'The Artificer is defined as a Staff Sergeant or Warrant Officer' - I dont know where you got that from, thats totally farse. The Artificer course only goes to PO, No higher for any Artificer branch within the Navy.
'He must... be prepared to assume personal responsibility for carrying out military and engineering tasks.' - So does the AEM out there working on the front-line.
'completion of an artificer course confirms their potential for the highest non-commissioned rank' - As Ive stated above, it doesn't confirm that you are gonna make it to WO.
'Their education and training is structured so as to enable them to understand and remedy failures both in equipments covered by their engineering discipline and others for which they have received no formal training' - Umm.. they have recieved no formal education on how the hydraulics work, but they can work on it? Ludacris - If that Aircraft falls out the sky and the Aircrew die with it, and the guy working on it, overseeing the AB's and LH's doing maintenance to it isn't qualified.. you have any idea of the repercussions?
'They perform duties at a higher level of responsibility than that of a technician or artisan, either independently or under the general direction of an Engineering Officer' - I know I'm nit-picking here.. but - If a CPOAEM tells a POAEA what to do, he does it.
'They must ensure that they complete their military or technical tasks regardless of local circumstances and survive, fight and work in all phases of war' - As does the Stores Accountant.
'Intellectually they need to be aware of current political, social, military and technical affairs and will be able to represent them to their soldiers' - Ok, I'll take you're word on that.. The LAEA in charge of my block didn't have the first clue into whats happening.
I was an Air Engineering Technician selected for fast track promotion to Petty Officer and doing the Air Engineering Artificer course all of a month and a half ago doing a *Foundation* Degree in Aeronautical Engineering, compare that to the EngO who has a full degree. Yes, the Engineering Officer may not be out there getting his hands dirty, but he is where the buck stops, and the OU - some may.. most don't from experience of speaking to many of them on there Killicks/PO courses and my DO was a CPOAEA(M) and he doesn't, nor was the POAEA(L) who was teaching us the course.