I think it's because (and I have witnessed this in the ED sticky) if there is too much negativity then the society, already a home for vulnerable users mostly still in the middle of the illness (with the odd recovered/not relapsing person) can become a very dark bleak circle-jerk and it's hard to climb out once this happens.
Also some of us (including, by which I mean probably mostly, myself) are somewhat consciously aware that they are thinking 'wrong' and doing things 'wrong' which is holding them back in life, making them unhappy etc. but have not found out why so do them anyway. Other people (often the ones recovered or at a high point) give good advice about it.
For example it is absolutely true I have been asking the same question about eating cake or going to the gym
since June 2011. See my post below.
I think the forum should be free for everyone,
especially those who are most vulnerable. But it is nice to see the positive posts too.
Hope you're OK
Thanks, Deyesy. I'm going to have to give some context to explain this.
I was Riku before Smash, for 3 years. I spent the first 18 months mostly on the Eating Disorder recovery thread, and for help on general social anxiety. Then I started using it for advice on chatting to girls, then my relationship…then found the Manosphere and PUAs which set me off an obsessive thread-loop. There's a continues theme of me using this forum as a crutch to avoid work (pathologically, as in get extensions/mitigating circumstances etc.) and any sort of life skill.
Around the time of my break-up I became obviously unhappy by and started pissing TSR off for little kicks.
Samba is somewhat right to yell at me for some of the stuff I do e.g. on Chat; Red Pill and even BB Misc ideology is triggering to MH sufferers. The BB approach to fitness and diet, 'aesthetics' etc., is absolutely triggering to ED sufferers. Some of it is misogynistic because of the time I've spent reading PUAs, my parent's divorce, my breakup and so on. I'm not very trusting of reships.
I'd say I've got anhedonia in my anxiety disorder. I enjoy TV and stuff, but still have little faith in where life is going, if these thought processes continue. I haven't figured out why I think this way, although I think part of the problem is I am even making these posts-ironically!
I'll be seeing NHS IAPT Step 4 Psychologies next year, the letter came through the post today saying I am definitely on the waiting list
I don't know why CBT has failed me because I'm sure I'm a prime candidate for it! Perhaps I';m not using it properly.
I'm also going to write one of those FutureMe letters now, I'll be worried if this is still happening in a year.
Thank you for being kind towards me