Join TSR
 
About Us | FAQs | Sign in
 
Advanced
Search

Join The Student Room Today

Be part of the UK's largest and fastest growing student community.

It's free to join and a lot of fun - Get inspired, express your ideas, interact and share

RSS  Welcome to the University of Oxford forum: where prospective and current students can discuss anything about Oxford.
Reply
 
Announcements   Posted By
 
All-new Posting Guide! READ!   calcium878
 
Old 13-01-2009: 13th January 2009 23:23 #1 
superkam superkam is offline Male
Full Member
Thread Starter
superkam will become famous soon enough
Join Date: Apr 2008
Location: sheffield
Posts: 139
Default Still no feedback
 
Hi i got rejected from christ church oxford for physics before an interview, in the rejection letter it said they would soon be sending some feedback to my school, however my school havent recieved anything yet and i want to know how well i need in my aptitude test, seeing as they sent my rejection letter last year surely the feedback should be here now? just wondered if anyone else was rejected without an interview and still hasnt recieved feedback.
 
Register to remove banners from posts.
Old 14-01-2009: 14th January 2009 17:19 #2 
Angelil's Avatar
Angelil Angelil is offline Female
TSR Francophile
Angelil  has too much reputation for their own goodAngelil  has too much reputation for their own goodAngelil  has too much reputation for their own goodAngelil  has too much reputation for their own goodAngelil  has too much reputation for their own goodAngelil  has too much reputation for their own goodAngelil  has too much reputation for their own goodAngelil  has too much reputation for their own goodAngelil  has too much reputation for their own goodAngelil  has too much reputation for their own goodAngelil  has too much reputation for their own goodAngelil  has too much reputation for their own goodAngelil  has too much reputation for their own goodAngelil  has too much reputation for their own goodAngelil  has too much reputation for their own good
England
Join Date: Mar 2004
Location: Paris
Posts: 16,394
My Societies
Send a message via MSN to Angelil
Default Re: Still no feedback
 
When I was rejected some years ago (2003 for 2004 entry), my school claimed that Oxford weren't sending feedback anymore as there were too many applicants for them to bother. Since applications to university have increased overall since then, and applicants in the current cycle ARE receiving feedback (I work in an international school in France and all of our Oxbridge applicants have received feedback), I have come to the conclusion that for whatever reason my school did not want me to see any feedback that the university sent. This may or may not be the case at your school. Keep pushing for it and make clear that you can take it like a man, as it were, no matter how harsh the feedback's contents.
 
Old 14-01-2009: 14th January 2009 17:21 #3 
H.JT's Avatar
H.JT H.JT is offline Female
Full Member
H.JT will become famous soon enough
United Kingdom
Join Date: Sep 2008
Location: UK
Posts: 105
My Societies
Default Re: Still no feedback
 
Apparently the majority of the "feedback" are just a copy of the letter you received.


You will get the results to the aptitude test though. Didn't some people get it with their letters?
 
Old 14-01-2009: 14th January 2009 18:02 #4 
cpchem cpchem is online now Male
Vengeful, Imperial Overlord of The Student Room
PS Helper
cpchem has more reputation than sensecpchem has more reputation than sensecpchem has more reputation than sensecpchem has more reputation than sensecpchem has more reputation than sensecpchem has more reputation than sensecpchem has more reputation than sensecpchem has more reputation than sensecpchem has more reputation than sensecpchem has more reputation than sensecpchem has more reputation than sensecpchem has more reputation than sense
Join Date: Nov 2005
Location: Oxford/London
My Societies
Default Re: Still no feedback
 
Originally Posted by Angelil
When I was rejected some years ago (2003 for 2004 entry), my school claimed that Oxford weren't sending feedback anymore as there were too many applicants for them to bother. Since applications to university have increased overall since then, and applicants in the current cycle ARE receiving feedback (I work in an international school in France and all of our Oxbridge applicants have received feedback), I have come to the conclusion that for whatever reason my school did not want me to see any feedback that the university sent. This may or may not be the case at your school. Keep pushing for it and make clear that you can take it like a man, as it were, no matter how harsh the feedback's contents.
That's probably not especially fair. Whether or not you get any feedback is dependent on college policy, as well as whether or not the tutors in question can be bothered.
 
Old 14-01-2009: 14th January 2009 18:17 #5 
thomasjtl thomasjtl is offline Male
Vengeful, Imperial Overlord of The Student Room
thomasjtl has a reputation beyond reputethomasjtl has a reputation beyond reputethomasjtl has a reputation beyond reputethomasjtl has a reputation beyond reputethomasjtl has a reputation beyond reputethomasjtl has a reputation beyond reputethomasjtl has a reputation beyond reputethomasjtl has a reputation beyond reputethomasjtl has a reputation beyond reputethomasjtl has a reputation beyond reputethomasjtl has a reputation beyond repute
St Helena
Join Date: Dec 2005
Location: ox/cam term/vac
Posts: 3,961
Default Re: Still no feedback
 
most feedback these days isn't particularly informative, just that they had lots of applicants etc. but it's not unusual for it to take a long while for it come- it might not come 'til like easter in some cases.
 
Old 16-01-2009: 16th January 2009 18:44 #6 
Jessikkaaa Jessikkaaa is offline
New Member
Jessikkaaa will become famous soon enough
Join Date: Dec 2008
Posts: 21
Default Feedback from Oxford?
 
Has anyone got feedbacks from Oxford?

When do they come?

And if you have got one, what did it say?
Old 16-01-2009: 16th January 2009 18:54 #7 
Cocaine Socialist's Avatar
Cocaine Socialist Cocaine Socialist is offline Male
Overlord in Training
Cocaine Socialist has a reputation beyond reputeCocaine Socialist has a reputation beyond reputeCocaine Socialist has a reputation beyond reputeCocaine Socialist has a reputation beyond reputeCocaine Socialist has a reputation beyond reputeCocaine Socialist has a reputation beyond reputeCocaine Socialist has a reputation beyond reputeCocaine Socialist has a reputation beyond reputeCocaine Socialist has a reputation beyond reputeCocaine Socialist has a reputation beyond reputeCocaine Socialist has a reputation beyond repute
International Brigades
Join Date: Aug 2005
Location: on edge
Posts: 2,169
Default Re: Feedback from Oxford?
 
Mine said I'm a wonderful dancer.
Old 16-01-2009: 16th January 2009 19:27 #8 
2strong 2strong is offline Male
Adored and Respected Member
2strong is on a distinguished road
Join Date: Apr 2008
Location: .
Posts: 433
Default How do I go about requesting feedback?
 
I applied for EM at Worcester college if that makes any difference. How should I go about asking for feedback?

I sat the TSA, I know the results for that come out sometime near the end of January, does feedback come with that?
Old 18-01-2009: 18th January 2009 19:30 #9 
GilbertLam GilbertLam is offline
Adored and Respected Member
GilbertLam will become famous soon enoughGilbertLam will become famous soon enough
Join Date: Oct 2008
Location: Eastbourne
Posts: 452
Default Do I email admissions tutors for feedback?
 
As I will be reapplying next year, I think feedback on my interviews would be of valuable use. However I haven't received it yet so I'm thinking of emailing Oxford. Who do I email?

I'm also not very sure of what to say - I don't want to sound bitter, rude or antagonistic. I'm thinking of keeping it short and to the point, something along the lines of:

'Dear professor ...,

Due to my unsuccessful application this year, I am seriously considering in reapplying to Oxford. Would it be possible to receive feedback on my interview performance so I have an idea on what areas to work on for my reapplication?

Kind regards,

Me'

Does that sound alright?
Old 18-01-2009: 18th January 2009 19:42 #10 
jonnymoblin's Avatar
jonnymoblin jonnymoblin is offline Male
Respected Member
jonnymoblin has a spectacular aura aboutjonnymoblin has a spectacular aura about
United Kingdom
Join Date: Jan 2007
Location: Tewkesbury
Posts: 171
My Societies
Default Re: Do I email admissions tutors for feedback?
 
I think what you write should be fine - I would e-mail it either to the admissions office if the college you applied to has one or to the Admissions Tutor for the subject and college you applied to - the college websites should have all the info.
 
Old 18-01-2009: 18th January 2009 19:45 #11 
nuodai's Avatar
nuodai nuodai is offline Male
TSR Demigod
PS Helper
nuodai has more reputation than sensenuodai has more reputation than sensenuodai has more reputation than sensenuodai has more reputation than sensenuodai has more reputation than sensenuodai has more reputation than sensenuodai has more reputation than sensenuodai has more reputation than sensenuodai has more reputation than sensenuodai has more reputation than sensenuodai has more reputation than sensenuodai has more reputation than sense
European Union
Join Date: Jan 2008
Location: Cambridge / Yorkshire
Default Re: Do I email admissions tutors for feedback?
 
I wouldn't mention reapplying, really. Also, from your wording, it makes it sound like you want to reapply because they rejected you (not because you want to be there or anything like that ). I'd word it something like:

"Due to my unsuccessful application, I would like to ask if it is possible to receive feedback on my interview performance, as it would help me greatly in the future."

Or something like that.
 
Old 18-01-2009: 18th January 2009 19:47 #12 
pineapplesmoothie's Avatar
pineapplesmoothie pineapplesmoothie is offline Female
Adored and Respected Member
pineapplesmoothie has a spectacular aura aboutpineapplesmoothie has a spectacular aura aboutpineapplesmoothie has a spectacular aura about
United Kingdom
Join Date: Oct 2008
Location: Manchester
Posts: 433
Default Re: Do I email admissions tutors for feedback?
 
I agree with not mentioning re-applying! Go with the suggestion in the previous post!
 
Old 18-01-2009: 18th January 2009 21:31 #13 
GilbertLam GilbertLam is offline
Adored and Respected Member
GilbertLam will become famous soon enoughGilbertLam will become famous soon enough
Join Date: Oct 2008
Location: Eastbourne
Posts: 452
Default Re: Feedback from Oxford?
 
What's wrong with mentioning reapplying? They will inevitably find out that I'm a reapplicant right?
Old 18-01-2009: 18th January 2009 22:11 #14 
The_Lonely_Goatherd The_Lonely_Goatherd is offline Female
TSR Idol
PS Helper
The_Lonely_Goatherd has a ridiculously high reputationThe_Lonely_Goatherd has a ridiculously high reputationThe_Lonely_Goatherd has a ridiculously high reputationThe_Lonely_Goatherd has a ridiculously high reputationThe_Lonely_Goatherd has a ridiculously high reputationThe_Lonely_Goatherd has a ridiculously high reputationThe_Lonely_Goatherd has a ridiculously high reputationThe_Lonely_Goatherd has a ridiculously high reputationThe_Lonely_Goatherd has a ridiculously high reputationThe_Lonely_Goatherd has a ridiculously high reputationThe_Lonely_Goatherd has a ridiculously high reputationThe_Lonely_Goatherd has a ridiculously high reputationThe_Lonely_Goatherd has a ridiculously high reputation
Sri Lanka
Join Date: Apr 2008
Location: London!
Posts: 8,126
My Societies
Default Re: Feedback from Oxford?
 
Not necessarily. I don't think there would be any way of them realising until the tutors' meetings when the Magdalen tutor would be like "Oh yeah, he was there last year" if he recognises your photo.

Don't e-mail him direct: use nuodai's swish wording and e-mail the admissions tutor at Magdalen
 
Old 18-01-2009: 18th January 2009 22:30 #15 
Old Timer's Avatar
Old Timer Old Timer is offline Male
Respected Member
Old Timer is infamous around these partsOld Timer is infamous around these partsOld Timer is infamous around these parts
Join Date: Mar 2008
Location: Oxford
Posts: 202
Default Re: Feedback from Oxford?
 
You may get it and find it isn't useful. They often cannot be too specific for a number of reasons: people going to the press, little to say, too many people to give detailed comments &etc.
Think about why you wish to reapply and whether your chances will be any better. What could you have done better this time? Unless you were a totally unsuitable applicant then there may not be much difference between you and someone with an offer. If you reject other Universities will they offer you a place next year or will you burn your bridges? If it worth starting life a year later just for another crack at Oxford, or better to get on with things?
 
Old 18-01-2009: 18th January 2009 23:26 #16 
JW's Avatar
JW JW is offline Male
Peer Of The TSR Realm
JW has much to be proud ofJW has much to be proud ofJW has much to be proud ofJW has much to be proud ofJW has much to be proud ofJW has much to be proud ofJW has much to be proud ofJW has much to be proud of
England
Join Date: May 2007
Location: Surrey
Default Re: Do I email admissions tutors for feedback?
 
Originally Posted by GilbertLam
As I will be reapplying next year, I think feedback on my interviews would be of valuable use. However I haven't received it yet so I'm thinking of emailing Oxford. Who do I email?

I'm also not very sure of what to say - I don't want to sound bitter, rude or antagonistic. I'm thinking of keeping it short and to the point, something along the lines of:

'Dear professor ...,

Due to my unsuccessful application this year, I am seriously considering in reapplying to Oxford. Would it be possible to receive feedback on my interview performance so I have an idea on what areas to work on for my reapplication?

Kind regards,

Me'

Does that sound alright?

Why are you set on reapplying before you've even received feedback?
 
Old 19-01-2009: 19th January 2009 21:31 #17 
GilbertLam GilbertLam is offline
Adored and Respected Member
GilbertLam will become famous soon enoughGilbertLam will become famous soon enough
Join Date: Oct 2008
Location: Eastbourne
Posts: 452
Default Re: Do I email admissions tutors for feedback?
 
Originally Posted by JW
Why are you set on reapplying before you've even received feedback?

I just have something within me that's driving me to reapply. I fell in love with the people and atmosphere while I was there so that is my main reason - originally I didn't even care for Oxford one bit, but something changed. Who knows, I may change my mind in 6 months time, I may not achieve my predicted grades etc but at the moment it's what I want to do. Feedback will be very helpful generally, even if I decide not to reapply.

Besides, I didn't plan my gap year properly. I might as well give Oxford another stab, I've got nothing to lose. As for KCL (my second option), if I get an offer there I will consider my options carefully as I don't want to lose the offer by reapplying. But I'm willing to take a risk.
Old 20-01-2009: 20th January 2009 12:32 #18 
Jessikkaaa Jessikkaaa is offline
New Member
Jessikkaaa will become famous soon enough
Join Date: Dec 2008
Posts: 21
Default Re: Do I email admissions tutors for feedback?
 
Originally Posted by GilbertLam
I just have something within me that's driving me to reapply. I fell in love with the people and atmosphere while I was there so that is my main reason - originally I didn't even care for Oxford one bit, but something changed. Who knows, I may change my mind in 6 months time, I may not achieve my predicted grades etc but at the moment it's what I want to do. Feedback will be very helpful generally, even if I decide not to reapply.

Besides, I didn't plan my gap year properly. I might as well give Oxford another stab, I've got nothing to lose. As for KCL (my second option), if I get an offer there I will consider my options carefully as I don't want to lose the offer by reapplying. But I'm willing to take a risk.


WOW you're just like me!
my second choice is KCL too
but I love oxford tooo mcuh
and I'm gonna reapply!
Old 20-01-2009: 20th January 2009 13:10 #19 
Old Timer's Avatar
Old Timer Old Timer is offline Male
Respected Member
Old Timer is infamous around these partsOld Timer is infamous around these partsOld Timer is infamous around these parts
Join Date: Mar 2008
Location: Oxford
Posts: 202
Default Re: Feedback from Oxford?
 
I love the idea of winning the lottery. It doesn't mean I keep playing it at the expense of other things.

Think carefully about what you might be turning down and what your chances are. I'm not being negative, but realistic. If, however, you think you have a good chance make sure you strengthen your CV as much as possible. But don't think that Oxford is the be all and end all. You can make it, in every sense of the term, from any university or none if you try hard enough.

Good luck.
 
Old 21-01-2009: 21st January 2009 18:22 #20 
super-emily's Avatar
super-emily super-emily is offline Female
Benevolent Member
super-emily is a splendid one to beholdsuper-emily is a splendid one to beholdsuper-emily is a splendid one to beholdsuper-emily is a splendid one to beholdsuper-emily is a splendid one to beholdsuper-emily is a splendid one to beholdsuper-emily is a splendid one to behold
Join Date: Nov 2008
Location: Canterbury
My Societies
Default Re: Feedback from Oxford?
 
I applied for History and English at Wadham, got rejected, and today I received feedback for 'History and Joint Honours'. It was general 'every-applicant' stuff; how many applicants, how many places, 'such a difficult decision' etc. However, it didn't have HAT scores.

Maybe I'll get an English reply as well, or not. If not I'll probably ask my referee to email and ask for more personalised information.
 
 
Thread Tools Search this Thread
Search this Thread
Advanced
Search