The "Is this university/course good enough for banking/consultancy?" thread

Discussion on investment and retail banking, equities, trading, derivatives, consultancy.

Announcements Posted on
TSR launches Learn Together! - Our new subscription to help improve your learning 16-05-2013
Interview discussion rules - please read before posting! 12-01-2013
Sign in to Reply
  • View Poll Results: Manchester L102 or Nottingham Industrial Economics
    Manchester Economics L102
    3 30.00%
    Nottingham Industrial Economics
    7 70.00%

  1. KLL's Avatar
    • Overlord in Training
    • Posts: 2,000
    Re: The "Is this university/course good enough for banking/consultancy?" thread
    (Original post by student222)
    ye they should be. it will focus on mainly internships, year placements, graduate schemes and spring insight weeks. But on request they can fill in any forms you like. They make money from customers using the service. From what I've heard its gonna be like £1.50 an application, or something ridiculously cheap like that, and the more you need filling in the cheaper it is.
    No,no I meant, does it also will out the education and work experience section of the application forms?
    Anyway, 1.5 is a bit steep.
  2. student222's Avatar
    • Junior Member
    • Location: London
    • Posts: 31
    Re: The "Is this university/course good enough for banking/consultancy?" thread
    (Original post by KLL)
    No,no I meant, does it also will out the education and work experience section of the application forms?
    Anyway, 1.5 is a bit steep.
    Oh okk, ye it does. fills in everything apart from the answer to personal questions. really 1.5 is steep? with a discount..i wouldn't complain if I had to pay £10 to fill in like 15 applications. seeing as ucas charges like 22+ for what it does. how much would you expect it to be?
  3. KLL's Avatar
    • Overlord in Training
    • Posts: 2,000
    Re: The "Is this university/course good enough for banking/consultancy?" thread
    (Original post by student222)
    Oh okk, ye it does. fills in everything apart from the answer to personal questions. really 1.5 is steep? with a discount..i wouldn't complain if I had to pay £10 to fill in like 15 applications. seeing as ucas charges like 22+ for what it does. how much would you expect it to be?
    Don't know. A flat fee possibly? But 50 quid for 30 apps, not really a good deal.
  4. student222's Avatar
    • Junior Member
    • Location: London
    • Posts: 31
    Re: The "Is this university/course good enough for banking/consultancy?" thread
    (Original post by KLL)
    Don't know. A flat fee possibly? But 50 quid for 30 apps, not really a good deal.
    no wont be 50, more you do, more discount. with 30 apps, you'll be looking at 30 quid max,
  5. Scorcher's Avatar
    • Respected Member
    • Location: London
    Re: The "Is this university/course good enough for banking/consultancy?" thread
    (Original post by student222)
    no wont be 50, more you do, more discount. with 30 apps, you'll be looking at 30 quid max,
    This is obviously your business. Every single thread I click on you've either advertised it or answered a question saying why it's so amazing. Subtle advertising :cool:

    Whilst it is a good idea in theory, I just can't see anybody trusting it with their details and applications at this stage, however once it's more well known that may change.

    I can't see anybody paying (especially broke students) when it doesn't take THAT long to fill out an application. It would work better as a free tool and then you can use that to leverage other ideas that you can charge for such as subscribing to an email with a list of all opportunities, or a CV/Cover Letter service etc. Just some food for thought.
  6. PaLaK-'s Avatar
    • New Member
    • Posts: 9
    Re: The "Is this university/course good enough for banking/consultancy?" thread
    Hi, I know I have left this very very late, but I was currently deciding between offers from the University of Nottingham and the University of Edinburgh, and was unsure which one to firm - both are for straight Economics.

    My dream job would be working in Investment Banking either in London or even abroad in a Major Financial area - e.g. Singapore, Zurich, Hong Kong, Paris, Shanghai, Frankfurt, Tokyo or even Amsterdam.

    Working for a Major IB e.g JP Morgan, UBS, Nomura, and living in one of those cities would literally be a dream for me, and if it increased the chances of me getting into Investment Banking I'd be more than willing to apply straight for an internship or jobs in one of those major cities abroad rather than working in London first - I can't see myself living in the UK for a long time after graduating anyway.

    Any advice would be REALLY appreciated as I will be firming soon, and I just wanted to know which Uni would be better for IB here, and which for abroad, and how big the advantages were? And if it would be easier/better to apply straight abroad from one of them universities for an internship/job, or easier to go to London and hope to get a transfer? Thanks.
    Last edited by PaLaK-; 09-05-2012 at 20:59. Reason: typos
  7. Industrious Orca's Avatar
    • Adored and Respected Member
    • Posts: 510
    Re: The "Is this university/course good enough for banking/consultancy?" thread
    (Original post by CynicaL)
    Quick question:

    I know it would not be as solid as a quantitative degree from one of the 'target universities' but I'd like an idea of how (MEng) Chemical Engineering at The University of Birmingham would stack up in comparison (providing a first or 2:1 and A*AA at A2). Birmingham is ranked highly for Chem Eng (3rd in Guardian rankings), would this be of any relevance?
    Everyone has A*AA. Everyone has a 1st or 2.1. Birmingham will hold you back massively, it's the university that matters, not the course. HR don't sit there looking at which university is first for each course in the Guardian rankings, and then interview loads of students from said course and university.

    Get a 2.1 at least (banks don't really care whether it's a 1st or 2.1). Get lots of work experience, volunteer work, extra-curriculars etc. Network well. Learn your **** and interview techniques. Then you will be in an okay position to get interviews. You can make it from Birmingham, but it'll be much harder than from one of the targets.
  8. Industrious Orca's Avatar
    • Adored and Respected Member
    • Posts: 510
    Re: The "Is this university/course good enough for banking/consultancy?" thread
    (Original post by PaLaK-)
    Hi, I know I have left this very very late, but I was currently deciding between offers from the University of Nottingham and the University of Edinburgh, and was unsure which one to firm - both are for straight Economics.

    My dream job would be working in Investment Banking either in London or even abroad in a Major Financial area - e.g. Singapore, Zurich, Hong Kong, Paris, Shanghai, Frankfurt, Tokyo or even Amsterdam.

    Working for a Major IB e.g JP Morgan, UBS, Nomura, and living in one of those cities would literally be a dream for me, and if it increased the chances of me getting into Investment Banking I'd be more than willing to apply straight for an internship or jobs in one of those major cities abroad rather than working in London first - I can't see myself living in the UK for a long time after graduating anyway.

    Any advice would be REALLY appreciated as I will be firming soon, and I just wanted to know which Uni would be better for IB here, and which for abroad, and how big the advantages were? And if it would be easier/better to apply straight abroad from one of them universities for an internship/job, or easier to go to London and hope to get a transfer? Thanks.
    Nottingham has a slight edge.
  9. Industrious Orca's Avatar
    • Adored and Respected Member
    • Posts: 510
    Re: The "Is this university/course good enough for banking/consultancy?" thread
    (Original post by student222)
    Oh okk, ye it does. fills in everything apart from the answer to personal questions. really 1.5 is steep? with a discount..i wouldn't complain if I had to pay £10 to fill in like 15 applications. seeing as ucas charges like 22+ for what it does. how much would you expect it to be?
    I would expect it to be free.

    You can't compare this to UCAS, because you HAVE to use UCAS to apply to university. Your business just takes money from students for what they could do for free; do you not see the problem with charging? I'm not going to pay for something that i can get for free.
  10. Scorcher's Avatar
    • Respected Member
    • Location: London
    Re: The "Is this university/course good enough for banking/consultancy?" thread
    (Original post by Industrious Orca)
    I would expect it to be free.

    You can't compare this to UCAS, because you HAVE to use UCAS to apply to university. Your business just takes money from students for what they could do for free; do you not see the problem with charging? I'm not going to pay for something that i can get for free.
    Agreed, thats why I said it should just be a free tool and then they can use it to advertise some other services which people may actually pay for (like the CV/CL service on M&I)
  11. student222's Avatar
    • Junior Member
    • Location: London
    • Posts: 31
    Re: The "Is this university/course good enough for banking/consultancy?" thread
    (Original post by Scorcher)
    This is obviously your business. Every single thread I click on you've either advertised it or answered a question saying why it's so amazing. Subtle advertising :cool:

    Whilst it is a good idea in theory, I just can't see anybody trusting it with their details and applications at this stage, however once it's more well known that may change.

    I can't see anybody paying (especially broke students) when it doesn't take THAT long to fill out an application. It would work better as a free tool and then you can use that to leverage other ideas that you can charge for such as subscribing to an email with a list of all opportunities, or a CV/Cover Letter service etc. Just some food for thought.
    Just to clear up, this is not my business idea. I don't want the person who does own it to think I am taking credit for it, I just genuinely thought it was a good idea. I actually posted it in about 2 or maybe 3 other threads...so not really everywhere..

    I think its worth it and seems as though a lot of people think the same, especially to the ones I have spoken to. And if it was my business, trust me I would have posted it anywhere I could to let people know. I just posted it into relevant threads where people thought it might be useful..which was about 3. Thought thats what student room was all about..
  12. student222's Avatar
    • Junior Member
    • Location: London
    • Posts: 31
    Re: The "Is this university/course good enough for banking/consultancy?" thread
    (Original post by Industrious Orca)
    I would expect it to be free.

    You can't compare this to UCAS, because you HAVE to use UCAS to apply to university. Your business just takes money from students for what they could do for free; do you not see the problem with charging? I'm not going to pay for something that i can get for free.
    Again, as I replied to someone else...this is not my business. I guess if it got companies on board to use it as the only way to apply to them then it would be more like UCAS and more people would be interested to use it...those who dont just want to pay to save them time filling in lots of generic info on forms. But still for me that took time..and something I would personally pay for and clearly a lot of people would pay for. A lot of students don't mind spending money just to make their life a little easier...don't think every student is as strapped for cash as everyone thinks..maybe thats just me..or the people around my uni...
  13. bmqib's Avatar
    • Banned
    • Location: The secret location
    • Posts: 1,071
    Re: The "Is this university/course good enough for banking/consultancy?" thread
    i think you are posting this on facebook applicant groups too
  14. Txi's Avatar
    • Banned
    • Location: alpha centuri
    • Posts: 998
    • Warning points: 1000
    Re: The "Is this university/course good enough for banking/consultancy?" thread
    (Original post by CynicaL)
    Didn't give IB much thought and picked the best option for chem eng outside of London. Wasn't predicted the A* either. Long story.
    Should have taken a gap and then reapplied to ICL or Oxbridge
  15. joestevens2092's Avatar
    • Exalted and Worshipped Member
    • Location: Essex
    • Posts: 1,206
    Re: The "Is this university/course good enough for banking/consultancy?" thread
    Importance of doing finance related modules in 2nd year? Or is quality of degree more important. Studying MMath at Nottingham if that helps. Thanks
  16. non's Avatar
    • Peer Of The TSR Realm
    • Posts: 1,603
    Re: The "Is this university/course good enough for banking/consultancy?" thread
    (Original post by joestevens2092)
    Importance of doing finance related modules in 2nd year? Or is quality of degree more important. Studying MMath at Nottingham if that helps. Thanks
    It's better to but you must get a 2.1 in The module otherwise it would be best to do what you're best at.
  17. lukas-0704's Avatar
    • New Member
    • Posts: 8
    Re: The "Is this university/course good enough for banking/consultancy?" thread
    Information Systems Management and Innovation (MSc) at Warwick Business School? What are the chances for Big4 in technology consulting, or accenture/ibm? or technology division within IB?
  18. TheNikko's Avatar
    • New Member
    • Posts: 1
    Re: The "Is this university/course good enough for banking/consultancy?" thread
    How is management bsc at Warwick viewed upon? Thinking about both ib and second tier consulting. Some say its a bull****t degree, but its target school right?
    Last edited by TheNikko; 06-06-2012 at 18:36.
  19. non's Avatar
    • Peer Of The TSR Realm
    • Posts: 1,603
    Re: The "Is this university/course good enough for banking/consultancy?" thread
    (Original post by TheNikko)
    How is management bsc at Warwick viewed upon? Thinking about both ib and second tier consulting. Some say its a bull****t degree, but its target school right?
    it's good!
  20. Zweihander's Avatar
    • Vengeful, Imperial Overlord of The Student Room
    • Location: Tha Hood
    Re: The "Is this university/course good enough for banking/consultancy?" thread
    (Original post by TheNikko)
    How is management bsc at Warwick viewed upon? Thinking about both ib and second tier consulting. Some say its a bull****t degree, but its target school right?
    Warwick is a target uni, so as long as your degree is respectable it's all ceteris paribus - Management is sufficiently respectable. I can't speak for consulting recruitment, but Management at Warwick will not hold you back in terms of IB recruitment, and there are a large number of people on the course who have secured summer internships in the industry this year.

    In terms of rigour of the degree, the Management students have a lot of choice in their modules, so you can fill your degree with "bull****" modules, or more challenging or finance-relevant modules, as you see fit.
    Last edited by Zweihander; 09-06-2012 at 18:00.
Sign in to Reply
Share this discussion:  
Useful resources
Article updates
Moderators

We have a brilliant team of more than 60 volunteers looking after discussions on The Student Room, helping to make it a fun, safe and useful place to hang out.

Reputation gems:
The Reputation gems seen here indicate how well reputed the user is, red gem indicate negative reputation and green indicates a good rep.
Post rating score:
These scores show if a post has been positively or negatively rated by our members.