The Student Room Group

Would you kill a Dog to save a Cat ?

Would you kill a Dog to save a Cat ? ....

Cats are so much better , clearly the superior pets :P

Scroll to see replies

Reply 1
... no :lolwut:
No. If it were the other way round I'd consider...
Original post by Lyrical Prodigy
No. If it were the other way round I'd consider...


:ditto:
Nooooo, unless the dog was like half dead and the cat was as super cute.

Also killing with your own bare hands, like if there was a button maybe haha XD

(I'd never injure an animal on purpose - especially to exchange it for another!)
I find cats are far more vicious than dogs...
The dog would need saving...

Besides, everyone knows cats are evil. Why do almost all villains in TV shows have cats sitting on their laps?!

Original post by Lyrical Prodigy
No. If it were the other way round I'd consider...


This. :smile:
this is a question for @MylittlePlusle
Reply 8
Depends, like if it was the dog that was going to kill the cat then maybe, but only as a last resort. Other then that no.
Reply 9
Original post by cpoper
Would you kill a Dog to save a Cat ? ....

Cats are so much better , clearly the superior pets :P


I'd have to conduct an investigation to see which is most worth saving; the healthiest one would be the one that I would save.

I'd need to ask them questions about their age, weights, medical history, and smoking status. The fittest gets to survive.
Original post by Lyrical Prodigy
No. If it were the other way round I'd consider...


This.
First world problem questions like OP makes me want to take my brains out.

cats have 9 lives so it'll be okay
Original post by cpoper
Would you kill a Dog to save a Cat ? ....

Cats are so much better , clearly the superior pets :P


Assuming that if I didn't kill the dog the cat wouldn't be killed by me then obviously I wouldn't kill the Dog. One you are making an active decision to physically kill an animal. The other one is an animal dying, where you have no active participation in it's death.
No, i will happily kill a rat or a snake to save either.
No way
Can't imagine I could ever kill an animal. Even if it was to save another animal. It goes completely against my morals & it would upset me so much.
I'd rather kill you to save a dog and a cat :colone:
Reply 18
Cats are devil spawn
Original post by missaxo
this is a question for @MylittlePlusle


Oh my gosh... =( I don't now what I would do.. I love furbabies that go meow so much but furbabies that go woof are cue too...

I guess I would have to kill the furbaby that goes woof...

Quick Reply

Latest