The Student Room Group

Would you be happier if people stopped following Islam?

Scroll to see replies

We should all learn about Islam. In history class and nowhere else.
Original post by mikeoxlong000
I doubt you've ever studied Islam, so you're unqualified to make such an accusatory statement. Although I have heard that Christianity do have slavery in the Bible, but that was of the context it was written in.

And there's nothing Islamic about ISIS (apart from the name). If you truly believe the opposite, then I worry for you. It only plays into their hands, as they slaughter Muslims and non-Muslims alike.


A pathetic attempt to shut down debate.

Slavery is mentioned many times in Allah's last and final message to mankind, space forbids an examination of each example. But just as an exemplar he tells his followers to be KIND to slaves three times (Quran 4:36, 9:60, 24:58).

Why does he do that if he doesn't approve of slavery? Isn't setting them free the highest form of kindness? You would think if he was trying to set the world onto the right path he would make it abundantly clear, without equivocation that all slaves should be free then, and there.

Why doesn't he? Until and unless you can answer this, my point stands. Slavery is condoned in Islam.

As for the Islamic State what do they do that isn't in the Quran or Hadith?
Original post by JezWeCan!
A pathetic attempt to shut down debate.

Slavery is mentioned many times in Allah's last and final message to mankind, space forbids an examination of each example. But just as an exemplar he tells his followers to be KIND to slaves three times (Quran 4:36, 9:60, 24:58).

Why does he do that if he doesn't approve of slavery? Isn't setting them free the highest form of kindness? You would think if he was trying to set the world onto the right path he would make it abundantly clear, without equivocation that all slaves should be free then, and there.

Why doesn't he? Until and unless you can answer this, my point stands. Slavery is condoned in Islam.

As for the Islamic State what do they do that isn't in the Quran or Hadith?


pathetic response. Slavery was part of human society at that point, not just muslims haha. Furthermore many of these slaves had no family to go back to and would suffer if they were set free due to lack of housing and money. In a way, it was beneficial for the slave, as they were treated kindly, given housing etc. However, there were many cases in which the Prophet PBUH actually set free slaves, if you actually took the time to research. You also underestimate that the Quran is telling Muslims to be kind to slaves, unlike many other slave owners which treated them like animals. In essence, slavery is not condoned, it is acknowledged as something humans used to do in that time frame, if slaves were able to take care of themselves, muslims would free them out of courtesy unlike other slave owners (Americans for example), the Quran does say to be kind to them, which you pointed out yourself. The Quran also says to respect the law of the land you live in so thus slavery is banned in Islam in accordance with today's laws.


Wow, ISIS commit murder, a deadly sin in any religion, especially in Islam, killing muslims and non-mulsims alike. If you think ISIS are following the Quran and Hadith, you are truly lost.
Reply 43
Original post by mikeoxlong000
pathetic response. Slavery was part of human society at that point, not just muslims haha. Furthermore many of these slaves had no family to go back to and would suffer if they were set free due to lack of housing and money. In a way, it was beneficial for the slave, as they were treated kindly, given housing etc. However, there were many cases in which the Prophet PBUH actually set free slaves, if you actually took the time to research. You also underestimate that the Quran is telling Muslims to be kind to slaves, unlike many other slave owners which treated them like animals. In essence, slavery is not condoned, it is acknowledged as something humans used to do in that time frame, if slaves were able to take care of themselves, muslims would free them out of courtesy unlike other slave owners (Americans for example), the Quran does say to be kind to them, which you pointed out yourself. The Quran also says to respect the law of the land you live in so thus slavery is banned in Islam in accordance with today's laws.


Wow, ISIS commit murder, a deadly sin in any religion, especially in Islam, killing muslims and non-mulsims alike. If you think ISIS are following the Quran and Hadith, you are truly lost.


Do you ever get tired of just completely ignoring facts and defending someone who you know deep down was a pretty awful person who did pretty awful things?
Original post by KingBradly
Do you ever get tired of just completely ignoring facts and defending someone who you know deep down was a pretty awful person who did pretty awful things?


You're blinded by your own bias and unjustified personal hatred. Jumping on the 'I hate Islam' bandwagon bcos the media portrayed it. Just remember hatred for something means you are forever bound to it. Spread love instead. And also respect the views shared by over 1.6 billion people worldwide. There must be something about it if the number of converts are increasing annually.
Reply 45
Original post by mikeoxlong000
You're blinded by your own bias and unjustified personal hatred. Jumping on the 'I hate Islam' bandwagon bcos the media portrayed it. Just remember hatred for something means you are forever bound to it. Spread love instead. And also respect the views shared by over 1.6 billion people worldwide. There must be something about it if the number of converts are increasing annually.


The media loves Islam, and goes out of it's way to deflect any blame that could be directed by it. The BBC even calls says that IS are only "so-called" Islamic. This website has been banning people for just posting up unpleasant quotes from the Qu'ran and Muslim opinion polls. Islam's very tagline "the religion of peace" is just a neologism invented by politicians after 9/11. Take a look at the latest Trump scandal: When 300,000 people petition for the borders to be closed after the Paris attacks, the news doesn't say a word. But even the supposedly impartial Reuters was reporting about the petition to block Trump from the UK, even when it only had 30,000 votes.

Oh no, all I have to do to understand how poisonous Islam is is to read the Quran or a few of the Hadiths.
Original post by KingBradly
The media loves Islam, and goes out of it's way to deflect any blame that could be directed by it. The BBC even calls says that IS are only "so-called" Islamic. This website has been banning people for just posting up unpleasant quotes from the Qu'ran and Muslim opinion polls. Islam's very tagline "the religion of peace" is just a neologism invented by politicians after 9/11. Take a look at the latest Trump scandal: When 300,000 people petition for the borders to be closed after the Paris attacks, the news doesn't say a word. But even the supposedly impartial Reuters was reporting about the petition to block Trump from the UK, even when it only had 30,000 votes.

Oh no, all I have to do to understand how poisonous Islam is is to read the Quran or a few of the Hadiths.


Yes I agree, UK media (bar The Sun) and UK in general is very tolerant and liberal with multiculturalism. American media if you have seen is by far the opposite. And I'm against banning Trump from the UK, its freedom of speech which i'm all for, if you were wondering.

Have you actually read the Quran and not cherry picked quotes to support your own biased view? There are 291 verses in the Quran which promote compassion (which incorporates love and kindness and mercy and forgiveness to others). I advise you read it one day with an open mindset, as in general, if you go looking for hate, you will inevitably find hate, but if you go looking for love, you will find love. A mindset which we should all strive to adopt.
Reply 47
Yes I would
Reply 48
Original post by mikeoxlong000

Have you actually read the Quran and not cherry picked quotes to support your own biased view? There are 291 verses in the Quran which promote compassion (which incorporates love and kindness and mercy and forgiveness to others). I advise you read it one day with an open mindset, as in general, if you go looking for hate, you will inevitably find hate, but if you go looking for love, you will find love. A mindset which we should all strive to adopt.


There are 291 verses in the Qu'ran and over 100 call followers to fight for Islam. Hardly "cherry picking".
Original post by KingBradly
There are 291 verses in the Qu'ran and over 100 call followers to fight for Islam. Hardly "cherry picking".


there are more than 291 verses in the Quran... I just said that is the number of verses containing compassion, ironically more than those which call for fight, yet you choose to ignore. Not all of the verses calling for fight mean violence, it can mean striving for excellence such as academia and fighting for a just cause like the poor and the weak. Violence is only permitted if you are attacked first and your life is in danger. Other than that... :
“Whoever kills a person [unjustly]…it is as though he has killed all mankind. And whoever saves a life, it is as though he had saved all mankind.” (Qur’an, 5:32)
Reply 50
Original post by mikeoxlong000
there are more than 291 verses in the Quran... I just said that is the number of verses containing compassion, ironically more than those which call for fight, yet you choose to ignore. Not all of the verses calling for fight mean violence, it can mean striving for excellence such as academia and fighting for a just cause like the poor and the weak. Violence is only permitted if you are attacked first and your life is in danger. Other than that... :
“Whoever kills a person [unjustly]…it is as though he has killed all mankind. And whoever saves a life, it is as though he had saved all mankind.” (Qur’an, 5:32)


You can cherry pick nice verses like that, but in the end I'm never going to find much affection for a text which tells people to strike off the heads and fingers of non-believers.
Original post by mikeoxlong000
there are more than 291 verses in the Quran... I just said that is the number of verses containing compassion, ironically more than those which call for fight, yet you choose to ignore. Not all of the verses calling for fight mean violence, it can mean striving for excellence such as academia and fighting for a just cause like the poor and the weak. Violence is only permitted if you are attacked first and your life is in danger. Other than that... :
“Whoever kills a person [unjustly]…it is as though he has killed all mankind. And whoever saves a life, it is as though he had saved all mankind.” (Qur’an, 5:32)


Ahhhh, the 73493537th time someone has misquoted verse 5.32 and quoted it entirely out of context on TSR in the last few weeks. Did you do that deliberately, or do you not genuinely not know what it says? Let's look at what it actually says, shall we?

"Because of that, We decreed upon the Children of Israel that whoever kills a soul unless for a soul or for corruption [done] in the land - it is as if he had slain mankind entirely. And whoever saves one - it is as if he had saved mankind entirely. And our messengers had certainly come to them with clear proofs. Then indeed many of them, [even] after that, throughout the land, were transgressors.

Indeed, the penalty for those who wage war against Allah and His Messenger and strive upon earth [to cause] corruption is none but that they be killed or crucified or that their hands and feet be cut off from opposite sides or that they be exiled from the land. That is for them a disgrace in this world; and for them in the Hereafter is a great punishment"

http://quran.com/5/32-33

Hmmmmmm, not quite as lovely and peaceful as you're pretending, is it? Notice the past tense, 'we decreed upon the children of Israel' - this is citing Jewish scripture. And Muslims complain about critics of Islam taking verses out of context! Freaking LOL.
Reply 52
Religion is a personal choice and every person has the right to believe in what ever they want :smile:
Original post by AprilLG
Religion is a personal choice and every person has the right to believe in what ever they want :smile:


such a childish misconception of 'rights'
Reply 54
Original post by BaconandSauce
such a childish misconception of 'rights'


You have the RIGHT to express your own opinion :smile:
Original post by KingBradly
You can cherry pick nice verses like that, but in the end I'm never going to find much affection for a text which tells people to strike off the heads and fingers of non-believers.


yet again you read without the context which is just as important as the actual verse. The verses calling for such was after the Battle of Badr, when a Meccan army of 1000 travelled to Medina to kill every Muslim, man, woman and child. The muslim army numbered at around 100. Thus those verses are taken in the context of actual wartime when your life is threatened. The 'non believers' was directed at the Meccans who came to slaughter. Islam is not a pacifistic religion, its basic message is that if your life is in danger and someone is trying to kill you, you don't just sit back and let them, which is hardly immoral, its called self defence in today's laws.

Would be nice if you read with context next time, makes it a whole lot easier to understand things in general.
Original post by Achaea
Ahhhh, the 73493537th time someone has misquoted verse 5.32 and quoted it entirely out of context on TSR in the last few weeks. Did you do that deliberately, or do you not genuinely not know what it says? Let's look at what it actually says, shall we?

"Because of that, We decreed upon the Children of Israel that whoever kills a soul unless for a soul or for corruption [done] in the land - it is as if he had slain mankind entirely. And whoever saves one - it is as if he had saved mankind entirely. And our messengers had certainly come to them with clear proofs. Then indeed many of them, [even] after that, throughout the land, were transgressors.

Indeed, the penalty for those who wage war against Allah and His Messenger and strive upon earth [to cause] corruption is none but that they be killed or crucified or that their hands and feet be cut off from opposite sides or that they be exiled from the land. That is for them a disgrace in this world; and for them in the Hereafter is a great punishment"

http://quran.com/5/32-33

Hmmmmmm, not quite as lovely and peaceful as you're pretending, is it? Notice the past tense, 'we decreed upon the children of Israel' - this is citing Jewish scripture. And Muslims complain about critics of Islam taking verses out of context! Freaking LOL.


If it was placed in the Quran then it is meant for muslims as well lol. Islam and Judaism are Abrahamic religions after all, teachings are very similar. You also seem to forget that if murder in cold blood was condoned by Islam, why do an incredibly small portion of the 1.6 billion population do it? (I believe the figure is close to 0.0001%, check my facts).

The irony of you taking the last verse out of context LOL. That verse is directed at the Meccans who came to slaughter the minority Muslims in Medina. Which became the Battle of Badr. Islam is not a pacifistic religion, one of its main basis is if you life is in danger and you're about to be killed, you don't just sit back and let it happen, this can be more commonly known in our laws as 'Self Defence'. Murder is only prohibited if you yourself are about to be murdered. Western Laws agree.

Other than that, the above verse still stands, if you kill one innocent, it is as if you have killed all of humanity :smile:
Original post by mikeoxlong000
pathetic response. Slavery was part of human society at that point, not just muslims haha. Furthermore many of these slaves had no family to go back to and would suffer if they were set free due to lack of housing and money. In a way, it was beneficial for the slave, as they were treated kindly, given housing etc. However, there were many cases in which the Prophet PBUH actually set free slaves, if you actually took the time to research. You also underestimate that the Quran is telling Muslims to be kind to slaves, unlike many other slave owners which treated them like animals. In essence, slavery is not condoned, it is acknowledged as something humans used to do in that time frame, if slaves were able to take care of themselves, muslims would free them out of courtesy unlike other slave owners (Americans for example), the Quran does say to be kind to them, which you pointed out yourself. The Quran also says to respect the law of the land you live in so thus slavery is banned in Islam in accordance with today's laws.


Wow, ISIS commit murder, a deadly sin in any religion, especially in Islam, killing muslims and non-mulsims alike. If you think ISIS are following the Quran and Hadith, you are truly lost.


You unwittingly refute your own argument in the sentence bolded.

You yourself admit that here the Quran in telling Muslims to be "kind" to slaves (and not treat them like animals). Wouldn't the "kindest" thing be to give them freedom?

Why didn't your God say, simply and categorically, "FREE ALL YOUR SLAVES. NOW AND AT ONCE. ENSLAVE NO MORE HUMAN BEINGS EVER AGAIN. IT IS EVIL AND WRONG TO POSSESS ANOTHER PERSON"?

If he (sorry Mohammed) had, the world would have been a much better place over the centuries.

You still haven't shown me where the Islamic State goes against the Quran and Hadith. Could you please?
(edited 8 years ago)
Original post by mikeoxlong000
The verses calling for such was after the Battle of Badr,


Where does it say this in the quran

and if this verse was only for the battle then doesn't that mean the other one is as well
Original post by mikeoxlong000
If it was placed in the Quran then it is meant for muslims as well lol.


The line is clear

'we ordained for the children of 'Israel'

this is for the Jews not for Muslims otherwise it would say so.

Unless that is you are going to argue the quran isn't clear in this regard

Quick Reply

Latest

Trending

Trending