The Student Room Group

Physiotherapy or Chiropractor?

Hi! I am very interested in the human body and helping others and I guess that's why I have an interest for those fields. However, I never really got a grasp on what the difference is between the two. I am very interested in treating sports injuries in particular and working with sports teams. Which would be a better fit for me? Also, which field has higher salaries and growth rate? I was also thinking of doing med school and specializing in Sports Medicine, but that's too long and risky, and I am already 24 years old.

Thanks.
Physiotherapy is largely based on evidence based medicine. Chiropractic is alternative medicine. While evidence suggests that chiropractic care can be helpful for low back pain, that's about it - and there is a large degree of 'quackery' in chiropractic, such as 'diagnosing' nutritional imbalances through muscle testing (applied kinesiology, which has nothing to do with kinesiology).

If you're interested in helping people, both can be rewarding. Physiotherapists can work in hospitals, clinics, etc. Chiropractors work for themselves or with other alternative medicine practitioners. If you're thinking about med school at all, PT is much closer allied to mainstream medicine than chiropractic.

I was a massage therapist, and was exposed to lots of chiropractic practices. Weird pseudoscience in a lot of alternative med led me to go back to school, and now I'm studying actual science (biology then bioinformatics) - so I'm biased but experienced. I'm in the US, but the above should be true in the UK as well.

If you're looking to work with sports teams that travel internationally, it may help to know that physical therapy is mainstream and recognized internationally, whereas chiropractic isn't always.
Reply 2
Original post by Oedipus_Regex
Physiotherapy is largely based on evidence based medicine. Chiropractic is alternative medicine. While evidence suggests that chiropractic care can be helpful for low back pain, that's about it - and there is a large degree of 'quackery' in chiropractic, such as 'diagnosing' nutritional imbalances through muscle testing (applied kinesiology, which has nothing to do with kinesiology).

If you're interested in helping people, both can be rewarding. Physiotherapists can work in hospitals, clinics, etc. Chiropractors work for themselves or with other alternative medicine practitioners. If you're thinking about med school at all, PT is much closer allied to mainstream medicine than chiropractic.

I was a massage therapist, and was exposed to lots of chiropractic practices. Weird pseudoscience in a lot of alternative med led me to go back to school, and now I'm studying actual science (biology then bioinformatics) - so I'm biased but experienced. I'm in the US, but the above should be true in the UK as well.

If you're looking to work with sports teams that travel internationally, it may help to know that physical therapy is mainstream and recognized internationally, whereas chiropractic isn't always.

Thanks very much. That was really helpful. I have been researching chiropractic over the past few days and the evidence seems to suggest exactly what you said. I guess chiropractic is more related to acupuncture and Chinese alternative medicine techniques as opposed to evidence based. Do you happen to know what the pay is like for both fields? Physical therapy seems to be similar everywhere at around 70k. But I have seen huge variations in Chiropractor, somewhere from 50k to 120k and I was unsure what the pay is like for chiropractors...
The pay for chiropractors would be what you make in your own business, as opposed to a pay band in the NHS or at a private clinic/hospital somewhere.

So, if you want to own your own business and work for yourself, and are a good enough salesperson and marketer to make that happen, then you could do that as a chiropractor or physical therapist. (Not sure if PTs can work independently in UK, they can in most US states w/out referral from GP). But if you don't want to own your own business, then chiropractic would not be the wisest decision.
Reply 4
Original post by Oedipus_Regex
The pay for chiropractors would be what you make in your own business, as opposed to a pay band in the NHS or at a private clinic/hospital somewhere.

So, if you want to own your own business and work for yourself, and are a good enough salesperson and marketer to make that happen, then you could do that as a chiropractor or physical therapist. (Not sure if PTs can work independently in UK, they can in most US states w/out referral from GP). But if you don't want to own your own business, then chiropractic would not be the wisest decision.

I see. Ok thanks very much. I live in Toronto, Canada as well btw, but I might opt to stay in England because I am interested in working within the football (soccer to us) sector...
Original post by sherifd
Hi! I am very interested in the human body and helping others and I guess that's why I have an interest for those fields. However, I never really got a grasp on what the difference is between the two. I am very interested in treating sports injuries in particular and working with sports teams. Which would be a better fit for me? Also, which field has higher salaries and growth rate? I was also thinking of doing med school and specializing in Sports Medicine, but that's too long and risky, and I am already 24 years old.

Thanks.


Hello,

If it is sports you are interested in, we would recommend choosing the initial training programme you are most excited by. At the AECC, we train chiropractors and offer specialist pathways into sports, paediatrics or veterinary.

Having spoken with many of our graduates who go into sports, they all work as part of a multi-disciplinary healthcare team now which often includes physiotherapists and medical doctors. We actually offer a placement at AFC Bournemouth for our final year students who want a career in sports.

So I would encourage you look around at chiropractic and physiotherapy courses and see some of the teaching facilities available. Our MChiro course is five years, but has two entry points depending on previous qualifications so you may only study for four years. There are fantastic and rewarding career opportunities available in these fields. Ulrik, one of graduates is currently the team chiropractor for Leicester Tigers Rugby, and Matt (another grad) is the team chiropractor for Williams-Mercedes F1 team.

If you want to know more about The AECC or some advice on the profession please contact: [email protected] or visit our website.

Quick Reply

Latest

Trending

Trending