Join TSR
 
About Us | FAQs | Sign in
 
Advanced
Search

Join The Student Room Today

Be part of the UK's largest and fastest growing student community.

It's free to join and a lot of fun - Get inspired, express your ideas, interact and share

RSS  Maths revision, coursework or discussion you will find help in here.
Reply
 
Announcements   Posted By
 
Old 06-12-2008: 6th December 2008 21:27 #1 
Mr Nonsense's Avatar
Mr Nonsense Mr Nonsense is online now Male
Overlord in Training
Thread Starter
Mr Nonsense is a jewel in the roughMr Nonsense is a jewel in the roughMr Nonsense is a jewel in the roughMr Nonsense is a jewel in the rough
England
Join Date: Apr 2008
Location: London
Posts: 2,211
My Societies
Default HELP PLEASE! - turning points, differentiation and cubics
 
revising for my further pure test at school on monday, and in the textbook there was this question:

consider the quartic equation  x^4 - bx + c = 0

find a relationship between b and c which will ensure that the equation has one real root


I am not really sure at all what to do.... I have differentiated and found the one turning point (i don't think that there are more) -  x = \sqrt[3]{\frac{b}{4}}

and then this gives a horrible value for y, involving lots of cube roots, etc. but i don't really see where it is going. I understand where you have two or three turning points and you want one on either side of the x-axis to get 2 or 4 solutions, but here i have no idea.

So can anyone help? thanks in advance!
 
Register to remove banners from posts.
Old 06-12-2008: 6th December 2008 21:33 #2 
SimonM's Avatar
SimonM SimonM is online now Male
TSR Demigod
SimonM has a ridiculously high reputationSimonM has a ridiculously high reputationSimonM has a ridiculously high reputationSimonM has a ridiculously high reputationSimonM has a ridiculously high reputationSimonM has a ridiculously high reputationSimonM has a ridiculously high reputationSimonM has a ridiculously high reputationSimonM has a ridiculously high reputationSimonM has a ridiculously high reputationSimonM has a ridiculously high reputationSimonM has a ridiculously high reputationSimonM has a ridiculously high reputation
Guernsey
Join Date: Dec 2007
Location: Guernsey
Posts: 6,164
My Societies
Send a message via AIM to SimonM Send a message via MSN to SimonM Send a message via Skype™ to SimonM
Default Re: HELP PLEASE! - turning points, differentiation and cubics
 
One turning point, its going to be a minimum. Be careful when you substitute back in and it comes our reasonably neatly
Old 06-12-2008: 6th December 2008 21:35 #3 
Swayum's Avatar
Swayum Swayum is offline Male
TSR Snake God
Swayum has disabled reputation
Join Date: Apr 2006
Location: My head
My Societies
Default Re: HELP PLEASE! - turning points, differentiation and cubics
 
If it has one turning point and you want one real root, and given that a quartic starts high and ends high (like a parabola), where would be a cunning place to place the turning point in terms of the graph?
 
Old 06-12-2008: 6th December 2008 22:40 #4 
somedumbname somedumbname is offline
New Member
somedumbname will become famous soon enough
Join Date: Dec 2008
Posts: 5
Default Re: HELP PLEASE! - turning points, differentiation and cubics
 
Edit: Never mind.

Last edited by somedumbname : 06-12-2008 at 22:44.

Old 06-12-2008: 6th December 2008 22:41 #5 
generalebriety generalebriety is offline Male
curiously non-spherical
Wiki Support Team
PS Helper
generalebriety has reputation beyond comprehensiongeneralebriety has reputation beyond comprehensiongeneralebriety has reputation beyond comprehensiongeneralebriety has reputation beyond comprehensiongeneralebriety has reputation beyond comprehensiongeneralebriety has reputation beyond comprehensiongeneralebriety has reputation beyond comprehensiongeneralebriety has reputation beyond comprehensiongeneralebriety has reputation beyond comprehensiongeneralebriety has reputation beyond comprehensiongeneralebriety has reputation beyond comprehensiongeneralebriety has reputation beyond comprehensiongeneralebriety has reputation beyond comprehensiongeneralebriety has reputation beyond comprehensiongeneralebriety has reputation beyond comprehensiongeneralebriety has reputation beyond comprehensiongeneralebriety has reputation beyond comprehensiongeneralebriety has reputation beyond comprehensiongeneralebriety has reputation beyond comprehensiongeneralebriety has reputation beyond comprehension
Join Date: Apr 2004
Location: Cambridge
My Societies
Default Re: HELP PLEASE! - turning points, differentiation and cubics
 
Originally Posted by somedumbname
If you want the full solution:

*snip*

Hope that helps.
Since you're new here, I should probably let you know that posting full solutions is typically frowned upon in here - see some of the sticky threads at the top of the maths forum for more information.
 
Old 06-12-2008: 6th December 2008 22:46 #6 
somedumbname somedumbname is offline
New Member
somedumbname will become famous soon enough
Join Date: Dec 2008
Posts: 5
Default Re: HELP PLEASE! - turning points, differentiation and cubics
 
Whoops! Sorry about that
Old 07-12-2008: 7th December 2008 00:38 #7 
Mr Nonsense's Avatar
Mr Nonsense Mr Nonsense is online now Male
Overlord in Training
Thread Starter
Mr Nonsense is a jewel in the roughMr Nonsense is a jewel in the roughMr Nonsense is a jewel in the roughMr Nonsense is a jewel in the rough
England
Join Date: Apr 2008
Location: London
Posts: 2,211
My Societies
Default Re: HELP PLEASE! - turning points, differentiation and cubics
 
Originally Posted by SimonM
One turning point, its going to be a minimum. Be careful when you substitute back in and it comes our reasonably neatly

Originally Posted by Swayum
If it has one turning point and you want one real root, and given that a quartic starts high and ends high (like a parabola), where would be a cunning place to place the turning point in terms of the graph?

Thank you both for your assistance - it is a great help!

I have substituted in the value for x at the turning point and y must = 0 for it to "sit" on the x-axis and this is the coniditon i got:

 256c^3 = 63b^4

Originally Posted by somedumbname
Whoops! Sorry about that
is that the same as you were thinking?

can it be simplified much more?

thanks again! you are all so helpful
 
Old 07-12-2008: 7th December 2008 01:07 #8 
Swayum's Avatar
Swayum Swayum is offline Male
TSR Snake God
Swayum has disabled reputation
Join Date: Apr 2006
Location: My head
My Societies
Default Re: HELP PLEASE! - turning points, differentiation and cubics
 
No, that can't be right.

Choose b = 4, so

256c^3 = 63 * 256
c = cbrt(63) (that's the cube root of 63)

So y = x^4 - 4x + cbrt(63)

Turning point x = 1

But x = 1 clearly doesn't mean y = 0.

*Edit*

I make the answer as

Spoiler:
 

Last edited by Swayum : 07-12-2008 at 04:04.

 
Thread Tools Search this Thread
Search this Thread
Advanced
Search