You are Here: Home >< Maths

STEP I, II, III 1999 solutions

Announcements Posted on
TSR's new app is coming! Sign up here to try it first >> 17-10-2016
1. STEP I, Question 5

(Please someone check this, I'm not very confident, because I did last year)

Spoiler:
Show

(i) Triangle with x on the adjacent, x on the opposite, and h+R on the hypotenuse, implies , so .

(ii) h is small relative to h, so distance tends to , but (for obviously small ), so , so .

(iii) We draw some strange diagram... and then... !

, where is an angle ZOK, where K is a side of the earth, as well as that angle being the angle XZO. So two triangles are congruent, and the opposite is R, hypotenuse h+R and x the adjacent.

, and since h gets large compared to R, . Then, , so and .
2. STEP I 1999 Question 7

Could somebody verify the method used in the third part? It really would not hold up as any kind of a proof in my eyes. I did this one last year, too.

Spoiler:
Show
First part:

Substituting into the differential equation:

.

As required, it is satisfied.

Second part:
, so , and

, , so , . At x = 0, also , so . At the differential equation, also, . Equating the x terms, we get . So, . Thus, is a polynomial solution to the differential equation.

Third part:
If we let for , then we get the equivalent solutions . This holds because the initial conditions hold for the polynomial solution and for the trigonometric solution. Thus, they must equal.
3. (Original post by Aurel-Aqua)
STEP I 1999 Question 7

Could somebody verify the method used in the third part? It really would not hold up as any kind of a proof in my eyes. I did this one last year, too.
I think you need to show the initial conditions are satisfied, but it's otherwise OK (if a little indirect).

The following isn't really any different to what you wrote, but it feels a little bit better, somehow:

My version
By the first part, we know Y(x) = sin(3 arcsin x) is a solution to the DE, and we can see Y(0) = 0 and Y'(0) = 3. So this must equal our other solution and so

sin(3 arcsin x) = 3x - 4x^3.

Then for -1 <= x <= 1 we can write x = sin y to get

sin 3y = 3 sin y - 4 sin^3 y.

I don't think you'd lose more than 2 marks for what you did though (and that would basically be because of not checking the initial conditions).
4. STEP I 1999 Question 10

(Someone please verify that my assumption is correct).

Spoiler:
Show
Diagram: points A, P and B in one vertical line (A at the top), l being the length of AND, and showing is going up.
The spring can be assumed as two separate [equal-length] ones.

At equilibrium, , so .

We also know that and .

Equating the forces in the general case, . Also and . Thus,

. We know that the spring constant is the same for both parts , so:
and then
, where k is the spring constant, which clearly is SHM.

. From this, the period will only be dependent on the mass, and nothing else (since the spring constant is unique to the spring itself and its natural length, not deformed length).

5. (Original post by Aurel-Aqua)
STEP I, Question 5

(Please someone check this, I'm not very confident, because I did last year)

Spoiler:
Show

(i) Triangle with x on the adjacent, x on the opposite, and h+R on the hypotenuse, implies , so .

(ii) h is small relative to h, so distance tends to , but (for obviously small ), so , so .

(iii) We draw some strange diagram... and then... !

, where is an angle ZOK, where K is a side of the earth, as well as that angle being the angle XZO. So two triangles are congruent, and the opposite is R, hypotenuse h+R and x the adjacent.

, and since h gets large compared to R, . Then, , so and .
I think that's right, although I used cos instead of sin.

Spoiler:
Show

i)

ii) use the approximation and ignore h.

iii) , ignore R.
6. I don't see how you can assume the string to be the same as two separate equal length ones, when we're given there are two lengths a and b.
7. (Original post by DFranklin)
I don't see how you can assume the string to be the same as two separate equal length ones, when we're given there are two lengths a and b.
Oh, my mistake... I think I misread my working from long time ago.
8. STEP I 1999 Question 14

Spoiler:
Show

In the valid range, .
(i)

.
(ii) To win, first we have to calculate the probability of winning: .
(Note: two ways to get (2,1))

.

So,
.

Using the conditional probability rule, .
9. STEP I, Question 2

Spoiler:
Show

Therefore

Is a circle, centre the centroid.

Therefore if is smaller than the distance to the centroid the circle would have to have a negative radius
10. STEP II, Question 10
Spoiler:
Show
First part
Forming the basic equations:

Thus, .

Second part

For the last hit particle not to be hit by the one before that, the condition: (This means: final velocity of particle n must be less than the initial particle's (n+1) velocity, so there would be N-1 impacts), which, after factoring, gives:
.

. We also know that , , and so . Summing,
. Initial K.E. .

, as required.
11. STEP II, Question 13

Spoiler:
Show
Wlog our stick is of unit length and by symmetry we can choose the length of the shorter piece. Let

The probability that is

Since we're choosing from a uniform distribution, this probability is

This is the cumulative distribution. Therefore the probability density function is

The expected value will be

and the variance

12. STEP II, Question 13
Don't even quote me on this question, there is absolutely no guidance within it.
Spoiler:
Show

Ratios for positions and are and respectively.
Draw a diagram, and then you have a simple probability density:

.

So .
13. Heh. Different method, different answers. Not great
14. Simon: Surely you really want to have p(R < r) = 1 in the case where r=1?

Edit: I don't think you're taking into account that your uniform variable is on [0,1/2], not [0,1], (and so has density 2 instead of density 1).
15. (Original post by DFranklin)
Simon: Surely you really want to have p(R < r) = 1 in the case where r=1?
This is true.. Better check my logic again

Ah... spotted the problem. Not too bad to fix

Edit: Yeah, that was what I ascertained. Stupid mistake
16. STEP II, Question 14

Spoiler:
Show
Your tactic will essentially be "stop rolling if greater than a given number", this is because each result is independent on the previous ones, so you must take a decision based on what you have rolled. The probability of obtaining any of the scores in the "stop" range is the same (symmetry, relabelling, etc). Therefore, considering cases we have:

Stop after first:

Stop if larger than 2

Stop if larger than 3

Stop if larger than 4

Stop if larger than 5

Therefore we should stop if we get greater than 3. (or 4, I guess we should consider variances)
17. (Original post by squeezebox)
Ok, so heres my working:

I get the integral down to;

which becomes:

which is equal to ?
I think i got the same answer as yours
18. (Original post by lilman91)
The hare finishes 1.5hrs. This means she has travelled 2X in 1.5hrs.
So,
Substituting expression for V,
.
Solving the quadratic but since , .
So, finally .
I think you've forgotten to add on the half hour rest at each end, so we end up with:

And we end up with a somwhat neater final answer:
Spoiler:
Show

19. For paper III Q2. PDF attached.
Attached Images
20. STEP III 1999 Q2.pdf (267.8 KB, 910 views)
21. STEP III Question 13

I am not certain that this method is correct, so it would be very much appreciated if somebody were to follow my working and check I have not made any wrong assumptions.

Firstly,

so

ie expected proportion of cake.

Currents are randomly placed so the expected number of currents = 4 * 2/3 = 8/3

Now taking a proportion X of the cake gives probability X^4 that all 4 currents will be in that portion.

So taking a portion X and getting all 4 currents in that portion has pdf:

Hence,

and,

So finally

I have spent a whole day thinking about pdfs and probabilities and venn diagrams and integrals and have got about 100 wrong answers to this question, let alone a lot of messing about with excel formulas to convert rand() into the continuous random variable you want, so now my brain hurts! But, I think I finally understand how to do this question. If anybody has any comments, that would be great, and also if anybody could point me in the direction of similar questions to practice this, that would be good too, as I'm hoping that probability will be one of my specialist subjects in STEP. Now to attempt number 14...

Register

Thanks for posting! You just need to create an account in order to submit the post
1. this can't be left blank
2. this can't be left blank
3. this can't be left blank

6 characters or longer with both numbers and letters is safer

4. this can't be left empty
1. Oops, you need to agree to our Ts&Cs to register

Updated: December 4, 2015
TSR Support Team

We have a brilliant team of more than 60 Support Team members looking after discussions on The Student Room, helping to make it a fun, safe and useful place to hang out.

This forum is supported by:
Today on TSR

How does exam reform affect you?

From GCSE to A level, it's all changing

Who would you like to thank?

Poll
Useful resources
Study resources

The Student Room, Get Revising and Marked by Teachers are trading names of The Student Room Group Ltd.

Register Number: 04666380 (England and Wales), VAT No. 806 8067 22 Registered Office: International House, Queens Road, Brighton, BN1 3XE

Reputation gems: You get these gems as you gain rep from other members for making good contributions and giving helpful advice.