Original post by RayApparently
I thought you were an authoritarian lol

Have you finally seen the light?


I converted to libertarianism recently from totalitarian socialism.
Original post by The Dictator
I converted to libertarianism recently from totalitarian socialism.


Sounds like a pretty big leap. I'm assuming you've given up on dictatorships but do you still believe in nationalised industry? Or do you want some sort of libertarian society run by a small-state dictator? Which, I admit, is a little tricky to imagine.
Reply 33
Neither!

Reply 34
Original post by The Dictator
UKIP are not racist.


The irony of being called 'The Dictator', and not understanding that UKIP have a core racist ethos is overwhelming. The Tories are racist, for God's sake!
Original post by RayApparently
Sounds like a pretty big leap. I'm assuming you've given up on dictatorships but do you still believe in nationalised industry? Or do you want some sort of libertarian society run by a small-state dictator? Which, I admit, is a little tricky to imagine.


I think the latter case is a bit fanciful but I wouldn't mind that. My nationstates.com country is run like that.

http://www.nationstates.net/nation=united_cromwellian_britain
Original post by maddo
The irony of being called 'The Dictator', and not understanding that UKIP have a core racist ethos is overwhelming. The Tories are racist, for God's sake!


They are a libertarian, non-racist party supporting Britain's interests. The Westminister elite don't want them to make a breakthrough!
Original post by The Dictator
I think the latter case is a bit fanciful but I wouldn't mind that. My nationstates.com country is run like that.

http://www.nationstates.net/nation=united_cromwellian_britain



Wow, very interesting. That actually perfectly says 'libertarian society run by a small-state dictator' haha

Of course as a socialist I'm uncomfortable with the whole 'unemployed at homeless shelter', corruption and rampant free market economics... Sounds like an uncomfortable place to live.

But I admire that, politically, you know your own mind.


So does this mean that (say you were Prime Minister) you'd dismantle/privatise the NHS?
Reply 38
Original post by The Dictator
They are a libertarian, non-racist party supporting Britain's interests. The Westminister elite don't want them to make a breakthrough!


They are a right wing, dangerous group of individuals who want to see something fun happen. Sorry mate, politics isn't fun. That's why we need a Communist state.
Original post by RayApparently
Wow, very interesting. That actually perfectly says 'libertarian society run by a small-state dictator' haha

Of course as a socialist I'm uncomfortable with the whole 'unemployed at homeless shelter', corruption and rampant free market economics... Sounds like an uncomfortable place to live.

But I admire that, politically, you know your own mind.


So does this mean that (say you were Prime Minister) you'd dismantle/privatise the NHS?


I would make a public/private system, yes.

Quick Reply

Latest

Trending

Trending