The Student Room Group

Any guys identify as feminists on here?

Scroll to see replies

Reply 60
Original post by DiddyDec
I haven't assumed anything. Don't we teach sex ed and consent in schools?


Personally I was never taught about consent.
Original post by kiki37
I agree with everything that you said apart from the part about not fighting men's battles too. Men should be able to identify as feminists too and fight with us.


I meant more along the lines of men saying 'Well if you care so much about equality, why aren't YOU fighting for ME to have this, this and this', which I've encountered a few times. I totally agree that men can identify and ally with feminists and we can fight together - but the together bit is important! :smile:
Original post by kiki37
Personally I was never taught about consent.


It seems education is the problem. I was most certainly taught at school.
Depends on what kind of feminism.

I have no issue with the textbook definition of feminism, it’s fundamental cores and values of equal rights are not something I disagree with and I wholeheartedly support, however.. I don’t subscribe to the textbook definition of feminism, I feel like that is an outdated description of what feminism is. Feminism has evolved from the original grass roots and is not the static movement a lot of people try to make it out to be and this outdated textbook definition is almost being used as a shield to hide behind to push other theories and agendas.

What I look at and disagree with (do not identify or subscribe to) is the theories that the 21st century feminism presents, what I would define as feminism today is a world view that involves the description of society as a patriarchal construct where men are uniformly privileged for their benefit and women are oppressed/subordinated for men’s benefit, this is going to be the common definition that you will find in women studies courses and gender studies courses and all of these academic feminist pieces in this time period. Unfortunately this type of feminism while subscribing to the patriarchy theory also subscribes to things such as male privilege, female oppression, rape culture, systematic gendered violence against women and all of these theories that don’t really fit the evidence, all of those things are taught in gender studies and women studies and are the basis of scholarly and academic feminism and too a large degree political feminism. I feel like these courses and theories that are being taught brainwash people and are very toxic, they promote and create a very 'us and them' mentality, while also creating tension and discord between the sexes.

Now like I said many people still buy into the dictionary definition of feminism and by that definition of feminism I would absolutely be a feminist but I can’t ignore all of this other sociological and theoretical movement that is really consuming and becoming the new identity of feminism.
(edited 9 years ago)
Original post by kiki37
That is literally what a feminist is.


But then they say it's impossible for men to ever be the ones disadvantaged by inequality
Reply 65
Original post by maddersla
I meant more along the lines of men saying 'Well if you care so much about equality, why aren't YOU fighting for ME to have this, this and this', which I've encountered a few times. I totally agree that men can identify and ally with feminists and we can fight together - but the together bit is important! :smile:


Yeah definitely!
Original post by maddersla
There still isn't full equality in the UK and in the West.
Yep & that applies to both sexes/genders.

Women are still denied abortions in Ireland. This has left many to die in agony from complications, or forced to travel to the UK for a procedure that should be a basic right - and before anyone says 'Oh blah blah sluts using it as contraception', I'm also talking women who need an abortion for a medical reason.
Agree for medical purposes.

It's fine for a newspaper to splash pictures of boobs all over the third page, but wouldn't have been fine for me to breastfeed my daughter in a cafe. :lolwut:
So the 1st page is covering the boobs? What don't women also complain about this?

Ched Evans. Regardless of whether you think he is guilty or innocent, a man is convicted of rape, and after less than three years in prison, is deemed to have 'served his time', and freed to encourage his family, friends and fans to hound his victim into hiding. He isn't arrested for harrassment - he's continuously excused for it.
Was he not free to do this whilst inside?

On a more trivial, but still meaningful, matter - it's starting from such a young age, with some of the world's biggest corporations. It's difficult to find any Big Hero Six merch featuring the female main characters, either on their own or alongside the men. Same for Power Rangers, Fireman Sam etc. Kids don't see male or female, they want something with all the characters on - but we're presumed to believe that women don't belong as superheroes and firefighters. It's a man's job. Similarly, little boys can't get anything with Peppa Pig on, or Frozen - it's unfair on both sides, and there's absolutely no good reason for it.
Stereotypes eh? Or just good business sense. Frozen - Olaf/snowman. Also female Thor, Ghostbusters, MacGyver (& Starbuck!) - if there is £$ to be made, the demand will be filled.
BTW did you see the violence in Tangled, she is quite the saucepan hitter; tying him for a beating.
Until these issues and more are fixed, we can't really call ourselves egalitarians. An egalitarian aim would be to maintain the balance of equality - feminists need to create that equality, before we can maintain it. If you see areas in which men are discriminated against, there is nothing stopping you from starting your own movement to try and correct it, but why should feminists fight your battles too?

Egalitarian - Affirming, promoting, or characterized by belief in equal political, economic, social, and civil rights for all people.
- of, relating to, or upholding the doctrine of the equality of mankind and the desirability of political, social, and economic equality.

It is a belief & we are upholding - so we can call ourselves egalitarian.
Why should we leave it to feminism, they've had >100 years & look where we are? Modern day feminism's tactics are similar to 100 years ago! See prev post & my viewpoint in bold.
(middle left woman is also about free bleeding)
Original post by maddersla
I meant more along the lines of men saying 'Well if you care so much about equality, why aren't YOU fighting for ME to have this, this and this', which I've encountered a few times. I totally agree that men can identify and ally with feminists and we can fight together - but the together bit is important! :smile:

Did I understand correctly?
This is like HeForShe - yes both sexes have problems, but we invite men to come & fix ours. If that is true, then you will see/hear more about boys/men problems.

In a 2nd talk (critiqued by Thunderf00t) Watson said something like women should know when they are being abused & men should know how to stop (themselves). Never that DV is genderless.
(edited 9 years ago)
Original post by kiki37
I only made an account on here a few days ago and I'm a bit shocked at how some guys just seem so sexist. It seems so subtle and common on here, sometimes not so subtle with one forum I read being called something like "what is wrong with girls". It's actually kind of upset me a bit, I had more faith in our generation.


You realise both men and women say this sort of thing all the time about the opposite gender? Or are you a social justice shill from gawker trying to make women look pathetic by calling them victims. I have a higher view of women than that.
Original post by So Instinct
Depends on what kind of feminism.

I have no issue with the textbook definition of feminism, it’s fundamental cores and values of equal rights are not something I disagree with and I wholeheartedly support, however.. I don’t subscribe to the textbook definition of feminism, I feel like that is an outdated description of what feminism is. Feminism has evolved from the original grass roots and is not the static movement a lot of people try to make it out to be and this outdated textbook definition is almost being used as a shield to hide behind to push other theories and agendas.

What I look at and disagree with (do not identify or subscribe to) is the theories that the 21st century feminism presents, what I would define as feminism today is a world view that involves the description of society as a patriarchal construct where men are uniformly privileged for their benefit and women are oppressed/subordinated for men’s benefit, this is going to be the common definition that you will find in women studies courses and gender studies courses and all of these academic feminist pieces in this time period. Unfortunately this type of feminism while subscribing to the patriarchy theory also subscribes to things such as male privilege, female oppression, rape culture, systematic gendered violence against women and all of these theories that don’t really fit the evidence, all of those things are taught in gender studies and women studies and are the basis of scholarly and academic feminism and too a large degree political feminism. I feel like these courses and theories that are being taught brainwash people and are very toxic, they promote and create a very 'us and them' mentality, while also creating tension and discord between the sexes.

Now like I said many people still buy into the dictionary definition of feminism and by that definition of feminism I would absolutely be a feminist but I can’t ignore all of this other sociological and theoretical movement that is really consuming and becoming the new identity of feminism.


Christina Hoff Sommers coined two definitions of feminism in the 1990s: Equity feminism and gender feminism. Equity feminism focuses on the legal rights and equal treatment of women as autonomous individuals. Gender feminism focuses on identity politics and the portrayal of women as a victimized group. The latter strongly characterizes modern (third wave) feminism: a gynocentric political movement more focused on victim politics and the 'gender wars' than real, honest equity. As such, it is awash with radicalism, gender bias, hypocrisy, and ludicrous double standards.

You and I would fall into the 'equity feminist' category, it seems.
I'm not a feminist. I'm what I am. I have got many choices to be brainwashed. But feminism? It just failed.

Posted from TSR Mobile
Reply 70
I support equality* between the sexes. If that is feminism then I am a feminist.

*Gigantic question on what exactly equality between the sexes might entail but I will leave that for now.
Posted from TSR Mobile

No.If you criticise sexist men you just get called a white knight and a beta male.
Original post by kiki37
Feminism MOSTLY works towards equality for women because it's needed most. Societies have been patriarchal for years, it's only been some decades that women have had some kind of power. And think of all the female-related issues worldwide. Forced marriage, FGM etc. And rape culture which is EVERYWHERE! Females literally have to take safety precautions with everything, it's ridiculous. Of course I'm aware this may never change because there will always be psychos in the world. But at the same time, feminists care for men's rights too, and the rights of transgenders. There's different sectors of feminism, this is the sector I belong to. And I know a lot of others do.


In bold is what I disagree with.

If you look at any statistics, in the western world men have it worse. Women have problems too, and I actively want to help women with things like not getting raped. However, advising women how to avoid the crime of rape is wrong, because apparently you're blaming her. I think this is appalling. This rhetoric will actively increase the number of rapes per year. The only reason I can think why feminism goes along with this line is that the more women get raped, the more funding feminist agencies will get. That's the nly rational reason for believing such a thing.

Rape culture in white western society is bull****. Sure, in some places such as Rotheram racial minorities has had a rape culture (which feminism doesn't acknowledge because it doesn't fit in with their absurd "white male" theory, which is frankly disgusting) But mainstream British culture, which abhors male on female rape more than any other crime is a rape culture?? No.

Feminism doesn't care about male rights. They often camp outside male rights meetings and try to destroy them. They have produced a narrative over the last 40 years that men are always oppressors, and women are always victims.

Transgendered people are a threat to feminism. They prove that, despite all the socialisation in the world to be a female, if you have the components in your mind to be a male, socialisation doesn't affect it and you will literally mutilate yourself to become the gender you are in your mind. This directly refutes the feminist notion that if male and female attributes are forced upon people in society, and that differences in biology don't affect behaviour.
Reply 73
Original post by skd1996
Feminism is equality of both genders.


Yes it is, however, it just stimulates misogyny
Original post by capitalismstinks
I'm a feminist, yes.

I think women are capable of more than aping male behaviours, so i don't support the modern feminist movement, which basically reduces women to second rate testosterone wannabes.

True feminists think women have their own path to take.


What's wrong with aping male behaviours if we want though? I've always found myself on the male end of the spectrum, wanting a career, having no interest in children, having mainly male friends, etc

I don't see why people have an issue with that...
Reply 76
Original post by Snagprophet
You realise both men and women say this sort of thing all the time about the opposite gender? Or are you a social justice shill from gawker trying to make women look pathetic by calling them victims. I have a higher view of women than that.


I have noticed much more sexism towards women on the student room. I'm not trying to make women look like victims at all! From this post, I was hoping to discover that there's actual educated guys on here!
Reply 77
Original post by scrotgrot
But then they say it's impossible for men to ever be the ones disadvantaged by inequality


Who's "they"? As a feminist I personally believe that men can be disadvantaged
Reply 78
Original post by So Instinct
Depends on what kind of feminism.

I have no issue with the textbook definition of feminism, it’s fundamental cores and values of equal rights are not something I disagree with and I wholeheartedly support, however.. I don’t subscribe to the textbook definition of feminism, I feel like that is an outdated description of what feminism is. Feminism has evolved from the original grass roots and is not the static movement a lot of people try to make it out to be and this outdated textbook definition is almost being used as a shield to hide behind to push other theories and agendas.

What I look at and disagree with (do not identify or subscribe to) is the theories that the 21st century feminism presents, what I would define as feminism today is a world view that involves the description of society as a patriarchal construct where men are uniformly privileged for their benefit and women are oppressed/subordinated for men’s benefit, this is going to be the common definition that you will find in women studies courses and gender studies courses and all of these academic feminist pieces in this time period. Unfortunately this type of feminism while subscribing to the patriarchy theory also subscribes to things such as male privilege, female oppression, rape culture, systematic gendered violence against women and all of these theories that don’t really fit the evidence, all of those things are taught in gender studies and women studies and are the basis of scholarly and academic feminism and too a large degree political feminism. I feel like these courses and theories that are being taught brainwash people and are very toxic, they promote and create a very 'us and them' mentality, while also creating tension and discord between the sexes.

Now like I said many people still buy into the dictionary definition of feminism and by that definition of feminism I would absolutely be a feminist but I can’t ignore all of this other sociological and theoretical movement that is really consuming and becoming the new identity of feminism.


I am against what you said too. Feminism should be bringing men and women together, not against each other
Reply 79
Original post by skunkboy
I'm not a feminist. I'm what I am. I have got many choices to be brainwashed. But feminism? It just failed.

Posted from TSR Mobile


Okay, some people aren't comfortable to call themselves feminists because of the radicals. That's fine. Simply put, do you believe women are equal to you?

Quick Reply

Latest

Trending

Trending