Do the dead have rights?

I would just like to ask all you saying absolute control what if a person died and didn't want to donate their organs but their heart could save a little boys life say? Is it not more moral to save the child's life then abide by the wishes of a dead person?

Yes. Personally I don't think necrophilia should be illegal as long as the corpse gave consent for their body to be used that way while they were alive, kind of like in a will. And of course precautions should be took in case of disease. It's not like it's hurting anyone or denying anyone else their rights. I'd happily donate my body to a necrophiliac and even give them permission to cut it up if they want. Dead bodies aren't something I put much value on. I would also gladly accept a corpse for those purposes.

Sorry what? 'You would glady accept a corpse for those purposes'?

Posted from TSR Mobile

No. It is not. I'm going to sound soulless saying this, but if the boy is in such a terrible condition that only this heart could save him, he probably couldn't survive anyway. Of course, if it was a boy close to me I'd take the heart- I'm a terrible hypocrite and not afraid to admit it.

I'm not saying only one heart can save him but with that attitude that 'someone else will doanate' might as well means no one does.

True enough. but there are people who donate, so that argument is flawed. As it happens I intend to donate- I'm not going to care what happens after I die. But for people who do care, it could well be a big deal, and knowing their wishes will likely not be respected could be very distressing to them at the end of their life. Is that not immoral also?

The argument is that it shouldn't be up to everyone else. I also feel that if you need to help someone then they are dead their wishes shouldn't matter over that of a living person. Call it autaritarian utilitarianism if you want but that is my opinion.

Nah, I couldn't give a **** about dead people's so-called 'rights'. It's not a person anymore, it's a bag of rotting meat at that point.

I'm a non-exclusive necrophiliac which means I like corpses, but also living persons.

I see the point- yes, if someone who is going to die can be saved by an organ from a dead person, then I'd say it is human to sympathise with the dying, not the dead. But I feel that peoples wishes must be respected, and if it is judged that taking the organs of a dead person despite their wishes is justified then I'd say that's the start of a slippery slope.

I would just like to ask all you saying absolute control what if a person died and didn't want to donate their organs but their heart could save a little boys life say? Is it not more moral to save the child's life then abide by the wishes of a dead person?

No, my views might change however, I do not think I want my organs donated (they are in tip top shape, I eat well, I do not drink, I do not smoke or do drugs). Not for any reasons other than you are not allowed to control who the organs go to and I do not want my organs going to save a member of the general public who are utter filth through and through.

Fair enough... is this something you tried and liked or always knew?

It must have been scary realising this fact unless this just feels naturally normal for you?

I can't express how pathetic that sounds.

Not sure. I can't trace necrophilia back to childhood like I can with all my other paraphilias and thought it might be the result of a reaction formation to my other fantasy which are very sick, as a means of justifying or making them not necessary.

Or it could be that I just never looked at corpses until around fourteen or fifteen so never knew until then. I saw them in media and then looked for the real thing, which is easy to find.

It wasn't scary, but I did feel messed up and tried to stop. Now I have just accepted it for what it is and be as open as I can, I am quite fearful of people's reactions though.

I just do not want to donate my organs to a member of the general public, one of those overwrought vermin that is ruled by emotion not reason. As for your 'oh but what if it could help a small child', overly sentimental crap. I do not care about children, most of them are a bunch of snotty little ****s who should be back working in the mines, no organs for them no thank you.

Awful troll btw. You just lost all believability.