I was in James Baillie in my first year (I'm now in third year). It has a really large car park, but I can't remember how much the permit was. The accomodation is close to Devonshire, although it's much more modern and much less Oxbridge-like. Almost all of the rooms are ensuite. I know a lot of people think that being really close to campus is a good thing, but I really don't agree. It's nice to be able to escape academic life when you go home at night. I wouldn't want to live in the grounds of a comprehensive school for the same reason. James Baillie is right between campus and Headingley (where I spent more of my time), and is set in lovely grounds. It doesn't have a bar, but with Headingley being a ten minute walk away, you don't need one.
Oh, and I forgot. If you like squirrels, you'll love James Baillie.