i'm at risk of sounding shallow here, but if I had a choice (obvs I wouldn't judge someone on this) i'd choose someone who isn't sporty or exercising regularly, because they'd probably be more like me. i'd like a guy I can eat pizza and watch tv with, dating an overly fit and healthy person would probably just make me self conscious and feel worse about my own body hahaha
and i'm personally not attracted to muscles, but don't mind whether the person is skinny or has some chub