I can't help wading into this of course! Finally, some action on the TV thread.
This debate was all about whether a degree in media or TV production would assist you to get into TV, rather than whether you learned anything useful on a media or TV production degree.
Readers, have no doubt about it! Any kind of media-related degree is not going to help you to get your first job in TV. Nor will it confer any advantage whatsover on you as a candidate for any other job in the future. So, when you say that you as a grad of your course would get a job against another candidate because you have your degree, you are very very wrong. Very wrong! When it comes to recruiting in TV, and I have recruited a lot of telly bods, you are looking for someone who has the experience you are looking for, and the attitude you need, having ideally made the type of show you are producing already, for the same broadcaster, ideally the same commissioner editor. For newbies, you are looking for experience of either the production office, or the production on location. I personally look for attitude, initiative, can-do approach, someone who can see what to do before it needs doing, someone who is a good member of the team. If this person shows character and talent and potential, it will be spotted and (personally speaking in the kind of TV background I have) that person will be spotted and advanced quite quickly.
I would say it certainly assists fairly quickly if you are tech savvy and understand gear/kit/cameras, and I mean really properly understand them and how to look after them. It is generally a problem on location getting the less experienced members of the team to look after the kit - bits get left around, broken, lost and it all costs money, plus the cameras are less effective for the next user.
That does not mean to say that, once you get going, your degree won't be any use - it is likely to help you.
Experience gained in student productions doesn't count I'm afraid - you can't draw any equivalency between student productions and proper broadcast telly. And by broadcast telly, really we are talking BBC, ITV, C4 - I do think, again, that the experience won't go to waste further on down the line for you. This is because making proper broadcast telly is a business, it is just as much about money and the budget as it is about creativity. You are making the programme as a product for a client, it needs to be and look a certain way and have a certain content. Plus, TV is hierarchical - even though it can be collaborative - if you are lucky enough to work on anything where you can be collaborative - mostly, you are there to do a job that someone else needs you to do, like they want you to do it. You are there to deliver to the commissioner editor what the controller wants. Ultimately. This is partly why the student stuff is not that relevant.
The second reason why student films are not that relevant is that TV production is pressurised and you need people who can cut the mustard - student films are not made in the same way so they are not proof that you have the chops for real telly production.
It is nice to have keen, enthusiastic people who are very interested in TV around, and in this way a TV degree could show this, but really it is down to your attitude - if you are wise, you will not allow a sense of entitlement to seep through in any TV environment - because this just will not do! If you do this, it will likely work against you. Inexperienced members of the team who think they are too good to be doing lowly jobs come a cropper pretty quickly as they are a liability - you will be weeded out quite quickly.
It is important to learn the ropes of the business before you start - I have always found that good people are good at all levels. So, if you have a good runner, then that person likely will make a good researcher and a good director.
This is all a bit rambly isn't it. TVMan definitely knows his stuff by the way - it's obvious to me.
What else? If you really are interested in TV, watch lots and lots of TV and start getting your head around the broadcaster commissioning remits, freely available. Oh yes, and the Unit List does do some very good guides - there is one particularly well written one about 'How to be a good TV runner' which is exactly right.