Revision:Ernest Gellner's (Modernist) Theory of Nationalism - The Student Room
The Student Room

Revision:Ernest Gellner's (Modernist) Theory of Nationalism

TSR Wiki > Study Help > Subjects and Revision > Revision Notes > Sociology > Ernest Gellner's (Modernist) Theory of Nationalism


Gellner defines nationalism as "a political principle which holds that that political and the national unit should be congruent". It is a fundamentally new feature of modern life since states in previous times were not organised on nationalist lines.

For Gellner, there are three stages to human history:

  • The hunter-gatherer
  • The agro-literate
  • The industrial

Nationalism appears in the transition from the agro-literate to the industrial stage of human history. In the second stage, there is no incentive for the ruling classes to impose cultural homogeneity on the masses - indeed, they benefit from diversity as it means that there will be no challenge to their power.

In industrial societies, "a high culture pervades the whole of society, defines it, and needs to be sustained by the polity". In industrial society, the changing nature of work demands cultural homogeneity. There is a need for impersonal, context-free communication.

Furthermore, industrial society depends on perpetual growth in order to satisfy needs. Perpetual growth can only be achieved by perennial shifts in the occupational structure. The high level of technical skill required means that many posts must be filled meritocratically. This necessitates a kind of egalitarianism. It also necessitates general training before specialised training, in order to allow shifts in occupation.

Thus, we see an important development in education. Education now defines the status of the individual, whereas in agro-literate societies kinship status was the defining factor.

The state takes this need for education, and fuses the state and culture together. There is a need to compete for overlapping cultural catchment areas, and nationalism is the only way of competing effectively for these areas.

Criticism

  • Too functionalist
  • Misreads the relationship between nationalism and industrialisation
  • Gellner's theory can not account for resurgence of nationalism in post-industrial societies
  • Gellner's theory can not explain the passions generated by nationalism
  • The processes causing nationalism are too general

Comments

Discussions  
Chemistry Unit 6B [6CH08][Edexcel][International Candidates][22.05.2012]
started by: Yorrap
forum: Chemistry Exams
replies: 185
last post: 2 Minutes Ago
Ionic equation..
started by: sabre2th1
forum: Chemistry
replies: 1
last post: 2 Minutes Ago
Psychology AQA A PSYA1 23rd May 2012!
started by: chelsey
forum: Psychology
replies: 474
last post: 2 Minutes Ago
AQA CHEM2 ~ May 23rd 2012 ~ AS Chemistry
started by: Sorro10
forum: Chemistry Exams
replies: 1779
last post: 3 Minutes Ago
Buying a Ford KA - Rust?
started by: +Adam+
forum: Motoring
replies: 10
last post: 3 Minutes Ago
Depression Society MKVII
started by: Noodlzzz
forum: Mental Health
replies: 1909
last post: 3 Minutes Ago
IGCSE Biology - May/June 2012
started by: Mazzini
forum: Biology Exams
replies: 14
last post: 3 Minutes Ago
Film Fanatics - Chat Thread II
started by: Ape Gone Insane
forum: Film
replies: 6447
last post: 4 Minutes Ago
Ballet
started by: CHEESE!
forum: Fitness
replies: 53
last post: 4 Minutes Ago
Did anyone else get an audition for the 2012 Olympic Opening Ceremony?
started by: BeautifullyTragic
forum: London 2012 Olympic and Paralympic Games
replies: 8728
last post: 4 Minutes Ago
Best Country in the World
started by: datta01
forum: International Lounge
replies: 128
last post: 6 Minutes Ago
Dyspraxia
started by: Alkranite
forum: Disabled Students
replies: 42
last post: 6 Minutes Ago
Choosing your A levels? Your questions answered here!
started by: Loz17
forum: A-Levels, ASs, A2s, VCEs
replies: 3235
last post: 6 Minutes Ago
How should I get my hair cut?
started by: Mr Bee
forum: Fashion and Beauty
replies: 4
last post: 6 Minutes Ago
Chemistry Unit 2 Edexcel, Exam- 23rd May 2012
started by: AmrinderRai
forum: Chemistry Exams
replies: 958
last post: 6 Minutes Ago
Are you seaching for a part-time job
started by: cathyhe
forum: Part-Time and Temporary Employment
replies: 20
last post: 7 Minutes Ago
The London Underground: Love It or Hate It?
started by: simonbellringer
forum: Travel
replies: 129
last post: 7 Minutes Ago
OCR Gateway Biology 2012 B1 B2 B3
started by: ghost_rebel
forum: Biology Exams
replies: 91
last post: 7 Minutes Ago
OCR AS Salters Chemistry F332 - Wednesday 23rd May 2012 1:30pm
started by: EstebanK0
forum: Chemistry Exams
replies: 558
last post: 8 Minutes Ago
Tsr Pakistani Society VI... Saag and Toast for all members!!
started by: killa78
forum: International Lounge
replies: 7872
last post: 9 Minutes Ago
Article Updates Edit