The Student Room Group

Investment Banker/Trader/Accountant

Scroll to see replies

Original post by IAmNero
Dudee, my dad is an investment banker, he works in risk and control, and has done for 30 years, he doesn't have a single degre or diploma, in fact, none of his department do!


Your dad isn't an investment banker. An investment banker specifically works in the investment banking division, likewise traders aren't investment bankers either.

Risk and control are middle office support roles for the trading desks, they basically make sure traders aren't reckless.

It was 100% possible to get a job at an IB without a degree 30 years ago, not anymore.
Reply 61
Original post by Princepieman
Your dad isn't an investment banker. An investment banker specifically works in the investment banking division, likewise traders aren't investment bankers either.

Risk and control are middle office support roles for the trading desks, they basically make sure traders aren't reckless.

It was 100% possible to get a job at an IB without a degree 30 years ago, not anymore.


He worked in the FO for many years before doing that.

The company hires people without degrees all the time!

But as you mention 30 years ago vs now.

Risk and Control was a very loose term I used
Original post by IAmNero
Dudee, my dad is an investment banker, he works in risk and control, and has done for 30 years, he doesn't have a single degre or diploma, in fact, none of his department do!


Whilst I do believe you that there are guys who have worked in IB for 30 years who don't have a degree, this isn't necessary helpful advice for the 17 year old student who wishes to take this route.


30 years ago you could get loads of professional jobs without a degree and learn as you studied, now a degree is basically used to filter out candidates they don't think will be able to learn. I think it's a load of shite and in many cases for non-specialist jobs (scientist, computer scientist, mathematician) you could probably be trained up to be good enough for an entry level position in 6 months as opposed to taking the degree, but you have to play the game and not having a degree will screw OP so hard.
Reply 63
Original post by Mahmoud X
Whilst I do believe you that there are guys who have worked in IB for 30 years who don't have a degree, this isn't necessary helpful advice for the 17 year old student who wishes to take this route.
30 years ago you could get loads of professional jobs without a degree and learn as you studied, now a degree is basically used to filter out candidates they don't think will be able to learn. I think it's a load of shite and in many cases for non-specialist jobs (scientist, computer scientist, mathematician) you could probably be trained up to be good enough for an entry level position in 6 months as opposed to taking the degree, but you have to play the game and not having a degree will screw OP so hard.


An apprentischip into finance would mean they would be qualified work in the financial industry!

But point taken.
Reply 64
Original post by Princepieman
Yes

It'd be alright, not a full on target but it does well enough year on year.


What i am trying to find out, and I am doing so in a very roundabout way is whether I would be better off studying at Bristol, a place that is renowned for Engineering, but is only a Semi-Target, or studying it Warwick, a place that is not renowned for Mechanical Engineering, but is a target university?

Another thing that I have been told may be a good idea is that if I don't get into IB, many large companies (the example used was BP) have trading floors, so this may be an alternative path into finance.

Also, unrelated, but you seem to be on every single forum on TSR, how can you manage!
Original post by jakepds
What i am trying to find out, and I am doing so in a very roundabout way is whether I would be better off studying at Bristol, a place that is renowned for Engineering, but is only a Semi-Target, or studying it Warwick, a place that is not renowned for Mechanical Engineering, but is a target university?

Another thing that I have been told may be a good idea is that if I don't get into IB, many large companies (the example used was BP) have trading floors, so this may be an alternative path into finance.

Also, unrelated, but you seem to be on every single forum on TSR, how can you manage!


Target wins every day of the week. Banks don't care whether your engineering degree is 'renouned', they just focus on recruiting from their core set of schools.

Yes, BP, EDF, Maersk etc, mostly oil or energy or commodities companies will have physical trading desks.

I get bored, plus there's a huge amount of misinformation surrounding IB on these forums.
Reply 66
Original post by Princepieman
Target wins every day of the week. Banks don't care whether your engineering degree is 'renouned', they just focus on recruiting from their core set of schools.

Yes, BP, EDF, Maersk etc, mostly oil or energy or commodities companies will have physical trading desks.

I get bored, plus there's a huge amount of misinformation surrounding IB on these forums.


That seems surprising to me. Obviously I have to see about where I like, but the more I think about the more I want to go to Cambridge.

On top of doing really well, what can I do to make myself stand out. I have got on to a head start course at Bristol and have thought of maybe writing a report on something engineering based as this may be a talking point.

I am the house captain at my school, but I don't imagine that counts for a whole lot.
Original post by jakepds
That seems surprising to me. Obviously I have to see about where I like, but the more I think about the more I want to go to Cambridge.

On top of doing really well, what can I do to make myself stand out. I have got on to a head start course at Bristol and have thought of maybe writing a report on something engineering based as this may be a talking point.

I am the house captain at my school, but I don't imagine that counts for a whole lot.


Your extra curriculars are the most important thing. focus on them. House captain is pretty good since it shows leadership skills but also do a sport or volunteering or both. Of course, do extra curriculars that interest you, not just for IB.
(edited 8 years ago)
Reply 68
Original post by Trapz99
Your extra curriculars are the most important thing. focus on them. House captain is pretty good since it shows leadership skills but also do a sport or volunteering or both. Of course, do extra curriculars that interest you, not just for IB.


Oh, I didn't add sport. I play tennis relatively frequently, and to a good level, however I have never really been bothered to play competitively, so don't have much to show for my tennis. I am on the school team and have the tour jacket to show for that, though!

I have done 6 months of volunteering (probably close to about 80 hours at Cancer Research)

I have done DofE Bronze, which I hear is the most irrelevant thing going.

Engineering Society

Maths Mentor

Little things like that, are they helpful?

Cheers
Original post by jakepds
Oh, I didn't add sport. I play tennis relatively frequently, and to a good level, however I have never really been bothered to play competitively, so don't have much to show for my tennis. I am on the school team and have the tour jacket to show for that, though!

I have done 6 months of volunteering (probably close to about 80 hours at Cancer Research)

I have done DofE Bronze, which I hear is the most irrelevant thing going.

Engineering Society

Maths Mentor

Little things like that, are they helpful?

Cheers

Yep those are good extra curriculars. Just keep doing them and join the finance society when you are at university.
Reply 70
Original post by Trapz99
Yep those are good extra curriculars. Just keep doing them and join the finance society when you are at university.


Does the finance society involve putting money up for investment. If so, how much may be made.

Please anyone with experience let me know!
Original post by gr8wizard10
source.. could you elaborate on this?

i've been in there tower hill office for a summer internship and haven't met anyone without a degree in their FO divisions


The only people I ever saw at SG in London who had or were completing apprenticeships was within CSR - never met anyone in an FO role without a degree. In fact, a lot had Masters.
(edited 8 years ago)
Reply 72
Would you be at a disadvantage doing a degree at Durham because of it's geography, you can't easily pop down to London for an interview like may be more possible at somewhere like Cambridge, Bristol etc?
Original post by jakepds
Would you be at a disadvantage doing a degree at Durham because of it's geography, you can't easily pop down to London for an interview like may be more possible at somewhere like Cambridge, Bristol etc?


Haven't you just answered your own question haha ?
Reply 74
Original post by Daniel9998
Haven't you just answered your own question haha ?


I don't know if that is a consideration that has to be made though, will you have to travel to interviews during your term time?
Original post by jakepds
I don't know if that is a consideration that has to be made though, will you have to travel to interviews during your term time?


Yeh I would consider it but it wouldn't be too big of a deal imo if you dont mind travelling back and forth to London a couple of times. The distance is the last thing you should worry about tbh
Original post by jakepds
Would you be at a disadvantage doing a degree at Durham because of it's geography, you can't easily pop down to London for an interview like may be more possible at somewhere like Cambridge, Bristol etc?


I wouldn't say so. Banks do phone interviews for spring weeks (and the first rounds of summer internships/grad entry). On top of that, any face to face interview travel cost will be reimbursed (or sometimes paid for).

Posted from TSR Mobile
Reply 77
The reason I ask is because I was talking with someone the other day and I was explaining to him how I really enjoy maths and physics and he suggested doing Physics a a degree choice. Upon looking, Durham looks like the place to be for physics and so I was wondering about the technicalities, but I suppose it is the last of my worries.

I guess physics stands up as much as mech eng would in an interview?
Original post by jakepds
The reason I ask is because I was talking with someone the other day and I was explaining to him how I really enjoy maths and physics and he suggested doing Physics a a degree choice. Upon looking, Durham looks like the place to be for physics and so I was wondering about the technicalities, but I suppose it is the last of my worries.

I guess physics stands up as much as mech eng would in an interview?


Your degree becomes moot once you hit interview, it's all on you as a person at that point.

Posted from TSR Mobile
Reply 79
Original post by Princepieman
Your degree becomes moot once you hit interview, it's all on you as a person at that point.

Posted from TSR Mobile


How about before interview, is a physics degree as good as a mech eng

Quick Reply

Latest

Trending

Trending