Join TSR
 
About Us | FAQs | Sign in
 
Advanced
Search

Join The Student Room Today

Be part of the UK's largest and fastest growing student community.

It's free to join and a lot of fun - Get inspired, express your ideas, interact and share

RSS  Discuss matters related to personal health and relationships in this forum. However, please keep it sensible and remember that people of all ages can view these forums. Remember, all advice is unprofessional.
Reply
 
Announcements   Posted By
 
Clarification of some H&R rules - Please read before posting   randdom
 
Old 20-07-2008: 20th July 2008 14:05 #1 
Anonymous Anonymous is offline
Anonymous user
User #1
Thread Starter
Anonymous has disabled reputation
Join Date: Nov 1999
Thumbs down Smear test -unfair age!
 
I've seen all these 'tell her' adverts about cervical cancer and read in so many magazines about young girls getting cervical cancer that's terminal when they couldve just had a smear and got it cleared up.

Im 18 and have been sexually active since I was 14 so I feel I should have one but the new age for smears is 25!

I'm becoming paranoid about it, can you ask for one from your GP?
Register to remove banners from posts.
Old 20-07-2008: 20th July 2008 15:57 #2 
Sallyjade Sallyjade is offline Female
Full Member
Sallyjade will become famous soon enough
Wales
Join Date: May 2008
Location: South Wales
Posts: 99
My Societies
Default Re: Smear test -unfair age!
 
Yes. It's just that you get called automatically when your 25.
It's suggested you have one 2 years after becoming sexually active. Of course the GP doesn't know when you become sexually active, you have to take action.
Old 20-07-2008: 20th July 2008 15:58 #3 
red_Rose's Avatar
red_Rose red_Rose is offline Female
Peer Of The TSR Realm
PS Helper
red_Rose has more reputation than sensered_Rose has more reputation than sensered_Rose has more reputation than sensered_Rose has more reputation than sensered_Rose has more reputation than sensered_Rose has more reputation than sensered_Rose has more reputation than sensered_Rose has more reputation than sensered_Rose has more reputation than sensered_Rose has more reputation than sensered_Rose has more reputation than sensered_Rose has more reputation than sense
Newcastle
Join Date: Jul 2006
Location: Newcastle
Posts: 1,967
My Societies
Default Re: Smear test -unfair age!
 
My mum had pre-cancerous cells before she was 25, luckily they were picked up but i feel i should be offered a smear before the age of 25 due to family history.
Old 20-07-2008: 20th July 2008 15:58 #4 
Spotty Dog's Avatar
Spotty Dog Spotty Dog is offline Female
Vengeful, Imperial Overlord of The Student Room
Spotty Dog has a reputation beyond reputeSpotty Dog has a reputation beyond reputeSpotty Dog has a reputation beyond reputeSpotty Dog has a reputation beyond reputeSpotty Dog has a reputation beyond reputeSpotty Dog has a reputation beyond reputeSpotty Dog has a reputation beyond reputeSpotty Dog has a reputation beyond reputeSpotty Dog has a reputation beyond reputeSpotty Dog has a reputation beyond reputeSpotty Dog has a reputation beyond repute
United Kingdom
Join Date: May 2008
Location: Kingston
Posts: 4,018
My Societies
Default Re: Smear test -unfair age!
 
You can request one yourself. You don't need to wait until you are 25.
 
Old 20-07-2008: 20th July 2008 16:00 #5 
atoms4peace's Avatar
atoms4peace atoms4peace is offline Female
Overlord in Training
atoms4peace has a spectacular aura aboutatoms4peace has a spectacular aura aboutatoms4peace has a spectacular aura about
United Kingdom
Join Date: Mar 2008
Location: London
Posts: 2,335
My Societies
Default Re: Smear test -unfair age!
 
Originally Posted by Anonymous
I've seen all these 'tell her' adverts about cervical cancer and read in so many magazines about young girls getting cervical cancer that's terminal when they couldve just had a smear and got it cleared up.

Im 18 and have been sexually active since I was 14 so I feel I should have one but the new age for smears is 25!

I'm becoming paranoid about it, can you ask for one from your GP?

nope.
 
Old 20-07-2008: 20th July 2008 16:28 #6 
Persipan Persipan is offline Female
Benevolent Member
Persipan has a brilliant futurePersipan has a brilliant futurePersipan has a brilliant futurePersipan has a brilliant futurePersipan has a brilliant futurePersipan has a brilliant futurePersipan has a brilliant futurePersipan has a brilliant futurePersipan has a brilliant future
Join Date: Jul 2008
Location: Exeter
Posts: 736
Default Re: Smear test -unfair age!
 

Explanation here.
Old 20-07-2008: 20th July 2008 17:18 #7 
-steph-'s Avatar
-steph- -steph- is offline Female
Exalted and Worshipped Member
-steph- is a jewel in the rough-steph- is a jewel in the rough-steph- is a jewel in the rough
Japan
Join Date: Jan 2007
Location: In the back yard.
Posts: 1,005
My Societies
Send a message via MSN to -steph-
Default Re: Smear test -unfair age!
 
I have thought about getting one in the next yr or so but hopefully my parents will not find out cause then i will be in some serious trouble.
Old 20-07-2008: 20th July 2008 17:20 #8 
Kabloomybuzz's Avatar
Kabloomybuzz Kabloomybuzz is offline Female
Peer Of The TSR Realm
Kabloomybuzz is just really niceKabloomybuzz is just really niceKabloomybuzz is just really niceKabloomybuzz is just really nice
England
Join Date: Sep 2007
Location: Derby UK
Posts: 1,466
Default Re: Smear test -unfair age!
 
Originally Posted by -steph-
I have thought about getting one in the next yr or so but hopefully my parents will not find out cause then i will be in some serious trouble.


Why will you be in troube for being careful with your health???
 
Old 20-07-2008: 20th July 2008 17:21 #9 
Sophi* Sophi* is offline Female
Full Member
Sophi* will become famous soon enough
England
Join Date: Jun 2008
Location: Somewhere Pretty
Posts: 93
My Societies
Default Re: Smear test -unfair age!
 
I'm 18 and I asked my doctor for one and she pretty much just laughed at me and was like.. wait till you're 25. I was not happy with that response at all, but she pretty much just made me feel stupid for asking :|
Old 20-07-2008: 20th July 2008 17:23 #10 
Lithium's Avatar
Lithium Lithium is offline Male
TSR Demigod
Lithium has more reputation than senseLithium has more reputation than senseLithium has more reputation than senseLithium has more reputation than senseLithium has more reputation than senseLithium has more reputation than senseLithium has more reputation than senseLithium has more reputation than senseLithium has more reputation than senseLithium has more reputation than senseLithium has more reputation than senseLithium has more reputation than sense
United States
Join Date: Apr 2004
Posts: 5,313
My Societies
Default Re: Smear test -unfair age!
 
Originally Posted by Anonymous
I've seen all these 'tell her' adverts about cervical cancer and read in so many magazines about young girls getting cervical cancer that's terminal when they couldve just had a smear and got it cleared up.

Im 18 and have been sexually active since I was 14 so I feel I should have one but the new age for smears is 25!

I'm becoming paranoid about it, can you ask for one from your GP?
cervical cancer has been correlated to early sexual activity. Of coruse, as usual, there is much debate. get one done and but your mind at ease.
 
Old 20-07-2008: 20th July 2008 17:31 #11 
galladriel's Avatar
galladriel galladriel is offline Female
Benevolent Member
galladriel will become famous soon enoughgalladriel will become famous soon enough
European Union
Join Date: Feb 2008
Location: West London
My Societies
Default Re: Smear test -unfair age!
 
Originally Posted by Sophi*
I'm 18 and I asked my doctor for one and she pretty much just laughed at me and was like.. wait till you're 25. I was not happy with that response at all, but she pretty much just made me feel stupid for asking :|

WHAT?????? In my country, doctors actually SCREAM if you are sexually active and haven't done a pap test no matter what's your age! I first went to get tested 3 years ago, when I was 22, but was sexually active since 19 -she looked at me with this very serious look in her eyes "don't do it again" style, and made me promise I would get tested once a year.

And all doctors here are like this, and mothers too.


Your doctor sounds like a bitch. Health is important and a gynaikologist should be much more sencitive than that.
She is supposed to be the one person you cn trust and tell everything. If she looks down on you and doesn't make you feel safe, change a doctor.
Old 20-07-2008: 20th July 2008 23:55 #12 
-steph-'s Avatar
-steph- -steph- is offline Female
Exalted and Worshipped Member
-steph- is a jewel in the rough-steph- is a jewel in the rough-steph- is a jewel in the rough
Japan
Join Date: Jan 2007
Location: In the back yard.
Posts: 1,005
My Societies
Send a message via MSN to -steph-
Default Re: Smear test -unfair age!
 
Originally Posted by Kabloomybuzz
Why will you be in troube for being careful with your health???

For being sexually active before marriage is a big no no in my family. Plus my parents see me as the innocent one.
Old 21-07-2008: 21st July 2008 08:14 #13 
Jillie Boe Jillie Boe is offline
Peer Of The TSR Realm
Jillie Boe has a spectacular aura aboutJillie Boe has a spectacular aura aboutJillie Boe has a spectacular aura about
England
Join Date: Aug 2006
Location: Somewhere
My Societies
Default Re: Smear test -unfair age!
 
Cancer runs in my friends family and she requested one, got to the Doctors and said she couldn't have one because she wasn't 25.

It is stupid, esp as Wales can have it before us.
Old 21-07-2008: 21st July 2008 10:54 #14 
*pink_sapphires*'s Avatar
*pink_sapphires* *pink_sapphires* is offline Female
Peer Of The TSR Realm
*pink_sapphires* has a reputation beyond repute*pink_sapphires* has a reputation beyond repute*pink_sapphires* has a reputation beyond repute*pink_sapphires* has a reputation beyond repute*pink_sapphires* has a reputation beyond repute*pink_sapphires* has a reputation beyond repute*pink_sapphires* has a reputation beyond repute*pink_sapphires* has a reputation beyond repute*pink_sapphires* has a reputation beyond repute*pink_sapphires* has a reputation beyond repute
United Kingdom
Join Date: Jun 2006
Location: Home
Posts: 1,913
My Societies
Default Re: Smear test -unfair age!
 
My Nan and my Mum both had cancerous cells before they were 25. Mum had me at 23 and they were picked up 6 months after I was born. I really want to have one, but I suppose the NHS has the final say. Seems silly because the age of consent is 16, so they're leaving people for 9 years before testing them! You can get free condoms at any age from the GUM clinic, but not a smear test. It's not right
Old 21-07-2008: 21st July 2008 11:14 #15 
Ilora-Danon's Avatar
Ilora-Danon Ilora-Danon is offline Female
TSR Legend
Ilora-Danon has a ridiculously high reputationIlora-Danon has a ridiculously high reputationIlora-Danon has a ridiculously high reputationIlora-Danon has a ridiculously high reputationIlora-Danon has a ridiculously high reputationIlora-Danon has a ridiculously high reputationIlora-Danon has a ridiculously high reputationIlora-Danon has a ridiculously high reputationIlora-Danon has a ridiculously high reputationIlora-Danon has a ridiculously high reputationIlora-Danon has a ridiculously high reputationIlora-Danon has a ridiculously high reputationIlora-Danon has a ridiculously high reputationIlora-Danon has a ridiculously high reputation
Join Date: Nov 2006
Location: Bucks
Posts: 11,475
My Societies
Default Re: Smear test -unfair age!
 
Originally Posted by galladriel
Your doctor sounds like a bitch. Health is important and a gynaikologist should be much more sencitive than that.
She is supposed to be the one person you cn trust and tell everything. If she looks down on you and doesn't make you feel safe, change a doctor.
In England, you usually only get to see a Gynaecologist if you have reproductive problems. All other matters are dealt with by your GP and smears (or paps) are carried out by a nurse.
Old 21-07-2008: 21st July 2008 11:27 #16 
Jamie's Avatar
Jamie Jamie is offline Male
TSR Legend
Jamie has a ridiculously high reputationJamie has a ridiculously high reputationJamie has a ridiculously high reputationJamie has a ridiculously high reputationJamie has a ridiculously high reputationJamie has a ridiculously high reputationJamie has a ridiculously high reputationJamie has a ridiculously high reputationJamie has a ridiculously high reputationJamie has a ridiculously high reputationJamie has a ridiculously high reputationJamie has a ridiculously high reputationJamie has a ridiculously high reputation
Join Date: Sep 2003
Location: London
Default Re: Smear test -unfair age!
 
Originally Posted by Jillie Boe
Cancer runs in my friends family and she requested one, got to the Doctors and said she couldn't have one because she wasn't 25.

It is stupid, esp as Wales can have it before us.
Ok guys can I just clarify something.

The 25 year old thing is for the national screening programme. We have a national screening programme for breasts as well, but that doesn't stop you getting a breast exam if you feel there is something untoward.


Now a girl of any age can get a smear test, and I personally applaud all of you here for being so proactive with your health.
The reason your GP is reluctant to give you the smear is because girls of a young age (especially less than 21) often have borderline results. They often have HPV infection. And 95% of them will have cleared up by the age of 25. It leads to a lot of repeat smears and anxiety from people who think they are going to develop cancer. They won't. And that is why the GPs are reluctant. THey are trying to save you froma whole heap of anxiety and unnecessary procedures. Think on that next time you complain about them.

But at the end of the day if you are already anxious. you are already stressing about it then tell you GP. Insist you want a smear, and tell them you are prepared to change GPs for one that will doa smear.
I assure you that most GPs will do a smear if you are insistent. THey will warn the hell out of you before hand, but they'll do it.
Ask them to do chlamydia and gonorrhoea swabs at the same time - GPs get points for every sexual screen they do, and points mean prizes...
Old 21-07-2008: 21st July 2008 12:21 #17 
emitothelee's Avatar
emitothelee emitothelee is offline Female
Benevolent Member
emitothelee has a spectacular aura aboutemitothelee has a spectacular aura about
Join Date: Jun 2007
Location: London
My Societies
Default Re: Smear test -unfair age!
 
If you're at risk you should get it done from your local BUPA clinic. However, it will cost you about £200.
Old 21-07-2008: 21st July 2008 17:07 #18 
galladriel's Avatar
galladriel galladriel is offline Female
Benevolent Member
galladriel will become famous soon enoughgalladriel will become famous soon enough
European Union
Join Date: Feb 2008
Location: West London
My Societies
Default Re: Smear test -unfair age!
 
Originally Posted by emitothelee
If you're at risk you should get it done from your local BUPA clinic. However, it will cost you about £200.

200 pounds for a smear test? In Greece you pay your doctor 50 euros (35pounds) and they do a total check up -pap test included. And that is if you go to your own doctor and not to the Public Insurance one. If you are insured and go to one of their doctors you don't pay at all.


And by doctor I mean gynaecologist (note: you have a strange way of spelling the word!)/ Every girl has one, my mother took me to mine long before I became sexually active -I was about 12 I think.
Old 21-07-2008: 21st July 2008 22:02 #19 
Jamie's Avatar
Jamie Jamie is offline Male
TSR Legend
Jamie has a ridiculously high reputationJamie has a ridiculously high reputationJamie has a ridiculously high reputationJamie has a ridiculously high reputationJamie has a ridiculously high reputationJamie has a ridiculously high reputationJamie has a ridiculously high reputationJamie has a ridiculously high reputationJamie has a ridiculously high reputationJamie has a ridiculously high reputationJamie has a ridiculously high reputationJamie has a ridiculously high reputationJamie has a ridiculously high reputation
Join Date: Sep 2003
Location: London
Default Re: Smear test -unfair age!
 
Yes yes Galladriel, greece is great yadda yadda yadda. Or not, as the eurpoean health tables show. Infact, aside from the newest EU members grece ranks lowest on health system. Bloody lucky that the greek diet is so healthy really.
Old 21-07-2008: 21st July 2008 22:08 #20 
cherrybella1 cherrybella1 is offline Female
Benevolent Member
cherrybella1 has a spectacular aura aboutcherrybella1 has a spectacular aura aboutcherrybella1 has a spectacular aura about
England
Join Date: Jun 2008
Posts: 605
Default Re: Smear test -unfair age!
 
Gah, the thought of having a smear test makes me die a little bit inside. I dont think the age should really be lowered, Im sure it wouldnt be 25 if there was even a small chance of getting cervical cancer before that age. I think it should probably be advertised more that you do have the option of having one before that age though, I know a couple of friends of mine who had one when they were 20
 
 
Thread Tools Search this Thread
Search this Thread
Advanced
Search