Join TSR
 
About Us | FAQs | Sign in
 
Advanced
Search

Join The Student Room Today

Be part of the UK's largest and fastest growing student community.

It's free to join and a lot of fun - Get inspired, express your ideas, interact and share

RSS  A place for general questions and discussions about university.
Reply
 
Announcements   Posted By
 
All-new Posting Guide! READ!   calcium878
 
Old 10-09-2008: 10th September 2008 16:23 #1 
Emmerald Emmerald is offline Female
Respected Member
Thread Starter
Emmerald will become famous soon enoughEmmerald will become famous soon enough
Northern Ireland
Join Date: May 2007
Location: Northen Ireland
Posts: 215
Default I hate the Good University Guide!
 
Well here I am, sitting on my laptop 2 days before I am set to leave for uni. I decided to have a look at the Good University Guide (even though I knew my uni wasn't very high on it) I was just curious as I forgot how bad it was. Basically it's in the 50's. And now I can't stop thinking why I choose the one I have. (I don't want to name it or my course but I'm sure if you look at some of my other posts you can find out!) I got AAB in my A-levels which was exactly what I thought I would get so it wasn't as if I chose my uni because I didn't think I could get the grades for my other 4 choices. How important do you think the ranking of your uni is on the good university guide?

I'm so annoyed because up until about 10 minutes ago I was really excited about going to uni!

Thanks for paying attention to my rant!
Register to remove banners from posts.
Old 10-09-2008: 10th September 2008 16:26 #2 
neon neon is offline
Peer Of The TSR Realm
neon  has too much reputation for their own goodneon  has too much reputation for their own goodneon  has too much reputation for their own goodneon  has too much reputation for their own goodneon  has too much reputation for their own goodneon  has too much reputation for their own goodneon  has too much reputation for their own goodneon  has too much reputation for their own goodneon  has too much reputation for their own goodneon  has too much reputation for their own goodneon  has too much reputation for their own goodneon  has too much reputation for their own goodneon  has too much reputation for their own goodneon  has too much reputation for their own goodneon  has too much reputation for their own good
Join Date: Apr 2008
My Societies
Default Re: I hate the Good University Guide!
 
It's *******s...they all are; ignore them. Just out of curiosity, what university is it?
 
Old 10-09-2008: 10th September 2008 16:29 #3 
Roobagnall's Avatar
Roobagnall Roobagnall is offline Male
Peer Of The TSR Realm
Roobagnall is on a distinguished road
Northern Ireland
Join Date: Jan 2008
Location: Worcester
Posts: 1,573
Default Re: I hate the Good University Guide!
 
Its annoying because if you had to get such good grades to go there then the uni cant be that bad atall.

Those guides mess around with the statistics to give a really bad portrail of a Unis ranking...
 
Old 10-09-2008: 10th September 2008 16:31 #4 
ahmadjan3's Avatar
ahmadjan3 ahmadjan3 is offline Male
Exalted and Worshipped Member
ahmadjan3 is a splendid one to beholdahmadjan3 is a splendid one to beholdahmadjan3 is a splendid one to beholdahmadjan3 is a splendid one to beholdahmadjan3 is a splendid one to beholdahmadjan3 is a splendid one to beholdahmadjan3 is a splendid one to behold
Join Date: Dec 2006
Posts: 1,226
My Societies
Default Re: I hate the Good University Guide!
 
i know which uni and course you are doing from prevoius posts it dont matter which uni you go to for the that course they are all accredited by the same body so they are roughly the same. and it doesnt matter i guess. thats what most people in here told me
Old 10-09-2008: 10th September 2008 16:33 #5 
River85's Avatar
River85 River85 is offline Male
Call me Lulubelle III
TSR Moderation Team: Moderator
River85 has reputation coming out of their earsRiver85 has reputation coming out of their earsRiver85 has reputation coming out of their earsRiver85 has reputation coming out of their earsRiver85 has reputation coming out of their earsRiver85 has reputation coming out of their earsRiver85 has reputation coming out of their earsRiver85 has reputation coming out of their earsRiver85 has reputation coming out of their earsRiver85 has reputation coming out of their earsRiver85 has reputation coming out of their earsRiver85 has reputation coming out of their earsRiver85 has reputation coming out of their earsRiver85 has reputation coming out of their earsRiver85 has reputation coming out of their earsRiver85 has reputation coming out of their earsRiver85 has reputation coming out of their ears
Northumbria
Join Date: Mar 2008
Location: In the Court of the Crimson King
My Societies
Default Re: I hate the Good University Guide!
 
Not very important. Whether you like the uni, the course, how you spend your time there, what course you are doing etc. are far more important.

Also, I can assure you that your uni has a fairly good employment record. Particularly in certain areas.

If you are happy with the choice that's all that matters.

Besides, 50(ish) is still mid-ranking. So still not "poor".
Old 10-09-2008: 10th September 2008 17:19 #6 
Jadel_L Jadel_L is offline
Adored and Respected Member
Jadel_L will become famous soon enough
Join Date: Dec 2007
Default Re: I hate the Good University Guide!
 
Well according to that guide my uni is just after 100 but i don't care about that at all.

Its the only uni that does the course i want to do so i'm happy to go to it.

League tables mean nothing.
Old 10-09-2008: 10th September 2008 17:21 #7 
AWZC's Avatar
AWZC AWZC is offline Male
Peer Of The TSR Realm
AWZC is a jewel in the roughAWZC is a jewel in the roughAWZC is a jewel in the roughAWZC is a jewel in the rough
United Kingdom
Join Date: May 2007
Location: Harby
Posts: 1,458
My Societies
Default Re: I hate the Good University Guide!
 
Originally Posted by Emmerald
Well here I am, sitting on my laptop 2 days before I am set to leave for uni. I decided to have a look at the Good University Guide (even though I knew my uni wasn't very high on it) I was just curious as I forgot how bad it was. Basically it's in the 50's. And now I can't stop thinking why I choose the one I have. (I don't want to name it or my course but I'm sure if you look at some of my other posts you can find out!) I got AAB in my A-levels which was exactly what I thought I would get so it wasn't as if I chose my uni because I didn't think I could get the grades for my other 4 choices. How important do you think the ranking of your uni is on the good university guide?

I'm so annoyed because up until about 10 minutes ago I was really excited about going to uni!

Thanks for paying attention to my rant!

Which university?
 
Old 10-09-2008: 10th September 2008 17:21 #8 
P_Ben21's Avatar
P_Ben21 P_Ben21 is offline Male
Benevolent Member
P_Ben21 is a splendid one to beholdP_Ben21 is a splendid one to beholdP_Ben21 is a splendid one to beholdP_Ben21 is a splendid one to beholdP_Ben21 is a splendid one to beholdP_Ben21 is a splendid one to beholdP_Ben21 is a splendid one to behold
United Kingdom
Join Date: Nov 2007
Location: Lol wut?
Posts: 613
Default Re: I hate the Good University Guide!
 
I know exactly what you mean, don't worry! I just ignore it....type in on google the university of x reviews and it will give you reviews of undergraduates of your university.
 
Old 10-09-2008: 10th September 2008 17:23 #9 
Tomber's Avatar
Tomber Tomber is offline Male
TSR Demigod
Tomber has a ridiculously high reputationTomber has a ridiculously high reputationTomber has a ridiculously high reputationTomber has a ridiculously high reputationTomber has a ridiculously high reputationTomber has a ridiculously high reputationTomber has a ridiculously high reputationTomber has a ridiculously high reputationTomber has a ridiculously high reputationTomber has a ridiculously high reputationTomber has a ridiculously high reputationTomber has a ridiculously high reputationTomber has a ridiculously high reputation
Join Date: May 2006
Location: Leicester
My Societies
Default Re: I hate the Good University Guide!
 
Find another league table that ranks it higher then?
 
Old 10-09-2008: 10th September 2008 17:24 #10 
Tomber's Avatar
Tomber Tomber is offline Male
TSR Demigod
Tomber has a ridiculously high reputationTomber has a ridiculously high reputationTomber has a ridiculously high reputationTomber has a ridiculously high reputationTomber has a ridiculously high reputationTomber has a ridiculously high reputationTomber has a ridiculously high reputationTomber has a ridiculously high reputationTomber has a ridiculously high reputationTomber has a ridiculously high reputationTomber has a ridiculously high reputationTomber has a ridiculously high reputationTomber has a ridiculously high reputation
Join Date: May 2006
Location: Leicester
My Societies
Default Re: I hate the Good University Guide!
 
Or write a list yourself, and place it at the top - it'll have the same validity and relevance to your degree.
 
Old 10-09-2008: 10th September 2008 17:29 #11 
QI Elf's Avatar
QI Elf QI Elf is offline Female
Overlord in Training
QI Elf has a brilliant futureQI Elf has a brilliant futureQI Elf has a brilliant futureQI Elf has a brilliant futureQI Elf has a brilliant futureQI Elf has a brilliant futureQI Elf has a brilliant futureQI Elf has a brilliant futureQI Elf has a brilliant future
United Kingdom
Join Date: Oct 2007
Location: UK
Posts: 2,379
Default Re: I hate the Good University Guide!
 
Originally Posted by AWZC
Which university?

At a guess, Robert Gordon University, Aberdeen. Am I right?
Old 10-09-2008: 10th September 2008 17:41 #12 
littleshambles's Avatar
littleshambles littleshambles is offline
Registered Russophile
littleshambles  has too much reputation for their own goodlittleshambles  has too much reputation for their own goodlittleshambles  has too much reputation for their own goodlittleshambles  has too much reputation for their own goodlittleshambles  has too much reputation for their own goodlittleshambles  has too much reputation for their own goodlittleshambles  has too much reputation for their own goodlittleshambles  has too much reputation for their own goodlittleshambles  has too much reputation for their own goodlittleshambles  has too much reputation for their own goodlittleshambles  has too much reputation for their own goodlittleshambles  has too much reputation for their own goodlittleshambles  has too much reputation for their own goodlittleshambles  has too much reputation for their own goodlittleshambles  has too much reputation for their own good
Join Date: Sep 2008
Location: Leicester
Posts: 3,583
My Societies
Default Re: I hate the Good University Guide!
 
Originally Posted by Tomber
Or write a list yourself, and place it at the top - it'll have the same validity and relevance to your degree.



League tables are nice and everything (not), but I suppose you should think of your uni as though it were a football team. It might not be Oxford / Manchester Utd, but it's your university / team, so there.

I prefer university reviews that tell you each university's individual strengths and weaknesses, and actually give you some information about what it's like to go there and what the courses involve rather than just a dumb list.
Old 10-09-2008: 10th September 2008 17:55 #13 
Diamonds Diamonds is offline
Permanently Banned
Diamonds is infamous around these parts
Join Date: Sep 2008
Location: London
Posts: 25
Default Re: I hate the Good University Guide!
 
It must be worse than the University of Faeces
Old 10-09-2008: 10th September 2008 18:01 #14 
jismith1989's Avatar
jismith1989 jismith1989 is online now Male
TSR Legend
jismith1989 has more reputation than sensejismith1989 has more reputation than sensejismith1989 has more reputation than sensejismith1989 has more reputation than sensejismith1989 has more reputation than sensejismith1989 has more reputation than sensejismith1989 has more reputation than sensejismith1989 has more reputation than sensejismith1989 has more reputation than sensejismith1989 has more reputation than sensejismith1989 has more reputation than sensejismith1989 has more reputation than sense
Join Date: Oct 2007
Location: Salford, the Venice of, erm, Greater Manchester
My Societies
Default Re: I hate the Good University Guide!
 
Originally Posted by littleshambles
League tables are nice and everything (not), but I suppose you should think of your uni as though it were a football team. It might not be Oxford / Manchester Utd, but it's your university / team, so there.


Nice analogy by the way.
 
Old 10-09-2008: 10th September 2008 18:03 #15 
River85's Avatar
River85 River85 is offline Male
Call me Lulubelle III
TSR Moderation Team: Moderator
River85 has reputation coming out of their earsRiver85 has reputation coming out of their earsRiver85 has reputation coming out of their earsRiver85 has reputation coming out of their earsRiver85 has reputation coming out of their earsRiver85 has reputation coming out of their earsRiver85 has reputation coming out of their earsRiver85 has reputation coming out of their earsRiver85 has reputation coming out of their earsRiver85 has reputation coming out of their earsRiver85 has reputation coming out of their earsRiver85 has reputation coming out of their earsRiver85 has reputation coming out of their earsRiver85 has reputation coming out of their earsRiver85 has reputation coming out of their earsRiver85 has reputation coming out of their earsRiver85 has reputation coming out of their ears
Northumbria
Join Date: Mar 2008
Location: In the Court of the Crimson King
My Societies
Default Re: I hate the Good University Guide!
 
Originally Posted by littleshambles


League tables are nice and everything (not), but I suppose you should think of your uni as though it were a football team. It might not be Oxford / Manchester Utd, but it's your university / team, so there..

Manchester United would be Cambridge, not Oxford.

Originally Posted by littleshambles
I prefer university reviews that tell you each university's individual strengths and weaknesses, and actually give you some information about what it's like to go there and what the courses involve rather than just a dumb list.

The Times (and Sunday Times) profiles which, although not "reviews", do give a decent overview of the uni and, if the OP reads the profiles of RGU, they'll see there's more than just its mediocore league position.
Old 10-09-2008: 10th September 2008 18:05 #16 
jismith1989's Avatar
jismith1989 jismith1989 is online now Male
TSR Legend
jismith1989 has more reputation than sensejismith1989 has more reputation than sensejismith1989 has more reputation than sensejismith1989 has more reputation than sensejismith1989 has more reputation than sensejismith1989 has more reputation than sensejismith1989 has more reputation than sensejismith1989 has more reputation than sensejismith1989 has more reputation than sensejismith1989 has more reputation than sensejismith1989 has more reputation than sensejismith1989 has more reputation than sense
Join Date: Oct 2007
Location: Salford, the Venice of, erm, Greater Manchester
My Societies
Default Re: I hate the Good University Guide!
 
Originally Posted by River85
Manchester United would be Cambridge, not Oxford.
The irony being that you repeatedly tell people not to bother about league tables, and then you, usually, spend three pages discussing the relative positions of universities.
 
Old 10-09-2008: 10th September 2008 18:08 #17 
River85's Avatar
River85 River85 is offline Male
Call me Lulubelle III
TSR Moderation Team: Moderator
River85 has reputation coming out of their earsRiver85 has reputation coming out of their earsRiver85 has reputation coming out of their earsRiver85 has reputation coming out of their earsRiver85 has reputation coming out of their earsRiver85 has reputation coming out of their earsRiver85 has reputation coming out of their earsRiver85 has reputation coming out of their earsRiver85 has reputation coming out of their earsRiver85 has reputation coming out of their earsRiver85 has reputation coming out of their earsRiver85 has reputation coming out of their earsRiver85 has reputation coming out of their earsRiver85 has reputation coming out of their earsRiver85 has reputation coming out of their earsRiver85 has reputation coming out of their earsRiver85 has reputation coming out of their ears
Northumbria
Join Date: Mar 2008
Location: In the Court of the Crimson King
My Societies
Default Re: I hate the Good University Guide!
 
Originally Posted by jismith1989
The irony being that you repeatedly tell people not to bother about league tables, and then you, usually, spend three pages discussing the relative positions of universities.

Erm...like where?

No more than anyone else....

And I don't think that league tables are completely worthless anyway.
Old 10-09-2008: 10th September 2008 18:10 #18 
jismith1989's Avatar
jismith1989 jismith1989 is online now Male
TSR Legend
jismith1989 has more reputation than sensejismith1989 has more reputation than sensejismith1989 has more reputation than sensejismith1989 has more reputation than sensejismith1989 has more reputation than sensejismith1989 has more reputation than sensejismith1989 has more reputation than sensejismith1989 has more reputation than sensejismith1989 has more reputation than sensejismith1989 has more reputation than sensejismith1989 has more reputation than sensejismith1989 has more reputation than sense
Join Date: Oct 2007
Location: Salford, the Venice of, erm, Greater Manchester
My Societies
Default Re: I hate the Good University Guide!
 
Originally Posted by River85
Erm...like where?

No more than anyone else....

And I don't think that league tables are completely worthless anyway.
Well, I do tend to see you pop up a lot on these kind of threads. There's nothing wrong with it; it just seems a little hypocritical when you told him that league tables are 'not very important'. But it's cool...

Surely, arguing about the relative positions of Oxford and Cambridge is nigh on worthless though?
 
Old 10-09-2008: 10th September 2008 18:12 #19 
desmondmac desmondmac is offline Male
Exalted and Worshipped Member
desmondmac has a spectacular aura aboutdesmondmac has a spectacular aura aboutdesmondmac has a spectacular aura about
Sierra Leone
Join Date: Dec 2005
Location: London
Posts: 904
Default Re: I hate the Good University Guide!
 
Originally Posted by jismith1989
The irony being that you repeatedly tell people not to bother about league tables, and then you, usually, spend three pages discussing the relative positions of universities.

So so true. It's hilarious to watch!

To river85: You say stuff like: 'There's nothing between X uni and Y uni but Y has that slight edge' lol. Always!
 

Last edited by desmondmac : 10-09-2008 at 18:14.

Old 10-09-2008: 10th September 2008 18:13 #20 
River85's Avatar
River85 River85 is offline Male
Call me Lulubelle III
TSR Moderation Team: Moderator
River85 has reputation coming out of their earsRiver85 has reputation coming out of their earsRiver85 has reputation coming out of their earsRiver85 has reputation coming out of their earsRiver85 has reputation coming out of their earsRiver85 has reputation coming out of their earsRiver85 has reputation coming out of their earsRiver85 has reputation coming out of their earsRiver85 has reputation coming out of their earsRiver85 has reputation coming out of their earsRiver85 has reputation coming out of their earsRiver85 has reputation coming out of their earsRiver85 has reputation coming out of their earsRiver85 has reputation coming out of their earsRiver85 has reputation coming out of their earsRiver85 has reputation coming out of their earsRiver85 has reputation coming out of their ears
Northumbria
Join Date: Mar 2008
Location: In the Court of the Crimson King
My Societies
Default Re: I hate the Good University Guide!
 
Originally Posted by jismith1989
Well, I do tend to see you pop up a lot on these kind of threads. There's nothing wrong with it; it just seems a little hypocritical when you told him that league tables are 'not very important'. But it's cool...

Sure, but it's not like I go, "oh my godz, that uni is ranked 28th. It's sooo crap."

Originally Posted by jismith1989
Surely, arguing about the relative positions of Oxford and Cambridge is nigh on worthless though?

I wasn't. It was just that, as a Manchester United fan (should I really admit that that?.....) I'd rather it was associated more with Cambridge

I was joking
 
Thread Tools Search this Thread
Search this Thread
Advanced
Search