Join TSR
 
About Us | FAQs | Sign in
 
Advanced
Search

Join The Student Room Today

Be part of the UK's largest and fastest growing student community.

It's free to join and a lot of fun - Get inspired, express your ideas, interact and share

RSS  TSR's model parliament.
Reply
Useful Resources:
 
Announcements   Posted By
 
Old 25-05-2009: 25th May 2009 16:13 #81 
Alasdair's Avatar
Alasdair Alasdair is offline Male
El pueblo unidos jamas sera vencido!
Alasdair has reputation coming out of their earsAlasdair has reputation coming out of their earsAlasdair has reputation coming out of their earsAlasdair has reputation coming out of their earsAlasdair has reputation coming out of their earsAlasdair has reputation coming out of their earsAlasdair has reputation coming out of their earsAlasdair has reputation coming out of their earsAlasdair has reputation coming out of their earsAlasdair has reputation coming out of their earsAlasdair has reputation coming out of their earsAlasdair has reputation coming out of their earsAlasdair has reputation coming out of their earsAlasdair has reputation coming out of their earsAlasdair has reputation coming out of their earsAlasdair has reputation coming out of their earsAlasdair has reputation coming out of their ears
International Brigades
Join Date: May 2006
Location: Leamington Spa
Posts: 12,917
My Societies
Send a message via MSN to Alasdair
Default Re: Ask a Tory Thread
 
Originally Posted by davireland
Yes because it means a right wing party can never win an election, dont you tihnk thats a tad unfair?

What?! How on earth is it unfair that less votes = less chance of forming a government?
Register to remove banners from posts.
Old 25-05-2009: 25th May 2009 16:15 #82 
davireland's Avatar
davireland davireland is offline Male
TSR Demigod
PS Helper
Thread Starter
davireland has a reputation beyond reputedavireland has a reputation beyond reputedavireland has a reputation beyond reputedavireland has a reputation beyond reputedavireland has a reputation beyond reputedavireland has a reputation beyond reputedavireland has a reputation beyond reputedavireland has a reputation beyond reputedavireland has a reputation beyond reputedavireland has a reputation beyond reputedavireland has a reputation beyond repute
England
Join Date: Mar 2007
Location: Reading & Guildford
Posts: 5,229
My Societies
Default Re: Ask a Tory Thread
 
Originally Posted by Alasdair
What?! How on earth is it unfair that less votes = less chance of forming a government?

So the party that performs best in an election can simply be ganged up on is fair?
 
Old 25-05-2009: 25th May 2009 16:15 #83 
retroprincess's Avatar
retroprincess retroprincess is offline Female
Full Member
retroprincess will become famous soon enoughretroprincess will become famous soon enough
United Kingdom
Join Date: Dec 2008
Location: Plymouth
Posts: 117
Default Re: Ask a Tory Thread
 
Who would you say are your main supporters? just out of intrest
Old 25-05-2009: 25th May 2009 16:17 #84 
Mrgd291190's Avatar
Mrgd291190 Mrgd291190 is offline Male
Secretary General
Forum Assistant
Mrgd291190 has more reputation than senseMrgd291190 has more reputation than senseMrgd291190 has more reputation than senseMrgd291190 has more reputation than senseMrgd291190 has more reputation than senseMrgd291190 has more reputation than senseMrgd291190 has more reputation than senseMrgd291190 has more reputation than senseMrgd291190 has more reputation than senseMrgd291190 has more reputation than senseMrgd291190 has more reputation than senseMrgd291190 has more reputation than sense
United Nations
Join Date: Sep 2007
Location: Rhyl, North Wales, Europe, Earth
Posts: 5,441
My Societies
Default Re: Ask a Tory Thread
 
Originally Posted by Bagration
That sounds pretty Socialist to mee.

But not to me. Or the rest of the LibDems. Or Socialists. Or Labour. Just because we're partially on the left doesn't mean we should forget our centrist leanings and it doesn't mean we're Socialists.

Like who exactly?

They can identify themselves, as I've said before to L i b , I don't want to show who would have preferred a coalition with the centre-right, as it discloses what happens in our sub-forum.

Well that would solve a lot of problems and I have suggested that in the past.

If I'm honest, I would like to see this, to a degree. It would mean you could never have had an issue with our coalition. But then again, why are the Right not a single party?

If you can find "numerous issues" where you are on a common ground with us, then what the hell are you doing in a coalition with the Socialists and Labour with whom we have basically no common ground?

I'm sure you don't have much common ground with the Socialists and Labour but we do. We also have some common ground with the Tories. We have common ground with the Libertarians.
Old 25-05-2009: 25th May 2009 16:17 #85 
Teigan Teigan is offline Female
Exalted and Worshipped Member
Teigan is a splendid one to beholdTeigan is a splendid one to beholdTeigan is a splendid one to beholdTeigan is a splendid one to beholdTeigan is a splendid one to beholdTeigan is a splendid one to beholdTeigan is a splendid one to behold
Join Date: Sep 2008
Location: Surrey
Posts: 954
Default Re: Ask a Tory Thread
 
Originally Posted by Mrgd291190
There are right wing members of our party.

Really? I don't recall any of them voting against the railways nationalisation bill.
 
Old 25-05-2009: 25th May 2009 16:19 #86 
Mrgd291190's Avatar
Mrgd291190 Mrgd291190 is offline Male
Secretary General
Forum Assistant
Mrgd291190 has more reputation than senseMrgd291190 has more reputation than senseMrgd291190 has more reputation than senseMrgd291190 has more reputation than senseMrgd291190 has more reputation than senseMrgd291190 has more reputation than senseMrgd291190 has more reputation than senseMrgd291190 has more reputation than senseMrgd291190 has more reputation than senseMrgd291190 has more reputation than senseMrgd291190 has more reputation than senseMrgd291190 has more reputation than sense
United Nations
Join Date: Sep 2007
Location: Rhyl, North Wales, Europe, Earth
Posts: 5,441
My Societies
Default Re: Ask a Tory Thread
 
Originally Posted by Teigan
Really? I don't recall any of them voting against the railways nationalisation bill.

Please see my answer to L i b
http://www.thestudentroom.co.uk/show...4&postcount=67


I never denied that the majority of our party are towards the left but we are still very centrist.
Old 25-05-2009: 25th May 2009 16:19 #87 
Metrobeans's Avatar
Metrobeans Metrobeans is offline Male
Vengeful, Imperial Overlord of The Student Room
Metrobeans has a ridiculously high reputationMetrobeans has a ridiculously high reputationMetrobeans has a ridiculously high reputationMetrobeans has a ridiculously high reputationMetrobeans has a ridiculously high reputationMetrobeans has a ridiculously high reputationMetrobeans has a ridiculously high reputationMetrobeans has a ridiculously high reputationMetrobeans has a ridiculously high reputationMetrobeans has a ridiculously high reputationMetrobeans has a ridiculously high reputationMetrobeans has a ridiculously high reputationMetrobeans has a ridiculously high reputation
Jamaica
Join Date: Mar 2006
Location: Yorkshire/London
Posts: 3,520
My Societies
Default Re: Ask a Tory Thread
 
How can the Tories accuse our coalition of being a "marriage of convenience", when they approached the Socialists for a coalition last session? Do they realise that their self-righteous bitching smacks of hypocrisy?
 
Old 25-05-2009: 25th May 2009 16:20 #88 
davireland's Avatar
davireland davireland is offline Male
TSR Demigod
PS Helper
Thread Starter
davireland has a reputation beyond reputedavireland has a reputation beyond reputedavireland has a reputation beyond reputedavireland has a reputation beyond reputedavireland has a reputation beyond reputedavireland has a reputation beyond reputedavireland has a reputation beyond reputedavireland has a reputation beyond reputedavireland has a reputation beyond reputedavireland has a reputation beyond reputedavireland has a reputation beyond repute
England
Join Date: Mar 2007
Location: Reading & Guildford
Posts: 5,229
My Societies
Default Re: Ask a Tory Thread
 
Originally Posted by retroprincess
Who would you say are your main supporters? just out of intrest

Just about anyone that is interested in individuality, meritocracy and a free economy.
 
Old 25-05-2009: 25th May 2009 16:20 #89 
CyclopsRock CyclopsRock is offline
Exalted and Worshipped Member
CyclopsRock has more reputation than senseCyclopsRock has more reputation than senseCyclopsRock has more reputation than senseCyclopsRock has more reputation than senseCyclopsRock has more reputation than senseCyclopsRock has more reputation than senseCyclopsRock has more reputation than senseCyclopsRock has more reputation than senseCyclopsRock has more reputation than senseCyclopsRock has more reputation than senseCyclopsRock has more reputation than senseCyclopsRock has more reputation than sense
Join Date: Mar 2009
Posts: 1,139
Default Re: Ask a Tory Thread
 
Originally Posted by Mrgd291190
We have common ground with the Libertarians.

No you don't. Or, rather, no more than any of the parties here. We're all students - who is homophobic or racist or any of the other socially illiberal things? That's the only ground our parties share (again, like all parties); please don't say things like the above. It makes us look bad.
Old 25-05-2009: 25th May 2009 16:21 #90 
Indievertigo's Avatar
Indievertigo Indievertigo is offline Male
Vengeful, Imperial Overlord of The Student Room
Indievertigo has a reputation beyond reputeIndievertigo has a reputation beyond reputeIndievertigo has a reputation beyond reputeIndievertigo has a reputation beyond reputeIndievertigo has a reputation beyond reputeIndievertigo has a reputation beyond reputeIndievertigo has a reputation beyond reputeIndievertigo has a reputation beyond reputeIndievertigo has a reputation beyond reputeIndievertigo has a reputation beyond reputeIndievertigo has a reputation beyond repute
Scotland
Join Date: Jun 2006
Location: Scotland
Default Re: Ask a Tory Thread
 
I'm going to propose an amendment that forces any coalition (government) to be formed with the party that has the largest number of seats. I don't know if I've got my party's support on it, because I've literally just decided that that's the best way forward.
 

Last edited by Indievertigo : 25-05-2009 at 16:25.

Old 25-05-2009: 25th May 2009 16:23 #91 
Matthew_Lowson Matthew_Lowson is offline Male
Peer Of The TSR Realm
Matthew_Lowson is a splendid one to beholdMatthew_Lowson is a splendid one to beholdMatthew_Lowson is a splendid one to beholdMatthew_Lowson is a splendid one to beholdMatthew_Lowson is a splendid one to beholdMatthew_Lowson is a splendid one to beholdMatthew_Lowson is a splendid one to behold
United Kingdom
Join Date: Aug 2008
Location: Sheffield
Posts: 1,886
Default Re: Ask a Tory Thread
 
Originally Posted by Metrobeans
How can the Tories accuse our coalition of being a "marriage of convenience", when they approached the Socialists for a coalition last session? Do they realise that their self-righteous bitching smacks of hypocrisy?

Because all you have sought is the governmentship, and you defended the speaker after he broke the rules - and justified it by saying not us, blame the man who knew the rules.

You do know that your lead partner did approach us asking to be in an administration led by us. Or did Dayne keep that from you
 
Old 25-05-2009: 25th May 2009 16:23 #92 
Teigan Teigan is offline Female
Exalted and Worshipped Member
Teigan is a splendid one to beholdTeigan is a splendid one to beholdTeigan is a splendid one to beholdTeigan is a splendid one to beholdTeigan is a splendid one to beholdTeigan is a splendid one to beholdTeigan is a splendid one to behold
Join Date: Sep 2008
Location: Surrey
Posts: 954
Default Re: Ask a Tory Thread
 
Originally Posted by Mrgd291190
Please see my answer to L i b
http://www.thestudentroom.co.uk/show...4&postcount=67


I never denied that the majority of our party are towards the left but we are still very centrist.

Are there any 'right wing' Lib Dem MPs?
 
Old 25-05-2009: 25th May 2009 16:24 #93 
Mrgd291190's Avatar
Mrgd291190 Mrgd291190 is offline Male
Secretary General
Forum Assistant
Mrgd291190 has more reputation than senseMrgd291190 has more reputation than senseMrgd291190 has more reputation than senseMrgd291190 has more reputation than senseMrgd291190 has more reputation than senseMrgd291190 has more reputation than senseMrgd291190 has more reputation than senseMrgd291190 has more reputation than senseMrgd291190 has more reputation than senseMrgd291190 has more reputation than senseMrgd291190 has more reputation than senseMrgd291190 has more reputation than sense
United Nations
Join Date: Sep 2007
Location: Rhyl, North Wales, Europe, Earth
Posts: 5,441
My Societies
Default Re: Ask a Tory Thread
 
Originally Posted by CyclopsRock
No you don't. Or, rather, no more than any of the parties here. We're all students - who is homophobic or racist or any of the other socially illiberal things? That's the only ground our parties share (again, like all parties); please don't say things like the above. It makes us look bad.

That's exactly what I intended. We have common ground with all parties. I assume you're liberal on e.g. drug legislation and the like? Thus we have more in common than we would with other parties.
Just because we disagree on economic matters, I'd assume, I'd say that socially, we're probably going to be in agreement more often than not. Or, I'd hope so.
Looking at some people on TSR, all students, a hell of a lot are socially illiberal.

Wow, sorry if it makes you look bad, that I think I agree with you on some matters. That's a true tragedy, I'm sure.
Old 25-05-2009: 25th May 2009 16:25 #94 
Mrgd291190's Avatar
Mrgd291190 Mrgd291190 is offline Male
Secretary General
Forum Assistant
Mrgd291190 has more reputation than senseMrgd291190 has more reputation than senseMrgd291190 has more reputation than senseMrgd291190 has more reputation than senseMrgd291190 has more reputation than senseMrgd291190 has more reputation than senseMrgd291190 has more reputation than senseMrgd291190 has more reputation than senseMrgd291190 has more reputation than senseMrgd291190 has more reputation than senseMrgd291190 has more reputation than senseMrgd291190 has more reputation than sense
United Nations
Join Date: Sep 2007
Location: Rhyl, North Wales, Europe, Earth
Posts: 5,441
My Societies
Default Re: Ask a Tory Thread
 
Originally Posted by Teigan
Are there any 'right wing' Lib Dem MPs?

This is going off-topic rapidly, feel free to ask in our question thread. But on the whole, I'd say there would be one or two. But once again, I won't give names.
Old 25-05-2009: 25th May 2009 16:30 #95 
Metrobeans's Avatar
Metrobeans Metrobeans is offline Male
Vengeful, Imperial Overlord of The Student Room
Metrobeans has a ridiculously high reputationMetrobeans has a ridiculously high reputationMetrobeans has a ridiculously high reputationMetrobeans has a ridiculously high reputationMetrobeans has a ridiculously high reputationMetrobeans has a ridiculously high reputationMetrobeans has a ridiculously high reputationMetrobeans has a ridiculously high reputationMetrobeans has a ridiculously high reputationMetrobeans has a ridiculously high reputationMetrobeans has a ridiculously high reputationMetrobeans has a ridiculously high reputationMetrobeans has a ridiculously high reputation
Jamaica
Join Date: Mar 2006
Location: Yorkshire/London
Posts: 3,520
My Societies
Default Re: Ask a Tory Thread
 
Originally Posted by Matthew_Lowson
Because all you have sought is the governmentship, and you defended the speaker after he broke the rules - and justified it by saying not us, blame the man who knew the rules.

You do know that your lead partner did approach us asking to be in an administration led by us. Or did Dayne keep that from you
I am well aware that there was discussion between the Lib Dems and your party. I would have been suprised if Dayne hadn't considered all of his options.

Do you accept that your party leader is a hypocrite?
 
Old 25-05-2009: 25th May 2009 16:35 #96 
davireland's Avatar
davireland davireland is offline Male
TSR Demigod
PS Helper
Thread Starter
davireland has a reputation beyond reputedavireland has a reputation beyond reputedavireland has a reputation beyond reputedavireland has a reputation beyond reputedavireland has a reputation beyond reputedavireland has a reputation beyond reputedavireland has a reputation beyond reputedavireland has a reputation beyond reputedavireland has a reputation beyond reputedavireland has a reputation beyond reputedavireland has a reputation beyond repute
England
Join Date: Mar 2007
Location: Reading & Guildford
Posts: 5,229
My Societies
Default Re: Ask a Tory Thread
 
Originally Posted by Metrobeans
How can the Tories accuse our coalition of being a "marriage of convenience", when they approached the Socialists for a coalition last session? Do they realise that their self-righteous bitching smacks of hypocrisy?

That was to prove a point, against yours and the Lib Dems inactivity, it was in no way politically motivated.
 
Old 25-05-2009: 25th May 2009 16:39 #97 
davireland's Avatar
davireland davireland is offline Male
TSR Demigod
PS Helper
Thread Starter
davireland has a reputation beyond reputedavireland has a reputation beyond reputedavireland has a reputation beyond reputedavireland has a reputation beyond reputedavireland has a reputation beyond reputedavireland has a reputation beyond reputedavireland has a reputation beyond reputedavireland has a reputation beyond reputedavireland has a reputation beyond reputedavireland has a reputation beyond reputedavireland has a reputation beyond repute
England
Join Date: Mar 2007
Location: Reading & Guildford
Posts: 5,229
My Societies
Default Re: Ask a Tory Thread
 
Originally Posted by Metrobeans
Do you accept that your party leader is a hypocrite?

Can you please stop with the personal attacks, Nick ive never ever said anything like that about you, I dont come in here to be labelled a hypocrite by you or insulted by Alasdair.
 
Old 25-05-2009: 25th May 2009 16:43 #98 
Metrobeans's Avatar
Metrobeans Metrobeans is offline Male
Vengeful, Imperial Overlord of The Student Room
Metrobeans has a ridiculously high reputationMetrobeans has a ridiculously high reputationMetrobeans has a ridiculously high reputationMetrobeans has a ridiculously high reputationMetrobeans has a ridiculously high reputationMetrobeans has a ridiculously high reputationMetrobeans has a ridiculously high reputationMetrobeans has a ridiculously high reputationMetrobeans has a ridiculously high reputationMetrobeans has a ridiculously high reputationMetrobeans has a ridiculously high reputationMetrobeans has a ridiculously high reputationMetrobeans has a ridiculously high reputation
Jamaica
Join Date: Mar 2006
Location: Yorkshire/London
Posts: 3,520
My Societies
Default Re: Ask a Tory Thread
 
Originally Posted by davireland
Can you please stop with the personal attacks, Nick ive never ever said anything like that about you, I dont come in here to be labelled a hypocrite by you or insulted by Alasdair.
I don't believe it's a personal attack. You and other members of your party have been questioning and attacking the Lib Dems on how they fit in with the coalition based on their ideology. Considering the parties you've approached in the past, I think "hypocrite" is a fair description of you and your party.
 
Old 25-05-2009: 25th May 2009 16:44 #99 
smalltownboy's Avatar
smalltownboy smalltownboy is online now Male
Overlord in Training
PS Helper
smalltownboy has more reputation than sensesmalltownboy has more reputation than sensesmalltownboy has more reputation than sensesmalltownboy has more reputation than sensesmalltownboy has more reputation than sensesmalltownboy has more reputation than sensesmalltownboy has more reputation than sensesmalltownboy has more reputation than sensesmalltownboy has more reputation than sensesmalltownboy has more reputation than sensesmalltownboy has more reputation than sensesmalltownboy has more reputation than sense
European Union
Join Date: Nov 2007
Location: Manchester/Sussex
Posts: 3,332
My Societies
Send a message via MSN to smalltownboy
Default Re: Ask a Tory Thread
 
Tbh you deserve insults. This day of posting has seen the most pathetic, whiny, insubstantial and frankly ridiculous posts I have ever seen in the HoC. Why couldn't you have simply accepted that we made a coalition that had more votes than yours? Do the useless titles mean that much to you? How can you accuse us of being too partisan and then say how you will vote against an amendment to specifically allow more than 2 parties in a coalition because you won't "ever get in government" (erm, who was in government last term?)? You have unashamedly thrown all of your toys out of the pram and have revealed to the House that you have no right to ever earn votes from the public again.
 
Old 25-05-2009: 25th May 2009 16:48 #100 
davireland's Avatar
davireland davireland is offline Male
TSR Demigod
PS Helper
Thread Starter
davireland has a reputation beyond reputedavireland has a reputation beyond reputedavireland has a reputation beyond reputedavireland has a reputation beyond reputedavireland has a reputation beyond reputedavireland has a reputation beyond reputedavireland has a reputation beyond reputedavireland has a reputation beyond reputedavireland has a reputation beyond reputedavireland has a reputation beyond reputedavireland has a reputation beyond repute
England
Join Date: Mar 2007
Location: Reading & Guildford
Posts: 5,229
My Societies
Default Re: Ask a Tory Thread
 
Originally Posted by smalltownboy
Tbh you deserve insults. This day of posting has seen the most pathetic, whiny, insubstantial and frankly ridiculous posts I have ever seen in the HoC. Why couldn't you have simply accepted that we made a coalition that had more votes than yours? Do the useless titles mean that much to you? How can you accuse us of being too partisan and then say how you will vote against an amendment to specifically allow more than 2 parties in a coalition because you won't "ever get in government" (erm, who was in government last term?)? You have unashamedly thrown all of your toys out of the pram and have revealed to the House that you have no right to ever earn votes from the public again.

It wasnt about the titles, because like people have said government means nothing, what i resent is working hard to get a decent election result and getting the most ever seats a tory party has recieved and yet still not be declared as the winners, its like whats the point of even bothering with this anymore?
 
 
Thread Tools