Join TSR
 
About Us | FAQs | Sign in
 
Advanced
Search

Join The Student Room Today

Be part of the UK's largest and fastest growing student community.

It's free to join and a lot of fun - Get inspired, express your ideas, interact and share

RSS  Get advice on courses and universities for medical and health subjects including medicine, dentistry, veterinary science, pharmacy, nursing and biochemistry.
Reply
 
Announcements   Posted By
 
All-new Posting Guide! READ!   calcium878
 
Old 20-12-2008: 20th December 2008 13:41 #1 
Polymorphing's Avatar
Polymorphing Polymorphing is offline Male
Exalted Member
Thread Starter
Polymorphing is on a distinguished road
Join Date: Dec 2007
Location: England
My Societies
Default Medicine or Veterinary Science: Which is 'harder'?
 
I was having a debate with my friend about the two courses aforementioned in the title and which one is 'harder'. She wants a career in Veterinary Science whilst I wish to work in Medicine, so there is some bias involved in both our arguments. Of course, first we must define 'harder' and there are many different perspectives from which we can determine the meaning of this word. I wonder whether fellow TSR's could bring fresh views on this debate. A few aspects that have been discussed: the breath of knowledge required, a persons mentality exhausted by the stress of the current sector, the intellectually challenging side of both careers, and the length of time to read the course at University coupled with the years taken to specialise. Think of your own basis for your argument or elaborate on one I have mentioned, but discuss!
 
Register to remove banners from posts.
Old 20-12-2008: 20th December 2008 13:43 #2 
Renal's Avatar
Renal Renal is offline Male
Angry Doctor
Renal  has too much reputation for their own goodRenal  has too much reputation for their own goodRenal  has too much reputation for their own goodRenal  has too much reputation for their own goodRenal  has too much reputation for their own goodRenal  has too much reputation for their own goodRenal  has too much reputation for their own goodRenal  has too much reputation for their own goodRenal  has too much reputation for their own goodRenal  has too much reputation for their own goodRenal  has too much reputation for their own goodRenal  has too much reputation for their own goodRenal  has too much reputation for their own goodRenal  has too much reputation for their own goodRenal  has too much reputation for their own good
Join Date: May 2005
Location: London
Posts: 19,017
My Societies
Default Re: Medicine or Veterinary Science: Which is 'harder'?
 
Career in vet science?
Work in medicine?
:wtf?:
 
Old 20-12-2008: 20th December 2008 13:45 #3 
anna_spanner89's Avatar
anna_spanner89 anna_spanner89 is offline Female
Banned
anna_spanner89 has a ridiculously high reputationanna_spanner89 has a ridiculously high reputationanna_spanner89 has a ridiculously high reputationanna_spanner89 has a ridiculously high reputationanna_spanner89 has a ridiculously high reputationanna_spanner89 has a ridiculously high reputationanna_spanner89 has a ridiculously high reputationanna_spanner89 has a ridiculously high reputationanna_spanner89 has a ridiculously high reputationanna_spanner89 has a ridiculously high reputationanna_spanner89 has a ridiculously high reputationanna_spanner89 has a ridiculously high reputationanna_spanner89 has a ridiculously high reputation
England
Join Date: Mar 2008
Posts: 8,159
My Societies
Default Re: Medicine or Veterinary Science: Which is 'harder'?
 
I guess animals can't tell you how they're feeling or where the pain is...but, at the same time, they're two very different areas, its like saying whats harder, dentistry or medicine..you can't do it as they're different disciplines
Old 20-12-2008: 20th December 2008 13:46 #4 
Cj-Tj Cj-Tj is offline
Vengeful, Imperial Overlord of The Student Room
PS Helper
Cj-Tj has much to be proud ofCj-Tj has much to be proud ofCj-Tj has much to be proud ofCj-Tj has much to be proud ofCj-Tj has much to be proud ofCj-Tj has much to be proud ofCj-Tj has much to be proud ofCj-Tj has much to be proud of
Yorkshire
Join Date: Jun 2006
Location: House
Posts: 4,941
Default Re: Medicine or Veterinary Science: Which is 'harder'?
 
Vet Med is harder, animals cant tell you whats wrong and the anatomy of a sheep is different to that of a parrot, humans tend to be quite similar.
Old 20-12-2008: 20th December 2008 13:46 #5 
.pushing.charlotte.'s Avatar
.pushing.charlotte. .pushing.charlotte. is offline Female
Peer Of The TSR Realm
.pushing.charlotte. has a brilliant future.pushing.charlotte. has a brilliant future.pushing.charlotte. has a brilliant future.pushing.charlotte. has a brilliant future.pushing.charlotte. has a brilliant future.pushing.charlotte. has a brilliant future.pushing.charlotte. has a brilliant future.pushing.charlotte. has a brilliant future.pushing.charlotte. has a brilliant future
South Africa
Join Date: Jan 2008
Location: South Africa and Winchester
Posts: 1,462
My Societies
Default Re: Medicine or Veterinary Science: Which is 'harder'?
 
No idea how hard each course is.
But having heard from both Doctors and Vets, apparently being a vet is harder as the animal cannot tell you exactly what hurts, how long for, symptoms, etc.
Prett basic logic really.
 
Old 20-12-2008: 20th December 2008 13:46 #6 
JennyB JennyB is offline Female
Respected Member
JennyB will become famous soon enough
Join Date: May 2008
Posts: 218
Default Re: Medicine or Veterinary Science: Which is 'harder'?
 
Does it really matter who is doing the harder course? Is this some type of competition?
Old 20-12-2008: 20th December 2008 13:47 #7 
Polymorphing's Avatar
Polymorphing Polymorphing is offline Male
Exalted Member
Thread Starter
Polymorphing is on a distinguished road
Join Date: Dec 2007
Location: England
My Societies
Default Re: Medicine or Veterinary Science: Which is 'harder'?
 
Originally Posted by Renal
Career in vet science?
Work in medicine?
:wtf?:

Why do have to be so pedantic about the words I choose? Do you not understand the meaning?
 
Old 20-12-2008: 20th December 2008 13:47 #8 
Renal's Avatar
Renal Renal is offline Male
Angry Doctor
Renal  has too much reputation for their own goodRenal  has too much reputation for their own goodRenal  has too much reputation for their own goodRenal  has too much reputation for their own goodRenal  has too much reputation for their own goodRenal  has too much reputation for their own goodRenal  has too much reputation for their own goodRenal  has too much reputation for their own goodRenal  has too much reputation for their own goodRenal  has too much reputation for their own goodRenal  has too much reputation for their own goodRenal  has too much reputation for their own goodRenal  has too much reputation for their own goodRenal  has too much reputation for their own goodRenal  has too much reputation for their own good
Join Date: May 2005
Location: London
Posts: 19,017
My Societies
Default Re: Medicine or Veterinary Science: Which is 'harder'?
 
What's does the ******* course matter - it's only five or six years.
 
Old 20-12-2008: 20th December 2008 13:48 #9 
History Lost in Physics's Avatar
History Lost in Physics History Lost in Physics is offline Male
Overlord in Training
History Lost in Physics is a splendid one to beholdHistory Lost in Physics is a splendid one to beholdHistory Lost in Physics is a splendid one to beholdHistory Lost in Physics is a splendid one to beholdHistory Lost in Physics is a splendid one to beholdHistory Lost in Physics is a splendid one to beholdHistory Lost in Physics is a splendid one to behold
United Kingdom
Join Date: Jan 2008
Location: North Somerset (like a big vat of cider))
Posts: 2,962
Default Re: Medicine or Veterinary Science: Which is 'harder'?
 
Oh for god's sake... My daddy's willy is better than your daddy's willy...
 
Old 20-12-2008: 20th December 2008 13:49 #10 
Renal's Avatar
Renal Renal is offline Male
Angry Doctor
Renal  has too much reputation for their own goodRenal  has too much reputation for their own goodRenal  has too much reputation for their own goodRenal  has too much reputation for their own goodRenal  has too much reputation for their own goodRenal  has too much reputation for their own goodRenal  has too much reputation for their own goodRenal  has too much reputation for their own goodRenal  has too much reputation for their own goodRenal  has too much reputation for their own goodRenal  has too much reputation for their own goodRenal  has too much reputation for their own goodRenal  has too much reputation for their own goodRenal  has too much reputation for their own goodRenal  has too much reputation for their own good
Join Date: May 2005
Location: London
Posts: 19,017
My Societies
Default Re: Medicine or Veterinary Science: Which is 'harder'?
 
Originally Posted by Polymorphing
Why do have to be so pedantic about the words I choose? Do you not understand the meaning?
Because I like it when people make sense.

A career in vetinary science? Why bother becoming a vet if you want to sit in a lab all day?

What the **** is working in medicine? Nursing, HCAing, physioing? If you want to work 'in medicine' why would you want to be a doctor?
 
Old 20-12-2008: 20th December 2008 13:50 #11 
Polymorphing's Avatar
Polymorphing Polymorphing is offline Male
Exalted Member
Thread Starter
Polymorphing is on a distinguished road
Join Date: Dec 2007
Location: England
My Societies
Default Re: Medicine or Veterinary Science: Which is 'harder'?
 
Originally Posted by .pushing.charlotte.
No idea how hard each course is.
But having heard from both Doctors and Vets, apparently being a vet is harder as the animal cannot tell you exactly what hurts, how long for, symptoms, etc.
Prett basic logic really.

What about when a person is unconscious?
 
Old 20-12-2008: 20th December 2008 13:50 #12 
anna_spanner89's Avatar
anna_spanner89 anna_spanner89 is offline Female
Banned
anna_spanner89 has a ridiculously high reputationanna_spanner89 has a ridiculously high reputationanna_spanner89 has a ridiculously high reputationanna_spanner89 has a ridiculously high reputationanna_spanner89 has a ridiculously high reputationanna_spanner89 has a ridiculously high reputationanna_spanner89 has a ridiculously high reputationanna_spanner89 has a ridiculously high reputationanna_spanner89 has a ridiculously high reputationanna_spanner89 has a ridiculously high reputationanna_spanner89 has a ridiculously high reputationanna_spanner89 has a ridiculously high reputationanna_spanner89 has a ridiculously high reputation
England
Join Date: Mar 2008
Posts: 8,159
My Societies
Default Re: Medicine or Veterinary Science: Which is 'harder'?
 
Originally Posted by History Lost in Physics
Oh for god's sake... My daddy's willy is better than your daddy's willy...


my dad will pound your dad up the arse



joke courtesy of frankie boyle...
Old 20-12-2008: 20th December 2008 13:51 #13 
History Lost in Physics's Avatar
History Lost in Physics History Lost in Physics is offline Male
Overlord in Training
History Lost in Physics is a splendid one to beholdHistory Lost in Physics is a splendid one to beholdHistory Lost in Physics is a splendid one to beholdHistory Lost in Physics is a splendid one to beholdHistory Lost in Physics is a splendid one to beholdHistory Lost in Physics is a splendid one to beholdHistory Lost in Physics is a splendid one to behold
United Kingdom
Join Date: Jan 2008
Location: North Somerset (like a big vat of cider))
Posts: 2,962
Default Re: Medicine or Veterinary Science: Which is 'harder'?
 
Originally Posted by anna_spanner89
my dad will pound your dad up the arse



joke courtesy of frankie boyle...

lol! That would probably be quite a good as idea as he seems to be terrified of gay people.
 
Old 20-12-2008: 20th December 2008 13:52 #14 
anna_spanner89's Avatar
anna_spanner89 anna_spanner89 is offline Female
Banned
anna_spanner89 has a ridiculously high reputationanna_spanner89 has a ridiculously high reputationanna_spanner89 has a ridiculously high reputationanna_spanner89 has a ridiculously high reputationanna_spanner89 has a ridiculously high reputationanna_spanner89 has a ridiculously high reputationanna_spanner89 has a ridiculously high reputationanna_spanner89 has a ridiculously high reputationanna_spanner89 has a ridiculously high reputationanna_spanner89 has a ridiculously high reputationanna_spanner89 has a ridiculously high reputationanna_spanner89 has a ridiculously high reputationanna_spanner89 has a ridiculously high reputation
England
Join Date: Mar 2008
Posts: 8,159
My Societies
Default Re: Medicine or Veterinary Science: Which is 'harder'?
 
Originally Posted by Polymorphing
What about when a person is unconscious?


not many patients are found unconcious without no history, symptoms etc...
Old 20-12-2008: 20th December 2008 13:55 #15 
Polymorphing's Avatar
Polymorphing Polymorphing is offline Male
Exalted Member
Thread Starter
Polymorphing is on a distinguished road
Join Date: Dec 2007
Location: England
My Societies
Default Re: Medicine or Veterinary Science: Which is 'harder'?
 
Originally Posted by Renal
Because I like it when people make sense.

A career in vetinary science? Why bother becoming a vet if you want to sit in a lab all day?

What the **** is working in medicine? Nursing, HCAing, physioing? If you want to work 'in medicine' why would you want to be a doctor?

I must say it does make sense, work and career are interchangeable in my expression. In my view, work can be defined as 'the occupation for which you are paid and career as 'the particular occupation for which you are trained'.

Are you also saying that a doctor does not work in (the field of) medicine?
 
Old 20-12-2008: 20th December 2008 13:57 #16 
Renal's Avatar
Renal Renal is offline Male
Angry Doctor
Renal  has too much reputation for their own goodRenal  has too much reputation for their own goodRenal  has too much reputation for their own goodRenal  has too much reputation for their own goodRenal  has too much reputation for their own goodRenal  has too much reputation for their own goodRenal  has too much reputation for their own goodRenal  has too much reputation for their own goodRenal  has too much reputation for their own goodRenal  has too much reputation for their own goodRenal  has too much reputation for their own goodRenal  has too much reputation for their own goodRenal  has too much reputation for their own goodRenal  has too much reputation for their own goodRenal  has too much reputation for their own good
Join Date: May 2005
Location: London
Posts: 19,017
My Societies
Default Re: Medicine or Veterinary Science: Which is 'harder'?
 
Originally Posted by Polymorphing
I must say it does make sense, work and career are interchangeable in my expression. In my view, work can be defined as 'the occupation for which you are paid and career as 'the particular occupation for which you are trained'.
Do you speak English as a first language?


Are you also saying that a doctor does not work in (the field of) medicine?
No, but doctoring isn't the only career option in 'medicine', so why do you want to do it?
 
Old 20-12-2008: 20th December 2008 13:59 #17 
SiaSiaSia's Avatar
SiaSiaSia SiaSiaSia is offline
wouldn't wanna be her.
SiaSiaSia has a ridiculously high reputationSiaSiaSia has a ridiculously high reputationSiaSiaSia has a ridiculously high reputationSiaSiaSia has a ridiculously high reputationSiaSiaSia has a ridiculously high reputationSiaSiaSia has a ridiculously high reputationSiaSiaSia has a ridiculously high reputationSiaSiaSia has a ridiculously high reputationSiaSiaSia has a ridiculously high reputationSiaSiaSia has a ridiculously high reputationSiaSiaSia has a ridiculously high reputationSiaSiaSia has a ridiculously high reputationSiaSiaSia has a ridiculously high reputation
Sweden
Join Date: May 2008
Posts: 4,892
My Societies
Send a message via AIM to SiaSiaSia
Default Re: Medicine or Veterinary Science: Which is 'harder'?
 
I can't really contribute on the difficulty... but why does it matter which one is more/less difficult anyway?
 
Old 20-12-2008: 20th December 2008 13:59 #18 
anna_spanner89's Avatar
anna_spanner89 anna_spanner89 is offline Female
Banned
anna_spanner89 has a ridiculously high reputationanna_spanner89 has a ridiculously high reputationanna_spanner89 has a ridiculously high reputationanna_spanner89 has a ridiculously high reputationanna_spanner89 has a ridiculously high reputationanna_spanner89 has a ridiculously high reputationanna_spanner89 has a ridiculously high reputationanna_spanner89 has a ridiculously high reputationanna_spanner89 has a ridiculously high reputationanna_spanner89 has a ridiculously high reputationanna_spanner89 has a ridiculously high reputationanna_spanner89 has a ridiculously high reputationanna_spanner89 has a ridiculously high reputation
England
Join Date: Mar 2008
Posts: 8,159
My Societies
Default Re: Medicine or Veterinary Science: Which is 'harder'?
 
Originally Posted by Renal
Do you speak English as a first language?


[b]No, but doctoring isn't the only career option in 'medicine', so why do you want to do it?


because it'll make mummy and daddy happy?
Old 20-12-2008: 20th December 2008 14:03 #19 
Polymorphing's Avatar
Polymorphing Polymorphing is offline Male
Exalted Member
Thread Starter
Polymorphing is on a distinguished road
Join Date: Dec 2007
Location: England
My Societies
Default Re: Medicine or Veterinary Science: Which is 'harder'?
 
Originally Posted by Renal
Do you speak English as a first language?

Yes

Originally Posted by Renal
No, but doctoring isn't the only career option in 'medicine', so why do you want to do it?
I have my own personal reasons which I will share at interview but will not do so on the web.

I don't understand why you have commented on this thread because you don't seem to have contributed anything worthwhile.
 

Last edited by Polymorphing : 20-12-2008 at 14:12.

Old 20-12-2008: 20th December 2008 14:08 #20 
Profesh's Avatar
Profesh Profesh is offline
TSR Royalty
Profesh has reputation beyond comprehensionProfesh has reputation beyond comprehensionProfesh has reputation beyond comprehensionProfesh has reputation beyond comprehensionProfesh has reputation beyond comprehensionProfesh has reputation beyond comprehensionProfesh has reputation beyond comprehensionProfesh has reputation beyond comprehensionProfesh has reputation beyond comprehensionProfesh has reputation beyond comprehensionProfesh has reputation beyond comprehensionProfesh has reputation beyond comprehensionProfesh has reputation beyond comprehensionProfesh has reputation beyond comprehensionProfesh has reputation beyond comprehensionProfesh has reputation beyond comprehensionProfesh has reputation beyond comprehensionProfesh has reputation beyond comprehensionProfesh has reputation beyond comprehension
Join Date: Nov 2004
My Societies
Default Re: Medicine or Veterinary Science: Which is 'harder'?
 
Originally Posted by Polymorphing
I must say it does make sense, work and career are interchangeable in my expression. In my view, work can be defined as 'the occupation for which you are paid and career as 'the particular occupation for which you are trained'.

You mean 'profession' or 'vocation'. A 'career' simply implies sustained commitment to a single occupation or avenue of employment.
 
 
Thread Tools Search this Thread
Search this Thread
Advanced
Search