Revision:Challenges To Religious Experiences - Essay Plan - The Student Room
The Student Room

Revision:Challenges To Religious Experiences - Essay Plan

TSR Wiki > Study Help > Subjects and Revision > Revision Notes > Philosophy > Challenges To Religious Experiences - Essay Plan


Describe and illustrate The Argument from Religious Experience.

(explanation of view + examples + key philosopher/s + key vocabulary)


Type 1: I have had an experience I am certain is God. I have no reason to doubt this experience. Therefore God exists. –Principle of Credulity: our experiences are a good guide to how things really are.

Type 2: I have heard reports from others of their experiences of God. I have no reason to doubt these reports. Therefore God exists. –Principle of Testimony; unless we have reason not to, we should believe others. –RICHARD SWINBURNE.


First objection to the view (+ example)

  • We cannot be certain a religious experience is real.

Response to objection that could be given or has been given

  • There are ways of testing, e.g. seeing how much impact the experience has had on the individual (e.g. their happiness, good deeds etc).

Conclusion on effectiveness of first objection

  • Such methods only test whether they believe the experience to be true. Not whether it is really true.


Second objection to the view (+ e.g.)

  • Religious people usually have these experiences and so their interpretation is biased to believe it is God.

Response to objection that could be given or has been given

  • There is no reason to assume religious people are less reliable than non believers. They are more open to experiences, which is why they have them more.

Conclusion on effectiveness of second objection

  • Religious people would be more likely to interpret the experience as God, as they are predisposed to believe. However, this is no grounds to dismiss their experiences-they could still be true.


Third objection to the view (+ e.g.)

  • Even if the person is in a “normal” state, we can still doubt them. Often our senses deceive us, e.g. optical illusions.

Response to objection that could be given or has been given

  • Just because our senses sometimes deceive us, we have no reason to generalise and say that all religious experiences are illusions.

Conclusion on effectiveness of third objection

  • It seems unreasonable to generalise and say all experiences are unreal, however it also seems unreasonable to assume that all experiences are real!


Overall conclusion on the view in question (+ some idea of a better alternative position if you think the view fails)

As there is little evidence with which to verify religious claims, we cannot be certain religious experiences are valid. People could have these experiences, however there is no proof that these are caused by a God, and therefore the argument is flawed in proving the existence of a God.


Comments

Discussions Toggle
Healthy New You: Your Change For Life #2
started by: xoxAngel_Kxox
forum: Fitness
replies: 155
last post: 1 Minute Ago
What is your dream job?
started by: Roberto-MOr
forum: Careers sectors and Employment
replies: 8
last post: 1 Minute Ago
Money for uni by matched betting
started by: sonyhamster
forum: Money and Finance
replies: 6226
last post: 1 Minute Ago
anyone know where to find this dress?
started by: kmcman
forum: Clothes and Accessories
replies: 3
last post: 1 Minute Ago
Dentistry Interviews 2012 entry
started by: EmmaW94
forum: Dentistry
replies: 2957
last post: 1 Minute Ago
pharmacy applicants 2012
started by: kingam
forum: Pharmacy
replies: 2299
last post: 1 Minute Ago
White British pupils from working class homes are more likely to fail at school
started by: xXxiKillxXx
forum: Society
replies: 19
last post: 1 Minute Ago
Hate crime against someone opposed to gay marriage
started by: Snagprophet
forum: News and Current Affairs
replies: 31
last post: 1 Minute Ago
"I got an offer from Oxford for 2012 and now I want to chat!!!!" thread
started by: silverspoonmess
forum: University of Oxford
replies: 782
last post: 1 Minute Ago
tinks lose fat/build muscle/get stronger blog
started by: tinktinktinkerbell
forum: Fitness Blogs
replies: 6136
last post: 1 Minute Ago
HYMS Medicine Applicants 2012
started by: apple17
forum: Medical Schools
replies: 445
last post: 1 Minute Ago
Leeds Medical School Applicants 2012
started by: joemullally
forum: Medical Schools
replies: 1132
last post: 1 Minute Ago
FA say Capello resigns
started by: lazy smurf
forum: Football
replies: 510
last post: 1 Minute Ago
Did anyone else get an audition for the 2012 Olympic Opening Ceremony?
started by: BeautifullyTragic
forum: London 2012 Olympic and Paralympic Games
replies: 2987
last post: 1 Minute Ago
Marxist Theory of Value versus Utility
started by: Classical Liberal
forum: Philosophy
replies: 166
last post: 1 Minute Ago
The "waiting for news is driving me crazy" uberthread 2011-12
started by: Minerva
forum: Applications and UCAS
replies: 4016
last post: 1 Minute Ago
Olympiad Math Question
started by: johnconnor92
forum: Maths
replies: 5
last post: 1 Minute Ago
Maths Selection Proceedures (Was BMO1 -1995)
started by: Physics Enemy
forum: Maths
replies: 61
last post: 1 Minute Ago
Single people, whats your plans for valentines day?
started by: insignificant
forum: Advice on Everyday Issues
replies: 215
last post: 1 Minute Ago
Alcohol vs Cannabis
started by: Piddly
forum: Health
replies: 108
last post: 1 Minute Ago
Article Updates Toggle
Contact Us | Site Rules | Staying Safe on TSR | Advertising | Staff Blog | Essays & Coursework | Terms & Conditions | Top
Customise your TSR | Life Advice | Hobbies and Interests | Debate and Current Affairs | Study Help | University and University courses
Universities and HE Colleges | Careers, Employment and Gap Years | General Discussion

Customise your TSR