Join TSR
 
About Us | FAQs | Sign in
 
Advanced
Search

Join The Student Room Today

Be part of the UK's largest and fastest growing student community.

It's free to join and a lot of fun - Get inspired, express your ideas, interact and share

RSS  Discussion about A Level exams and choosing A Level courses, including VCEs.
Reply
 
Announcements   Posted By
 
Old 20-09-2008: 20th September 2008 14:01 #1 
Princess_X Princess_X is offline Female
Junior Member
Thread Starter
Princess_X will become famous soon enough
Join Date: May 2008
Location: London
Posts: 59
Default AS Religious Studies or Psychology
 
Out of religious studies and psychology, which is seen as a more academic/ respected subject?
Register to remove banners from posts.
Old 20-09-2008: 20th September 2008 14:11 #2 
Beska's Avatar
Beska Beska is offline
Exalted and Worshipped Member
Beska has much to be proud ofBeska has much to be proud ofBeska has much to be proud ofBeska has much to be proud ofBeska has much to be proud ofBeska has much to be proud ofBeska has much to be proud ofBeska has much to be proud of
Join Date: Jun 2008
Location: UK
My Societies
Default Re: AS Religious Studies or Psychology
 
They're both probably equal in terms of academia, learning required, and concepts to grasp. They both have the same amount of theories and ideas to learn, etc. They're also both essay based subjects - it depends which way you personally prefer.

Do you prefer a more scientific subject (hypothesis, conclusion, aims, graphs, statistics) or more an arts subject (your opinion, quoting from text [the bible], the whole 'balanced argument' essay piece).
Old 20-09-2008: 20th September 2008 14:16 #3 
Princess_X Princess_X is offline Female
Junior Member
Thread Starter
Princess_X will become famous soon enough
Join Date: May 2008
Location: London
Posts: 59
Default Re: AS Religious Studies or Psychology
 
Well basically I chose to do religious studies over psychology but I do have the option to do psychology instead- as a subject I'd prefer religious studies but I wasn't sure if it was a respected subject as some people i know dont think it is.. thanks for your help
Old 20-09-2008: 20th September 2008 14:53 #4 
piece_by_piece piece_by_piece is offline Female
TSR Demigod
piece_by_piece has more reputation than sensepiece_by_piece has more reputation than sensepiece_by_piece has more reputation than sensepiece_by_piece has more reputation than sensepiece_by_piece has more reputation than sensepiece_by_piece has more reputation than sensepiece_by_piece has more reputation than sensepiece_by_piece has more reputation than sensepiece_by_piece has more reputation than sensepiece_by_piece has more reputation than sensepiece_by_piece has more reputation than sensepiece_by_piece has more reputation than sense
Join Date: Sep 2007
My Societies
Default Re: AS Religious Studies or Psychology
 
I think they're both pretty much the same. If it helps, I'm doing Psychology and I love it.
 
Old 20-09-2008: 20th September 2008 15:30 #5 
Malsy's Avatar
Malsy Malsy is offline
TSR Legend
Malsy has disabled reputation
Join Date: Feb 2008
My Societies
Default Re: AS Religious Studies or Psychology
 
Psychology is fun, not up there with the Chemistry and English Literature but it's certanly also not down there with the Food Tech or something, so my point is as long as you have other well respected subjects Psychology is not a ****** subject!!!
 
Old 20-09-2008: 20th September 2008 15:33 #6 
jesus-ninja's Avatar
jesus-ninja jesus-ninja is offline Female
Exalted and Worshipped Member
jesus-ninja has a spectacular aura aboutjesus-ninja has a spectacular aura about
Join Date: May 2008
Posts: 939
My Societies
Default Re: AS Religious Studies or Psychology
 
I think RS is more respected, read it on the internet-link somewhere on TSR Not sure though.
 
Old 20-09-2008: 20th September 2008 15:34 #7 
im so academic's Avatar
im so academic im so academic is offline
TSR Demigod
im so academic is infamous around these partsim so academic is infamous around these partsim so academic is infamous around these partsim so academic is infamous around these partsim so academic is infamous around these partsim so academic is infamous around these partsim so academic is infamous around these partsim so academic is infamous around these partsim so academic is infamous around these partsim so academic is infamous around these partsim so academic is infamous around these partsim so academic is infamous around these parts
Join Date: May 2008
Posts: 6,379
My Societies
Default Re: AS Religious Studies or Psychology
 
Pretty much the same but I'd say RS. But OP, pick which one you are good at as an A in psychology is better than a scraped C in RS.
 
Old 20-09-2008: 20th September 2008 15:34 #8 
nolongerhearthemusic's Avatar
nolongerhearthemusic nolongerhearthemusic is offline
TSR Demigod
nolongerhearthemusic has a reputation beyond reputenolongerhearthemusic has a reputation beyond reputenolongerhearthemusic has a reputation beyond reputenolongerhearthemusic has a reputation beyond reputenolongerhearthemusic has a reputation beyond reputenolongerhearthemusic has a reputation beyond reputenolongerhearthemusic has a reputation beyond reputenolongerhearthemusic has a reputation beyond reputenolongerhearthemusic has a reputation beyond reputenolongerhearthemusic has a reputation beyond reputenolongerhearthemusic has a reputation beyond repute
Join Date: Dec 2007
Default Re: AS Religious Studies or Psychology
 
Religious Studies is always in the 'suitable' list. Psyhology is on some 'less suitable' lists.

EDIT: If you're choosing between the two, I would suggest looking up the RS syllabus. It's really nothing like GCSE RS.

People assume it's less respected because they've done 'RS' or 'RE' lessons all through school, and obviously those are stupid and easy.

Last edited by nolongerhearthemusic : 20-09-2008 at 15:37.

Old 20-09-2008: 20th September 2008 16:41 #9 
im so academic's Avatar
im so academic im so academic is offline
TSR Demigod
im so academic is infamous around these partsim so academic is infamous around these partsim so academic is infamous around these partsim so academic is infamous around these partsim so academic is infamous around these partsim so academic is infamous around these partsim so academic is infamous around these partsim so academic is infamous around these partsim so academic is infamous around these partsim so academic is infamous around these partsim so academic is infamous around these partsim so academic is infamous around these parts
Join Date: May 2008
Posts: 6,379
My Societies
Default Re: AS Religious Studies or Psychology
 
Originally Posted by nolongerhearthemusic
Religious Studies is always in the 'suitable' list. Psyhology is on some 'less suitable' lists.

EDIT: If you're choosing between the two, I would suggest looking up the RS syllabus. It's really nothing like GCSE RS.

People assume it's less respected because they've done 'RS' or 'RE' lessons all through school, and obviously those are stupid and easy.

 
Old 20-09-2008: 20th September 2008 17:13 #10 
junoreacter junoreacter is offline Male
Full Member
junoreacter will become famous soon enough
England
Join Date: Sep 2008
Location: Londinium
Posts: 105
Default Re: AS Religious Studies or Psychology
 
Don't listen to some of the posters.
RS IS VERY RESPECTED. Its alongside English Literature.
ITs on the A - List at Cambridge (the highest List), where as Psychology is on the 'limited suitability' (B) list
Old 21-09-2008: 21st September 2008 00:12 #11 
Galatea Galatea is offline Female
Exalted and Worshipped Member
Galatea is a splendid one to beholdGalatea is a splendid one to beholdGalatea is a splendid one to beholdGalatea is a splendid one to beholdGalatea is a splendid one to beholdGalatea is a splendid one to beholdGalatea is a splendid one to behold
United Kingdom
Join Date: Jun 2006
Location: West Sussex
Posts: 1,083
My Societies
Default Re: AS Religious Studies or Psychology
 
as junoreactor said, RS is definitely the more respected, as a traditional arts subject, of the two. But it is also (and correspondingly) slightly more difficult, and if the OP's more interested in psychology then perhaps that's the way to go. Or the OP could do both.
 
Old 21-09-2008: 21st September 2008 00:21 #12 
student_s student_s is offline Female
Respected Member
student_s is a name known to allstudent_s is a name known to allstudent_s is a name known to allstudent_s is a name known to allstudent_s is a name known to allstudent_s is a name known to all
Join Date: Nov 2007
Location: London
Posts: 226
My Societies
Default Re: AS Religious Studies or Psychology
 
RS is more respected, sometimes I've seen that Psychology is classed as a softer A level, I took both for A-Levels! I absolutely LOOOOVED RS, but choose which one you think you will enjoy most, because I was like the only one in my class who got an A! If you enjoy it though, it'll give you more motivation to study it and do well! Good Luck, If you have any questions let me know and I'd be happy to answer them!
 
Old 21-09-2008: 21st September 2008 07:31 #13 
bex2306 bex2306 is offline
Exalted Member
bex2306 will become famous soon enough
Join Date: May 2008
Location: London
Posts: 279
Default Re: AS Religious Studies or Psychology
 
Do you know what you want to do after college? That should relate to your choice more than what you think is easy/hard.
Old 21-09-2008: 21st September 2008 09:48 #14 
barries barries is offline
Junior Member
barries will become famous soon enoughbarries will become famous soon enough
Join Date: Sep 2008
Location: plymouth
Posts: 27
Default Re: AS Religious Studies or Psychology
 
At my school everyone had to take RE as AS. Psychology is a choice. Most of those who did it last year say RE is easier to pass.

Apparently psychology is very hard and most of those who went on to A2 in RE had failed psychology but got passes in RE.

Thats just what happened. I dont know about which is most respectable.

I would choose which I liked the best.
Old 21-09-2008: 21st September 2008 09:50 #15 
Awara_Jawaan's Avatar
Awara_Jawaan Awara_Jawaan is offline Female
Benevolent Member
Awara_Jawaan has a reputation beyond reputeAwara_Jawaan has a reputation beyond reputeAwara_Jawaan has a reputation beyond reputeAwara_Jawaan has a reputation beyond reputeAwara_Jawaan has a reputation beyond reputeAwara_Jawaan has a reputation beyond reputeAwara_Jawaan has a reputation beyond reputeAwara_Jawaan has a reputation beyond reputeAwara_Jawaan has a reputation beyond reputeAwara_Jawaan has a reputation beyond reputeAwara_Jawaan has a reputation beyond repute
Join Date: Nov 2007
Location: Somewhere
Posts: 842
Default Re: AS Religious Studies or Psychology
 
Originally Posted by Princess_X
Well basically I chose to do religious studies over psychology but I do have the option to do psychology instead- as a subject I'd prefer religious studies but I wasn't sure if it was a respected subject as some people i know dont think it is.. thanks for your help

I'm at Oxbridge and I studied it, I know of others who studied it too. It depends on what you're thinking of getting into. But generally do what interests you and do well at it. I really loved RS, best A Level and fun class..
Old 21-09-2008: 21st September 2008 10:08 #16 
surreal's Avatar
surreal surreal is offline Male
Respected Member
surreal is a jewel in the roughsurreal is a jewel in the roughsurreal is a jewel in the rough
United Kingdom
Join Date: Nov 2007
Location: Suffolk - UK
Posts: 238
Default Re: AS Religious Studies or Psychology
 
I'm doing both, RS is so much more interesting so far. I had no idea it was up there with english lit, looks like English lit, Psychology, RS and Business&Economics is a decent combination. (What I am doing at AS if you didnt pick up on that)
Old 21-09-2008: 21st September 2008 10:13 #17 
DJkG.1's Avatar
DJkG.1 DJkG.1 is offline Male
Overlord in Training
DJkG.1 has a reputation beyond reputeDJkG.1 has a reputation beyond reputeDJkG.1 has a reputation beyond reputeDJkG.1 has a reputation beyond reputeDJkG.1 has a reputation beyond reputeDJkG.1 has a reputation beyond reputeDJkG.1 has a reputation beyond reputeDJkG.1 has a reputation beyond reputeDJkG.1 has a reputation beyond reputeDJkG.1 has a reputation beyond reputeDJkG.1 has a reputation beyond repute
India
Join Date: Jul 2008
Location: England
Posts: 2,711
My Societies
Default Re: AS Religious Studies or Psychology
 
OP, please make sure you take reliable information away from this thread.

RS A-level is definitely a very respected subject, alongside the likes of English lit. and history. It is always in the ‘preferred’ or ‘recommended’ list of subjects published by the top few universities.

Psychology is not exactly a soft subject like sociology for example, but it is occasionally seen in the ‘somewhat suitable’ or ‘helpful’ list of subjects as opposed to the ‘recommended’ list.

See what subject you like more in terms of subject matter and if you have say 3 other strong subjects, then psychology isn’t a bad choice but if you want this one to be a strong A-level, go for RS.

Hope this helped!
 
Old 21-09-2008: 21st September 2008 10:23 #18 
nothingspek's Avatar
nothingspek nothingspek is offline Female
Permanently Banned
nothingspek has a reputation beyond reputenothingspek has a reputation beyond reputenothingspek has a reputation beyond reputenothingspek has a reputation beyond reputenothingspek has a reputation beyond reputenothingspek has a reputation beyond reputenothingspek has a reputation beyond reputenothingspek has a reputation beyond reputenothingspek has a reputation beyond reputenothingspek has a reputation beyond reputenothingspek has a reputation beyond repute
United Kingdom
Join Date: Dec 2007
Location: Hampshire
Posts: 4,657
My Societies
Default Re: AS Religious Studies or Psychology
 
R.S definitely, I took psychology at the beginning of my AS levels and dropped in by half the year, it really is dire. I take R.S (Well, philosophy by definition.) and it's one of my favourite subjects.

But y'know, this is all subjective, and my opinion.
Old 21-09-2008: 21st September 2008 10:29 #19 
barries barries is offline
Junior Member
barries will become famous soon enoughbarries will become famous soon enough
Join Date: Sep 2008
Location: plymouth
Posts: 27
Default Re: AS Religious Studies or Psychology
 
"Psychology is not exactly a soft subject like sociology for example, but it is occasionally seen in the ‘somewhat suitable’ or ‘helpful’ list of subjects as opposed to the ‘recommended’ list."

I read recently that Psychology gets under rated for some reason and its very hard. According to research its as hard to get top grades with as something like Chemistry or biology.

Sociology it seems was much easier.

The difficulty of a subject might not be reflected in those lists. The lists seem to be based on some old idea of what is " traditional" - like maths , English or bilogy Chemistry and Physics.
Anything else seems to get more limited approval.

Since I am not going to Oxbridge because I cant afford it it wont matter to me so I am doing Maths, Chemistry, Biology Psychology and English and we have to take RE at AS as a compulsary extra.

I hope to finish up with maths biology and psychology which will happily get me a place locally.
I am staying at home because it will be cheaper and doubt the degree will be worth more because its come from Oxford or Cambridge or something.

They dont get all the " best " students - only those who are good and can afford it or who are daft enough to get a mortgage for a debt before they reach 21.
Old 21-09-2008: 21st September 2008 10:47 #20 
purplefrog's Avatar
purplefrog purplefrog is offline Male
Benevolent Member
purplefrog is a jewel in the roughpurplefrog is a jewel in the roughpurplefrog is a jewel in the rough
United Kingdom
Join Date: May 2008
Location: S.E England
Posts: 873
My Societies
Default Re: AS Religious Studies or Psychology
 
Here is what people mentioned earlier about the A-list http://www.trin.cam.ac.uk/index.php?pageid=604
Hope it is of some use.
 
 
Thread Tools Search this Thread
Search this Thread
Advanced
Search