You are Here: Home

# sin 2X = Sin X??

Announcements Posted on
TSR's new app is coming! Sign up here to try it first >> 17-10-2016
1. So the question is, "solve for the following in the interval shown:
Sin 2X = Sin X (0<X<360) (< = less than or equal)

Now I was able to bring this down to SinX = 1/2 , leaving me with 60 degrees and 300 degrees for values of X, but the mark scheme is showing two more values?? Can someone explain this please?
2. (Original post by ludd-sama)
So the question is, "solve for the following in the interval shown:
Sin 2X = Sin X (0<X<360) (< = less than or equal)

Now I was able to bring this down to SinX = 1/2 , leaving me with 60 degrees and 300 degrees for values of X, but the mark scheme is showing two more values?? Can someone explain this please?
Sub X = 0

i.e. where 2X = X

3. You mean sinx=sin(2x) thus sinx(2cosx-1)=0 thus sinx=0 or cosx=1/2 (not sin as you wrote)
the other two values are from sinx=0
4. Sin2x = SinX
2SinXCosX - Sinx = 0
Sinx(2CosX-1) = 0
Sinx=0 CosX= 1/2

I am pretty sure you are able to do it like that..
5. Ha you beat me to it...
6. (Original post by Vesniep)
You mean sinx=sin(2x) thus sinx(2cosx-1)=0 thus sinx=0 or cosx=1/2 (not sin as you wrote)
the other two values are from sinx=0
yh I meant cos X sorry, but yh thanks I see exactly where I went wrong now, it didn't occur to me that I could make the equation equal 0.
7. (Original post by Indigo.Brownhall)
Sin2x = SinX
2SinXCosX - Sinx = 0
Sinx(2CosX-1) = 0
Sinx=0 CosX= 1/2

I am pretty sure you are able to do it like that..
yep, really helpful, thanks a lot
8. I actually have one more question if anyone would be willing to help.

"3cosX - sin(X/2) - 1 = 0" (0<X<720)

I was able to factorise it down to (9cosX - 1)(2cosX-1) leaving me with The values of X being: 60, 83.6, 276.4, 300, 420, 660, 636.4 and 443.6.
The issue is, the mark scheme only contained 4 of these (60, 300, 443.6, 636.4). Is there a reason why only half of the answers I got were accepted, I don't think there was a fault in my working out?
9. (Original post by ludd-sama)
I actually have one more question if anyone would be willing to help.

"3cosX - sin(X/2) - 1 = 0" (0<X<720)

I was able to factorise it down to (9cosX - 1)(2cosX-1) leaving me with The values of X being: 60, 83.6, 276.4, 300, 420, 660, 636.4 and 443.6.
The issue is, the mark scheme only contained 4 of these (60, 300, 443.6, 636.4). Is there a reason why only half of the answers I got were accepted, I don't think there was a fault in my working out?
You can check each of your answers by putting them into the equation and testing which work.
E.g. 83.6 doesn't work.
If you show your working someone can help yo find your error

Posted from TSR Mobile
10. (Original post by gdunne42)
You can check each of your answers by putting them into the equation and testing which work.
E.g. 83.6 doesn't work.
If you show your working someone can help yo find your error

Posted from TSR Mobile
83.6 doesn't work (bear in mind this is rounded to 3dp)? when I put in the arccos of 1/9 I get 83.6. as for the working..
I made the equation equal sin(X/2) and plugged in the relevant half angle formula for sin(X/2), then squared both sides, leaving me with a quadratic which I factorised to (9cosX -1)(2cosX -1) which I'm sure is right. obviously this left me with cosX=1/9 and cosX=1/2, and then I just used my calculator and CAST method to get out all the values for X (which all checked out on the calculator)
11. (Original post by ludd-sama)
83.6 doesn't work (bear in mind this is rounded to 3dp)? when I put in the arccos of 1/9 I get 83.6. as for the working..
I made the equation equal sin(X/2) and plugged in the relevant half angle formula for sin(X/2), then squared both sides, leaving me with a quadratic which I factorised to (9cosX -1)(2cosX -1) which I'm sure is right. obviously this left me with cosX=1/9 and cosX=1/2, and then I just used my calculator and CAST method to get out all the values for X (which all checked out on the calculator)
3cos(83.6)-sin(83.6/2)-1 does not equal anything close to 0

Squaring both sides of an equation can easily introduce solutions that are not valid for the original equation.

Consider
Cos(X)=0.5 (2 solutions 0-360)
Cos^2(X)=0.25
So cos(X)=root(0.25) = plus or minus 0.5 (4 solutions 0-360)

Using the double angle formula to rewrite 3cos(X) in terms of sin(X/2) is an alternative approach

Posted from TSR Mobile
12. (Original post by Indigo.Brownhall)
Ha you beat me to it...
unlucky brownhole
13. I think you're dividing by sinx or dividing by trig terms and therefore losing answers. You always want to factorise and not just divide. What I mean is for example if you have
.
You should factor out the cosx and not just divide by cosx as you will lie answers.
14. (Original post by Alexion)
Sub X = 0

i.e. where 2X = X

sin isn't injective. That's not the only solution.
15. (Original post by morgan8002)
sin isn't injective. That's not the only solution.
I know it's not the only solution - OP was just missing the zero/2pi solution from his answer.

## Register

Thanks for posting! You just need to create an account in order to submit the post
1. this can't be left blank
2. this can't be left blank
3. this can't be left blank

6 characters or longer with both numbers and letters is safer

4. this can't be left empty
1. Oops, you need to agree to our Ts&Cs to register

Updated: May 28, 2016
TSR Support Team

We have a brilliant team of more than 60 Support Team members looking after discussions on The Student Room, helping to make it a fun, safe and useful place to hang out.

This forum is supported by:
Today on TSR

### How does exam reform affect you?

From GCSE to A level, it's all changing

### Who would you like to thank?

Poll
Useful resources
Study resources

The Student Room, Get Revising and Marked by Teachers are trading names of The Student Room Group Ltd.

Register Number: 04666380 (England and Wales), VAT No. 806 8067 22 Registered Office: International House, Queens Road, Brighton, BN1 3XE

Reputation gems: You get these gems as you gain rep from other members for making good contributions and giving helpful advice.