(Also, am I just making it up, or does HoA at York accept General Studies.
Did when I applied, much to my surprise.
It'll be great if someone could tell me about the lecturers, teaching, the course... anything really
The course structure is changing a bit next year I understand. At the moment we have one module a term, which means you can study a subject in huge depth but restricts the breadth of things you can study. In future, there will be a mix of bigger and smaller modules.
Teaching is almost entirely in 3 hour seminars of 15 students, twice a week (though my module this term was only 8 people), with individual tutorials for essay feedback. You are expected to do a lot of reading for each seminar and also make presentations several times a term. History of Art is very demanding at York in terms of what they expect of undergraduate students. Most modules involve study trips, sometimes local or regional, sometimes to London and sometimes abroad. I've been lucky enough to go to Amsterdam, Florence & Venice. Flights and accommodation are paid for by the uni, but you have to pay for food, museum entrance fees, train fares and so on.
Most of the lecturers are excellent with teaching based on their own research topics, though there is the occasional duff one (probably true of every uni). York is strong on medieval, Georgian and twentieth century art and particularly architecture. This is reflected in the modules, although there is a huge number to choose from. You have to do at least one option in pre-1500, middle and later periods. First year modules are compulsory with no options.
UCL is also a very well respected HoA department and has the advantage of some of the best museums and galleries in the world in London. The city also offers a very cosmopolitan, multi-cultural, fast pace environment. York is obviously smaller, slower but great in terms of its friendliness and the way in which you can soon feel at home. York is also considerably cheaper - you can live comfortably on £6-7k a year, compared to £10-12k in London.
Good luck with your decision and exams. For those of you who have already chosen York, I can honestly say that you won't regret it. The only bad thing is how quickly the three years go.