The Student Room Group

Should i buy this laptop?

(edited 7 years ago)
Original post by I feel myself
https://m.johnlewis.com/hp-envy-13-d...d-hd/p/2477228

How capable is it doing high performance stuff etc



I'm using a desktop, removed the "https//:m." and replaced with "http://www." and yet still got a 404 error.
What's the Make/Model and so on for the Laptop? Link the desktop URL if possible. May well be me being thick though.

Elaborate on "high performance stuff" too, would help a lot
(edited 7 years ago)


I have an ENVY but I bought mine in Jan 2014
Original post by fr0sr_
I'm using a desktop, removed the "https//:m." and replaced with "http://www." and yet still got a 404 error.
What's the Make/Model and so on for the Laptop? Link the desktop URL if possible. May well be me being thick though.

Elaborate on "high performance stuff" too, would help a lot


Is it better now? I will be using it for photoshop etc :smile:
https://m.johnlewis.com/hp-envy-13-d008na-laptop-intel-core-i3-4gb-ram-128gb-13-3-inch-and-mcafee-livesafe-2016/p/236168507

Assuming its this.

No, its bad, i3, 4gb RAM and no dedicated graphics card. You should be aiming for an i5, 6-8gb ram and a dedicated graphics card (950 series if you're looking to play newer games).
Original post by I feel myself
Is it better now? I will be using it for photoshop etc :smile:


Better. :smile:
I'll take a look!


As someone who works for JL I can affirm it's a pretty powerful machine. High SSD storage, 8gb ram is the average for the entire laptop market, and ofc the i7 is a good choice.

The unit itself is a bit weird with the hinge on the lid; if you sit with the laptop on your lap it will be kinda painful after a while as the bar digs in :tongue:

I personally went for a higher-spec model of the Spectre x360, but it depends on what you want out of a machine :smile:

Feel free to ask for any more info

Posted from TSR Mobile
Original post by physicsphysics91
https://m.johnlewis.com/hp-envy-13-d008na-laptop-intel-core-i3-4gb-ram-128gb-13-3-inch-and-mcafee-livesafe-2016/p/236168507

Assuming its this.

No, its bad, i3, 4gb RAM and no dedicated graphics card. You should be aiming for an i5, 6-8gb ram and a dedicated graphics card (950 series if you're looking to play newer games).

I've edited the link now, is it working now?
It depends on what you plan on doing. Anything can run photoshop. Just depends how well.

Spend more get more. I can run photoshop on a 5 year old PC I got for under 200GBP. Doesnt mean it runs it well, or rendering time is good, but it still runs well enough to be able to everything fine. Just slower.



An I7 is a bit much imo, I mean my gaming rig which can run most of the newest games at high with +60fps has a mid tier CPU.


Also, an I7 depends on a per model basis. I7 is not always better than I5, or i3. The newest i3 would probably be better than an older i7 sort of thing
(edited 7 years ago)
Original post by I feel myself
I've edited the link now, is it working now?


It doesnt seem to have a dedicated graphics card sadly. Depends what you need it for.
Reply 10
The 500 GB SSD is good, but the graphics and processor is well below what you can usually expect for that price. It is pretty light though and the screen is high res.

Overall, for 'high perfomance stuff' this laptop is not great and also overpriced.

I personally use the lenovo y500 with the sli graphics card add-on and it runs most high end games at medium-high absolutely fine.

The lenovo y50 is the newer version of the one I have and has a better graphics card, processor + more ram.

Here's a link:
https://www.amazon.co.uk/Lenovo-15-6-inch-Notebook-i7-4720HQ-External/dp/B015Q2941M

It's also slightly cheaper than the envy you're wanting.

Just saw you want to use it for photoshop. I currently do freelance graphic design on the side and use photoshop and illustrator on my laptop and it works smoothly, so I can only imagine it will be even better on the y50.
(edited 7 years ago)
Original post by isaisababy
The 500 GB SSD is good, but the graphics and processor is well below what you can usually expect for that price. It is pretty light though and the screen is high res.

Overall, for 'high perfomance stuff' this laptop is not great and also overpriced.

I personally use the lenovo y500 with the sli graphics card add-on and it runs most high end games at medium-high absolutely fine.

The lenovo y50 is the newer version of the one I have and has a better graphics card, processor + more ram.

Here's a link:
https://www.amazon.co.uk/Lenovo-15-6-inch-Notebook-i7-4720HQ-External/dp/B015Q2941M

It's also slightly cheaper than the envy you're wanting.

Thanks for the help
Original post by physicsphysics91
It doesnt seem to have a dedicated graphics card sadly. Depends what you need it for.


Is it find though as i wont be using it for gaming?
Original post by I feel myself
Is it find though as i wont be using it for gaming?




What will you be doing on it though? I mean my 150£ chromebook can run everything from watching movies to playing small indie games, and photo editing fine (with gimp). Does it make it a good choice if youre buying it primarily for editing? No. But it will work.


Decide on a budget and usage. An amount you feel comortable with spending. There is no perfect overall laptop. Choose a laptop that works for you.


If your priority editing video/photos/gaming, then prioritise having a Graphics card.

If you just want to watch movies and do word stuff on it, with the occasional photoshop, then stick to an I5 or something with a integrated graphics card


From what I've seen, it is a reasonably good machine. 8GB RAM is expected for most modern day laptops. An Intel Core i7 is usually a good choice; this one seems to be dual core rather than quad core though (but should still be powerful enough for the vast majority of things).

It is quite expensive though, at almost £900, and has no dedicated graphics card. Something that must be borne in mind if you wanted to play games on it. (Though from my experience, most integrated graphics cards are OK.)

Chances are, what is really pushing up the price on that laptop is the SSD (SSD's are quite expensive). Do you need the extra performance that an SSD offers? If so, then it is a good investment. If not, then mechanical hard drives are cheaper.

I must also mention, that at a 13.3 inch screen size, it's more suited to portability as well. I doubt it'd be noticeable that much between a 13 inch screen and a 15 inch screen (I've always used 15 inch screens) but I wouldn't personally want to go for a screen size any smaller.

Overall, it is a good laptop, though depending on what you need/require, you might be able to find something a bit cheaper.
Original post by Brokensteps
What will you be doing on it though? I mean my 150£ chromebook can run everything from watching movies to playing small indie games, and photo editing fine (with gimp). Does it make it a good choice if youre buying it primarily for editing? No. But it will work.


Decide on a budget and usage. An amount you feel comortable with spending. There is no perfect overall laptop. Choose a laptop that works for you.


If your priority editing video/photos/gaming, then prioritise having a Graphics card.

If you just want to watch movies and do word stuff on it, with the occasional photoshop, then stick to an I5 or something with a integrated graphics card


Will be using it for web design, mobile app making, and photoshop etc
The specs look dreadful. Waste of money.

Amazon has plenty of gaming laptops worth a look at.


"high performance stuff" is very vague

As some one who has built computers since the age of 10 (I am 21 now), I can advise you very well with computers.

Could you elaborate on what "high performance stuff" means ?
Original post by I feel myself
Will be using it for web design, mobile app making, and photoshop etc


https://www.reddit.com/r/SuggestALaptop/


I'd reccomend checking out these guys. They know a lot more than anyone on here. I would've offered to help but ive got an exam soon


Dont buy any laptop. Try and find one thats the best for you in the budget you have.

Really anything can run the stuff you've listed. Ive done app development on an AMD athlon x64 (a processor from 2003) not too long ago. Same with photoshop.

Choose an amount youre comfortable with spending right now. If you dont need the extra power then theres no need to get it. In a year or two when you kick off you'll probably have more money to spend, so by the time the medium preformance starts to get annoying you'll have the money to buy more.

Try and follow the format when you submit it onto there will you?

Quick Reply

Latest

Trending

Trending