The Student Room Group

Scroll to see replies

Reply 60
Eric Qin
In China, different religions can co-exist, the west can never achieve this point.
This is the dross in your culture.


Considering the fact that you practically got rid of religion I'm not sure your in a position to judge atm, since it's not long since you could express religions that openly. But if you ask me the only reason religion can exist side by side in the East is because, they are generally non combative, I mean Taoists and Buddhists aren't exactly likely to kick off. Or for example Muslims and Budhists. Stick a load of Christians in close proximity to a nation of Muslims or Hindus though and it'll kick off soon enough, trust me. Put some Jews near the Muslims and well fireworks baby :eek:. Some would claim the dross in society is religion itself as well. and that the only way it can co-exist peacefully is to do the communist thing and restrict it or destroy it entirely. I disagree just make sure it has no power over anything but spiritual matters and you should be fine. Restricting religion completely is much worse than the alternative, it just gets bitter and separatist.
I talked to an evangelical Christian friends of mine about this, except it wasn't specific to athiests.

Ok basically she thinks Jesus was perfect, God in human form or something, so without sin. However every human being who has ever lived, who lives now, and who will live in the future - however "nice" they are - is not without sin in the same was as Jesus. We all lie sometime in our lives, etc ...

God accepts this and that you can't very well ALL go to hell. That's why Jesus died despite doing no wrong, to die for people sins. Thus even if you're a sinful person (and indeed you are, we all are, even Martin Luthur King etc) you can gain forgiveness and salvation by loving Jesus and what he did for you.

Thus a murderer with faith in Jesus will go to the kingdom of heaven and a charity worker without faith in Jesus will NOT go to the kingdom of heaven.

This is the religious persons prespective on this, personally I'm an athiest who is convinced that the bible is nothing but political propaganda against Jews ....
Reply 62
tis_me_lord
I talked to an evangelical Christian friends of mine about this, except it wasn't specific to athiests..


Ah, no offence to your friends but evangelical Christianity is a total mess of contradiction. I mean you have to be spectacularly unwilling to embrace logic and reason to make up creationism as a viable alternative to evolution. If you ask me the best and most coherent idea of religion in Christianity is Orthodox, the first Christian religion (technically). After that it all went gradually pear shaped.

The ideas they have on sin and redemption fit very well with The Bible, and at least some sort of logic. For example if you sin even in a minor way you must repent and do some sort of good work to make up for it. And if your sin is serious then you become unable to even attend church and temporarily sinful/apostate. And of course cardinal sins require massive commitments to overturn that sin. This to me says: yeah you're getting into heaven theoretically but you can't just get there on a mountain of sin, skulls and inequity.
Reply 63
JMonkey
Considering the fact that you practically got rid of religion I'm not sure your in a position to judge atm, since it's not long since you could express religions that openly. But if you ask me the only reason religion can exist side by side in the East is because, they are generally non combative, I mean Taoists and Buddhists aren't exactly likely to kick off. Or for example Muslims and Budhists. Stick a load of Christians in close proximity to a nation of Muslims or Hindus though and it'll kick off soon enough, trust me. Put some Jews near the Muslims and well fireworks baby :eek:. Some would claim the dross in society is religion itself as well. and that the only way it can co-exist peacefully is to do the communist thing and restrict it or destroy it entirely. I disagree just make sure it has no power over anything but spiritual matters and you should be fine. Restricting religion completely is much worse than the alternative, it just gets bitter and separatist.

You were brainwashed by your government, in my country, there're mainly 5 religions, Christianism (my grandmum is a Christian), Islam, Buddhism, Daoism and even Confucianism.
In China there're three kinds of harmony, Daoism, the harmony with the nature, Confucianism, the harmony with the society, Zen, the harmony with oneself.

Saying that Chinese government oppresses the religious freedom is nonsense, the fact is the western culture is too tiny, but the characteristic of our culture is we can accept different things and co-exist with them, but you can't!
Eric Qin
You were brainwashed by your government, in my country, there're mainly 5 religions, Christianism (my grandmum is a Christian), Islam, Buddhism, Daoism and even Confucianism.
In China there're three kinds of harmony, Daoism, the harmony with the nature, Confucianism, the harmony with the society, Zen, the harmony with oneself.

Saying that Chinese government oppresses the religious freedom is nonsense, the fact is the western culture is too tiny, but the characteristic of our culture is we can accept different things and co-exist with them, but you can't!


You are aware that the protestant reformation took place in Europe, yes?

Please, read - http://www.religioustolerance.org/rt_china.htm
Reply 65
Eric Qin
You were brainwashed by your government, in my country, there're mainly 5 religions, Christianism (my grandmum is a Christian), Islam, Buddhism, Daoism and even Confucianism.
In China there're three kinds of harmony, Daoism, the harmony with the nature, Confucianism, the harmony with the society, Zen, the harmony with oneself.

Saying that Chinese government oppresses the religious freedom is nonsense, the fact is the western culture is too tiny, but the characteristic of our culture is we can accept different things and co-exist with them, but you can't!


Me brainwashed. I can vote for more than one party! :tongue:

In a country where the government controls if not inhibits all forms of free expression, it's probably not a good idea to accuse liberal countries of being brainwashed. I've met plenty of Russians who thought Stalin was a God and a merciful and great man, having never heard about the ~3-16 million people who died under his rule. You may have religious freedom now, and more Western values, but I'd be wary of mocking that which is spoon fed to you by a government who has 100% control practically over nearly everything you see in the media. Ask yourself are you getting the full story? Because I don't trust my news media and it is at least free of control...

I did say that's why China is ok, it's religions are not mutually exclusive enough and it's population too diverse to really have direct conflict. It's not a good idea to compare Europe though it's an unfair comparison.

you might be surprised at what is going on in the real world, when you finally do get democracy as well.
Reply 66
JMonkey
Me brainwashed. I can vote for more than one party! :tongue:

In a country where the government controls if not inhibits all forms of free expression, it's probably not a good idea to accuse liberal countries of being brainwashed. I've met plenty of Russians who thought Stalin was a God and a merciful and great man, having never heard about the ~3-16 million people who died under his rule. You may have religious freedom now, and more Western values, but I'd be wary of mocking that which is spoon fed to you by a government who has 100% control practically over nearly everything you see in the media. Ask yourself are you getting the full story? Because I don't trust my news media and it is at least free of control...

I did say that's why China is ok, it's religions are not mutually exclusive enough and it's population too diverse to really have direct conflict. It's not a good idea to compare Europe though it's an unfair comparison.

you might be surprised at what is going on in the real world, when you finally do get democracy as well.

Guy, I do not want to give a lecture on democracy, general election doesn't mean democracy, every western country is controlled by macro-corporations and big families, but not the people, have you seen the protest and demonstration on your streets? Why? Why several years ago, there's no so severe demonstration?
The cheap products from the developing countries make the ordinary westerner blind to their problems.
It's naive to think the west is democratic.
I don't want to give your a lecture on that, it costs too much time.

It's your choice to think your media system is free, the fact is I have free acess to the western media, I saw most of your reports are biased with fake photos, you live in this environment, so you will not be aware of that.

The west is absolutely undemocratic, I can tell you, the so called western-style democracy is just the tool of your politicians to fool you people.
My words might not be powerful, only when you confront more and more financial crisis, you will understand my words.
Reply 67
khalaf
But please explain to me why he would send you to heaven when the only thing he told you to do, believe in him and be obedient to him, wasn't done?? Why would you expect that he will let you go to heaven if you don't even give him the benefit of the doubt that he is, in fact, your creator?


Well if people are not brought up in a religious family and have never had access to a bible or been taught much about religion surely it is expected that they grow up as athiests? You know if they have done good all there life why should they be sent to hell.
Eric Qin
Guy, I do not want to give a lecture on democracy, general election doesn't mean democracy, every western country is controlled by macro-corporations and big families, but not the people, have you seen the protest and demonstration on your streets? Why? Why several years ago, there's no so severe demonstration?
The cheap products from the developing countries make the ordinary westerner blind to their problems.
It's naive to think the west is democratic.
I don't want to give your a lecture on that, it costs too much time.

It's your choice to think your media system is free, the fact is I have free acess to the western media, I saw most of your reports are biased with fake photos, you live in this environment, so you will not be aware of that.

The west is absolutely undemocratic, I can tell you, the so called western-style democracy is just the tool of your politicians to fool you people.
My words might not be powerful, only when you confront more and more financial crisis, you will understand my words.


From this post, I must conclude that you're a ********-talking know-nothing. There's not a single coherent point in there.
Reply 69
ForeverIsMyName
From this post, I must conclude that you're a ********-talking know-nothing. There's not a single coherent point in there.

The westerners are misinformed for nearly a century.
Only one thing can waken you, the rise of China, otherwise you do not know how to see this world, you will not think actively with your brain.
Reply 70
ForeverIsMyName
From this post, I must conclude that you're a ********-talking know-nothing. There's not a single coherent point in there.

I know one thing, you people are pround of your system, called democratic system, de facto was controlled by big families (like Bush familiy) and macro-corporations (especially ammunition industry in US).

Telling you the truth is just like telling you there's no god in the world, you will be hurt mentally.
Reply 71
Eric Qin
Guy, I do not want to give a lecture on democracy, general election doesn't mean democracy, every western country is controlled by macro-corporations and big families, but not the people, have you seen the protest and demonstration on your streets? Why? Why several years ago, there's no so severe demonstration?
The cheap products from the developing countries make the ordinary westerner blind to their problems.
It's naive to think the west is democratic.
I don't want to give your a lecture on that, it costs too much time.


It's naive to think that communist China is more democratic and free. And you accuse me of being brainwashed?


It's your choice to think your media system is free, the fact is I have free acess to the western media, I saw most of your reports are biased with fake photos, you live in this environment, so you will not be aware of that.

I said I don't trust my media, already. How can you trust yours though, I mean it doesn't even hide the fact that it is feeding you only what it wants you to hear?


The west is absolutely undemocratic, I can tell you, the so called western-style democracy is just the tool of your politicians to fool you people.
My words might not be powerful, only when you confront more and more financial crisis, you will understand my words.

Lol I'd take that a lot more seriously if I wasn't likely to be run over by tanks for protesting against the government. Free protest, free voting, freedom to leave the country, freedom of religious expression, freedom of the press to print anything at all, freedom of industry (which you call corporate control). you do know that a company cannot publicly or privately fund any law or campaign in government, and any sign of bribery means dismissal from government. I think you are thinking of the US where the whole system is funded by business. General in the more socialist Europe business has a great deal less input. The Chinese government is even more corrupt than the US government as well. But generally European governments have the least amount of corruption in the world, and the most universally free system too.
AMillionFilaments
Nice post.. SO true.

Wow, just got neg repped for this. And the message was just "God".

Very insightful. Thanks to whoever that was :smile:
Reply 73
dude, if you're an atheist you dont beleive god, heaven or hell exists, so erm.... you're not going to go anywhere unless you believe in god...
Reply 74
Reply 75
JMonkey
It's naive to think that communist China is more democratic and free. And you accuse me of being brainwashed?



I said I don't trust my media, already. How can you trust yours though, I mean it doesn't even hide the fact that it is feeding you only what it wants you to hear?



Lol I'd take that a lot more seriously if I wasn't likely to be run over by tanks for protesting against the government. Free protest, free voting, freedom to leave the country, freedom of religious expression, freedom of the press to print anything at all, freedom of industry (which you call corporate control). you do know that a company cannot publicly or privately fund any law or campaign in government, and any sign of bribery means dismissal from government. I think you are thinking of the US where the whole system is funded by business. General in the more socialist Europe business has a great deal less input.

One party system has nothing wrong, the fact is we have 9 parties, 8 minor party and one ruling party.
The compitition also exists in our system, everyone can apply for the membership of CCP, everyone has the chance to compete for higher position.
Our system assures the unity of our country and also doesn't neglect the supervision. That's why we achieved a lot in the last 3 decades, thought that's not enough.

Saying that the western countries are liberal is a big joke. I'd like to take your system as a part of your soft power, which makes your government more arrogant envolving in world's affairs, they can accuse other countries, which increased their bargain chip.

Thinking who fund those president candidates? What should the president do to his or her supporters, after he or she is elected as the president?
Easy to understand?

Yes, you can choose a president from several parties, it's just a show, a big show only! There's no difference, whether Obama or Mccain was elected. A single man can not change the history.

Let the fact to educate your people, I don't want to waste my ink to teach you what is real democracy.

But I think your government will continue to propagandize the western-style democracy across the world, whilst people of the world are just taking them as clowns, watching the soap opera.

Use your brain, guy.
Reply 76
The religion is just the collection of the fables in its origin.
As long as the religions is in accordance with the profits of the rulers or dictators, they will adopt this religion and propadandize it widely, make the people believe them, the practical aim is it's easier to control people's thoughts!

Later on, arts, literature, ect were put into the religion, the religion was expanded, its meaning and significance were expanded, sometimes it's more like a philosophy, psychology and ethnics.

Any religion, who still exists in the world, accompanies this way of development, no exception!
Reply 77
Eric Qin
One party system has nothing wrong, the fact is we have 9 parties, 8 minor party and one ruling party.
The compitition also exists in our system, everyone can apply for the membership of CCP, everyone has the chance to compete for higher position.
Our system assures the unity of our country and also doesn't neglect the supervision. That's why we achieved a lot in the last 3 decades, thought that's not enough.


Well to be honest I don't know where to start with how wrong a one party system is. But let's face it a history lesson into Chinese communism is a good start. Let's face it millions of people don't tend to die of starvation under Western systems. That said like you I don't have the ink to teach you what democracy really means. Suffice to say if you think it's all pulling in the same direction you are wrong. Diversity is strength in any system that isn't doomed to fail.


Saying that the western countries are liberal is a big joke. I'd like to take your system as a part of your soft power, which makes your government more arrogant envolving in world's affairs, they can accuse other countries, which increased their bargain chip.


I can have 100 children, vote every 6 years or not for whomever I think is best to rule the country, get rid of governments that suck by the same means. You however are lumbered if your government is particularly poor. And let's face it the reason you are doing better now is you have embraced Western capitalism, given out more freedoms and unrestricted expression to some extent. So how you can blame the medicine (Western liberalism) that is effecting your increase in wealth, I don't know.


Thinking who fund those president candidates? What should the president do to his or her supporters, after he or she is elected as the president?
Easy to understand?


I'm European, no one is allowed to finance our ministers, they can't even sponsor companies or do anything involved directly with promoting business. You're attacking the US and I agree their system is far to influenced by business. But even so it's better than Chinas.


Yes, you can choose a president from several parties, it's just a show, a big show only! There's no difference, whether Obama or Mccain was elected. A single man can not change the history.


Well it's a good job we elect each member of our parliament by way of local elections as well then. You then get a change of membership of the whole of parliament in every period of voting. And you still get two parties able to block a bad governments bad policies. Unlike in communism where you are given free reign.


Let the fact to educate your people, I don't want to waste my ink to teach you what is real democracy.


No offence but you really need to study modern political systems a great deal more before you are able to compare and contrast.


But I think your government will continue to propagandize the western-style democracy across the world, whilst people of the world are just taking them as clowns, watching the soap opera.

Use your brain, guy.


The antithesis of democracy to me is proselytising or as you put it propagandising. There is no democracy without the right to self determination and I have no interest in telling another country how to run itself. I can however see what is a better form of government. The funny thing is you are moving ever more towards a Western style government, and at the same time bitterly denouncing it, even though it has brought you prosperity? I find that ironic to say the least...
Reply 78
Atheists are made of diamond and therefore will not melt!
Reply 79
JMonkey
Well to be honest I don't know where to start with how wrong a one party system is. But let's face it a history lesson into Chinese communism is a good start. Let's face it millions of people don't tend to die of starvation under Western systems. That said like you I don't have the ink to teach you what democracy really means. Suffice to say if you think it's all pulling in the same direction you are wrong. Diversity is strength in any system that isn't doomed to fail.

I can have 100 children, vote every 4 years or not for whomever I think is best to rule the country, get rid of governments that suck by the same means. You however are lumbered if your government is particularly poor. And let's face it the reason you are doing better now is you have embraced Western capitalism, given out more freedoms and unrestricted expression to some extent. So how you can blame the medicine (Western liberalism) that is effecting your increase in wealth, I don't know.

I'm European, no one is allowed to finance our ministers, they can't even sponsor companies or do anything involved directly with promoting business. Your attacking the US and I agree their system is far to influenced by business. But even so it's better than Chinas.

Well it's a good job we elect each member of our parliament by way of local elections as well then. You then get a change of membership of the whole of parliament in every period of voting. And you still get two parties able to block a bad governments bad policies. Unlike in communism where you are given free reign.

No offence but you really need to study modern political systems a great dea more before you are able to compare and contrast.

The antithesis of democracy to me is proselytising or as you put it propagandising. There is no democracy without the right to self determination and I have no interest in telling another country how to run itself. I can however see what is a better form of government. The funny thing is you are moving ever more towards a Western style government, and at the same time bitterly denouncing it, even though it has brought you prosperity? I find that ironic to say the least...

Let's stop debating. When you can see the real world, come to tell me, then let's debate. When you can have a really free media system, you will begin to understand your system.
Only the fact can educate your people. People can learn very quickly, only when they get hurt.

Latest

Trending

Trending