The Student Room Group

Tax or Auditing?

I did an internship in personal tax this summer and enjoyed it. However, I think there are a lot more Auditing internship places than tax? Am I right? I am not sure whether I should apply for tax or auditing. On one hand I had experience in tax but on the other hand there are fewer tax internship places. I dont know what to do ? :s-smilie:
Reply 1
Tax
Mainly office based with largely fixed hours.
A range of clients in one day (timesheets can get annoying because of this though).
Go through the whole tax compliance process, from raw y/e data to the final tax forms.
Pays slightly more.
More specialised knowledge than audit but you do receive both accounting and tax qualifications.

Audit
Get to see all the clients' offices. Many of the big clients have amazing canteens.
Paid travel to the clients so that adds to your income. May mean longer hours commuting to work though.
At busy times of he year you may be working until 8/9pm.
Can be more boring than tax because your just box ticking but you can to interact with clients a lot more.

Don't forget that you do secondments. I'm personally going into tax because of the KPMG Tax Business school, dual qualifications, fixed hours and the ability to try other departments via secondments. I could always move into audit if I got bored of tax but it would be difficult to move into tax from audit.
Kemik
Tax
Mainly office based with largely fixed hours.
A range of clients in one day (timesheets can get annoying because of this though).
Go through the whole tax compliance process, from raw y/e data to the final tax forms.
Pays slightly more.
More specialised knowledge than audit but you do receive both accounting and tax qualifications.

Audit
Get to see all the clients' offices. Many of the big clients have amazing canteens.
Paid travel to the clients so that adds to your income. May mean longer hours commuting to work though.
At busy times of he year you may be working until 8/9pm.
Can be more boring than tax because your just box ticking but you can to interact with clients a lot more.

Don't forget that you do secondments. I'm personally going into tax because of the KPMG Tax Business school, dual qualifications, fixed hours and the ability to try other departments via secondments. I could always move into audit if I got bored of tax but it would be difficult to move into tax from audit.


Thanks for the input. I was looking at PWC internship program and they only have tax in two of their regional offices (none of the london offices). Does this mean 90% (guestimate) of the internship places are for auditing?
Reply 3
prospectivEEconomist
Thanks for the input. I was looking at PWC internship program and they only have tax in two of their regional offices (none of the london offices). Does this mean 90% (guestimate) of the internship places are for auditing?


I'd assume something along those lines yes. I was quite surprised to see the PWC office below the KPMG one. It's literally half the size. KPMG run a whole floor, PWC run half of one.
Reply 4
Kemik
I'd assume something along those lines yes. I was quite surprised to see the PWC office below the KPMG one. It's literally half the size. KPMG run a whole floor, PWC run half of one.

Can you talk with your colleagues when auditing? To make things less boring.
Reply 5
Mr Kipling
Can you talk with your colleagues when auditing? To make things less boring.


I'm in tax so I hardly see the audit team, they're always at clients. I'm pretty sure they chat to each other inbetween work though yeah :yes:
Kemik
I'd assume something along those lines yes. I was quite surprised to see the PWC office below the KPMG one. It's literally half the size. KPMG run a whole floor, PWC run half of one.


This sounds stupid but I don't really care which section I work in. Do you think Tax is more competitive even after taking into account I have done one tax internship?
Reply 7
I have the same problem- I cant decide between Reorganisation/Recovery services or Audit. And as I found out at today's Deloitte insight day, there are only 7 places in Reorganisation services in London, 2 of which have already been taken, meaning there are 5 places left for 2010 intake O_O. Think I'll go for audit instead...
Reply 8
From doing an internship with KPMG this summer, I know that a lot of people working in tax have lost their jobs and so there isn't going to be a significant number of graduates taken on. Compared to audit, which hasn't been significantly effected by the financial crisis and where the graduate intake is still pretty good.

Which is better I am not sure. Go for tax if you want to work regular hours and not have significant travel to work.

If you work in audit you will work longer hours and have a lot more travel, espicially if you are in a regional office. The benefits are that you are not in the same office every day and you get to work with different people on a regular basis.

Really depends on what you would prefer. Those working in audit say they would hate to work in tax and visa versa.
Reply 9
donaldduck
From doing an internship with KPMG this summer, I know that a lot of people working in tax have lost their jobs and so there isn't going to be a significant number of graduates taken on. Compared to audit, which hasn't been significantly effected by the financial crisis and where the graduate intake is still pretty good


Which office where you based at out of interest?

Latest

Trending

Trending