The Student Room Group

The Pedo Next Door (channel 4 tonight at 9)

image.jpg

So a pedo is set to out himself tonight on tv.
Never happened before.
What are your thoughts on this.
Should he be jailed or dead?
Should he be left to have illicit thoughts about kids?
For me prevention is better than cure so death penalty it should be but i know some will disagree.
What do you think

Scroll to see replies

Reply 1
I think the NHS should offer psychiatric support for those who are suffering from sexual attraction to children, have not committed a crime, and wish to tackle their problem.
Original post by matthewduncan
image.jpg
For me prevention is better than cure so death penalty it should be but i know some will disagree.


Sometimes i wonder if the evolution of our species is going backwards.
Reply 3
Channel 4 should stick to comedy shows. It's what they did best. Sick of the documentaries they show.


Posted from TSR Mobile
Technically he has committed no crime and he may even have a point about more support perhaps making a difference. And as for the OP suggesting the death penalty, you cannot condemn a man to death for the thoughts he thinks.
Reply 5
He has not committed a crime so should not be punished at all. He should be offered help by the NHS, people should be tolerent of him (not going to happen though) and he should be left to live a normal life.
It's car crash TV, no better than Big Brother, University Challenge, I'm A Celeb, or Gogglebox.

Stop talking about it.
The sad thing is, this man's life will probably be in danger once he outs himself to the world. And if he has indeed not committed any crimes against a child then that is a complete injustice. It's pretty obvious that there is not enough if at all any support for those with sexual thoughts towards children to come forward and seek help...and no wonder they don't when people like OP think they should be killed regardless of if they have committed a crime.

Sometimes people make me sick, and no it's not the paedophile who has not committed a crime that makes me sick (though his thoughts do), it's the people who won't allow help to reach them because their heads are too small to see how it could actually make a difference and prevent future sexual crimes against children.
Lmao "prevention is better than the cure so off with his head".
Trashy TV at it's best.
Original post by SophieSmall
The sad thing is, this man's life will probably be in danger once he outs himself to the world. And if he has indeed not committed any crimes against a child then that is a complete injustice. It's pretty obvious that there is not enough if at all any support for those with sexual thoughts towards children to come forward and seek help...and no wonder they don't when people like OP think they should be killed regardless of if they have committed a crime.

Sometimes people make me sick, and no it's not the paedophile who has not committed a crime that makes me sick (though his thoughts do), it's the people who won't allow help to reach them because their heads are too small to see how it could actually make a difference and prevent future sexual crimes against children.


The reason why i think they should be killed is because its cheaper than life imprisonment and we are currently in tough economic times. Thats the only other option for people like them.
People like that CANNOT be fully rehabilitated.
They are scum.
Original post by matthewduncan
The reason why i think they should be killed is because its cheaper than life imprisonment and we are currently in tough economic times. Thats the only other option for people like them.
People like that CANNOT be fully rehabilitated.
They are scum.


Do you have any evidence for that?

And so what if it's cheaper, it could be cheaper to leave you to die rather than treat you if you became ill but that won't happen because we are a civilised country.
Original post by SophieSmall
Do you have any evidence for that?

And so what if it's cheaper, it could be cheaper to leave you to die rather than treat you if you became ill but that won't happen because we are a civilised country.


Its common knowledge.
And theres nothing civilised about letting such sick people like that roam our streets.
These people are the scum of the earth who make peoples lives hell
Original post by matthewduncan
Its common knowledge.
And theres nothing civilised about letting such sick people like that roam our streets.
These people are the scum of the earth who make peoples lives hell


So you have no evidence then. Didn't think so, thank you for confirming.
This is clearly a mental illness. I don't know why everyone is so behind with this. No one wakes up and chooses to give themselves a life sentence, it's obviously a compulsion they can't control. Prevention is to get people the help they need before it is too late.

Posted from TSR Mobile
Original post by SophieSmall
So you have no evidence then. Didn't think so, thank you for confirming.


There is no cure to paedophilia.Google is your friend.
Original post by matthewduncan
Its common knowledge.
And theres nothing civilised about letting such sick people like that roam our streets.
These people are the scum of the earth who make peoples lives hell


Imo there's a huge difference between a Paedophile and a child molester. A Paedophile is just someone with a mental illness (I'm sure there are some who would argue it's a sexual orientation but I'm not going to discuss that). They think about things which other people (and possibly they themselves) find disturbing, to say the least. But punishing them through prison or death penalty is pointless. You want to give everyone who has once thought about murdering people or stealing something the death penalty too, while you're at it? It's your actions which define you, not your thoughts. And they'd be far less likely to act on their disgusting fantasies if society decided to help them through therapy etc. rather than drive them underground. There's nothing more dangerous than a group of people who all share sick fantasies. They would (and probably do) encourage each other.

I think child molesters should be separated from society because they are clearly a danger. I also think there needs to be punishment given to those who support the disgusting child pornography industry, because it contributes towards the suffering of children and there needs to be a deterrent.

But yeah, I totally get where you're coming from because I used to have a similar opinion when I was younger. Over the last few years I've tried to think about things from other people's perspectives more generally, though. These people didn't choose to be paedophiles, and undoubtedly there are a lot of people out there who share the opinion that 'all pedos should die'. Pretty much all of them live with a secret which the know if it got out, everyone would hate them and want them dead, possibly and probably including some friends and family. That's not going to help matters, because it will often lead to depression etc., I'm sure, and that'll make it more likely they'll actually do something awful. I do encourage you to think about it, at least.
At least he's admitted that he has a problem, and by doing it on TV he's going to be raising awareness of these sorts of problems. He shouldn't be punished, he hasn't actually hurt anybody. If anything,we should be offering him help - he's trying to do something about his problem, most people like that aren't.

I think that sometimes people forget that pedophilia has been around for ages, it's just over the past few decades that it's really even bought into the limelight. It'd be wrong to punish the one man admitting he has a problem, when there are thousands of child molesters out there who've committed terrible crimes, yet still aren't being caught.
Original post by Wahrheit
Imo there's a huge difference between a Paedophile and a child molester. A Paedophile is just someone with a mental illness (I'm sure there are some who would argue it's a sexual orientation but I'm not going to discuss that). They think about things which other people (and possibly they themselves) find disturbing, to say the least. But punishing them through prison or death penalty is pointless. You want to give everyone who has once thought about murdering people or stealing something the death penalty too, while you're at it? It's your actions which define you, not your thoughts. And they'd be far less likely to act on their disgusting fantasies if society decided to help them through therapy etc. rather than drive them underground. There's nothing more dangerous than a group of people who all share sick fantasies. They would (and probably do) encourage each other.

I think child molesters should be separated from society because they are clearly a danger. I also think there needs to be punishment given to those who support the disgusting child pornography industry, because it contributes towards the suffering of children and there needs to be a deterrent.

But yeah, I totally get where you're coming from because I used to have a similar opinion when I was younger. Over the last few years I've tried to think about things from other people's perspectives more generally, though. These people didn't choose to be paedophiles, and undoubtedly there are a lot of people out there who share the opinion that 'all pedos should die'. Pretty much all of them live with a secret which the know if it got out, everyone would hate them and want them dead, possibly and probably including some friends and family. That's not going to help matters, because it will often lead to depression etc., I'm sure, and that'll make it more likely they'll actually do something awful. I do encourage you to think about it, at least.


It's also interesting to note that not all child molesters are paedophiles.
Original post by SophieSmall
It's also interesting to note that not all child molesters are paedophiles.


Very true.

Quick Reply

Latest