Revision:The Judiciary and Civil Liberties - The Student Room
The Student Room

Revision:The Judiciary and Civil Liberties

TSR Wiki > Study Help > Subjects and Revision > Revision Notes > Politics > The Judiciary and Civil Liberties


Contents

The role of the judiciary and judges

  • To interpret and administer the laws laid down by Parliament or other judges.
  • To defend the liberty of the individual.
  • Sit on judicial review panels and offering expert opinion.


Separation of Powers

  • Essential area for the judiciary.
  • Montesquieu – three branches of power…legislature, judiciary and executive.
  • Does SoP really apply in UK? No…Lord Chancellor’s office gives a link between the judiciary and the executive, as Lord Chancellor is political appointment (Lord Falconer is a friend of Tony Blair).
  • Separation of Power stronger in USA with elected judges, more liberal constitution, and no overlap.


Judicial Independence

Ensured by:

  • Judicial review
  • Security of judge’s jobs means they can make decisions without worry of being sacked.
    • Freedom of speech cannot be sued for their words or actions in court.
    • Only accountable to superior judges, not parliament.


Are judges free from…

The legislature The executive
  • Only Law Lords are involved in law making process, but legal experience helpful for practical reasons.
  • Part time judges can be MP’s.
  • Judges can create case law – should they be able to make such a law if not democratically elected (acting as legislature here).
  • Can’t dismiss senior judges.
  • Free from fear of being sacked, as jobs are extremely safe.
  • Changes made so appointment made by Independent Judicial Appointments Committee.


Noteworthy examples

  • IAN HUNTLEY – The judge (and jury) had hard time remaining neutral, as ‘trial by press’ had occurred so much.
  • ‘SPYCATCHER’ – Peter Wright publishing book about MI5, breaking secrets act – injunction against UK publication allowed, even though already on sale in Australia and USA – fell on side of govt…an un-neutral decision here?
  • GCHQ UNIONISM – Thatcher tried to ban civil servants being in unions, to safeguard secrets being leaked in disputes. Judge found in Thatcher’s (govt) favour…no neutrality?
  • CLIVE PONTING – Found not guilty of breaking secrets act, after releasing classified info about Belgrano sinking – jury felt necessary for the public to know, despite political fallout for govt…a neutral judicial system?


Human Rights

  • UN declaration – Right to life, free movement, food and shelter, freedom from torture and slavery.
  • Euro Convention on Human Rights – Entrenched the UN declaration into the EU…however…in UK didn’t become entrenched as a part of UK law, unlike in France where it was then adopted as statute.
  • Euro Court of H.R. – From 1966 ECHR was permitted to be used in UK, but only HRA 1998 was a UK statute created.
  • HRA 1998 – Covers all public state bodies (police, courts, council, devolved bodies etc). Key areas of discussion are – Right To Privacy (can privacy be given up?) and Freedom of Expression (example the BNP activist and leader being found not guilty on race-hate charges recently).


Past questions and areas to mention

Describe two civil liberties. (5)

  • Freedom from torture (regulations on how government authorities can act, after the horrors of WW2 ‘interrogations’ by Nazis and Russia).
  • Right to take part in elections – free democracy must be implemented in countries taking on the Euro Convention of Human Rights.


How do judges protect civil liberties? (15)

  • The HRA act has allowed judges a UK statute to enforce Human Rights with a UK law.
  • Judicial review protects individual against the government’s machines growth of use.
  • Judges can ensure natural justice is allowed, and therefore can throw out trials that will not achieve a fair result.


To what extent are judges independent and neutral? (30)

  • They cannot easily be removed from office, and can therefore make decisions, knowing that the government isn’t going to sack them for a decision that goes against them. ‘Scrutiny of tenure’
  • Conventions against parliament verbally attacking judicial decisions.
  • Seek to serve the individual to get justice, regardless of political bias.
  • Are not politically engaged (and if they are the trial is appealed, as in the Pinochet extradition case, where the judge didn’t announce he was an Amnesty Member).
  • Only accountable to more senior judge’s decisions, and not parliament.
  • Freedom of speech ensures they can make whatever ruling they see as fit.


(Answers extracted from an Edexcel mark scheme.)


Comments

These notes are aimed at people studying for Edexcel A Level Politics, module 2.

Originally submitted by mattey on TSR Forums.

Discussions  
Advanced Higher Biology 2012
started by: escapingthefate
forum: Scottish Qualifications
replies: 15
last post: 1 Minute Ago
Official AS/A Levels Thread/Results Day Thread 2012! (16th August 2012)
started by: madders94
forum: A-Levels, ASs, A2s, VCEs
replies: 155
last post: 1 Minute Ago
Shall i take the risk?
started by: Miss Sweet
forum: A-Levels, ASs, A2s, VCEs
replies: 2
last post: 1 Minute Ago
Current Year 11 thread mark III (woo!) / Year 12 2012/13
started by: g.k.galloway
forum: GCSEs
replies: 2302
last post: 1 Minute Ago
AQA GCSE Spanish 21st and 25th May 2012
started by: Jimmy20002012
forum: Foreign Languages
replies: 71
last post: 1 Minute Ago
The Official TSR Euro 2012 Fantasy Football Thread
started by: Da_hopeful_1
forum: Euro 2012
replies: 34
last post: 1 Minute Ago
OCR Chemistry A F322 Chains, Energy and Resources Wed 23 May 2012
started by: kickasskaz01
forum: Chemistry Exams
replies: 1880
last post: 1 Minute Ago
The Edexcel S2 (24/05/12 - AM) Revision Thread
started by: number23
forum: Maths Exams
replies: 407
last post: 1 Minute Ago
Best Irish University for IB
started by: Fanatec
forum: Investment Banking and Consultancy
replies: 9
last post: 1 Minute Ago
OCR GCSE Chemistry A- C7 + Ideas In Context, May 24th 2012. OFFICIAL THREAD
started by: Coke1
forum: Chemistry Exams
replies: 167
last post: 1 Minute Ago
AQA CHEM2 ~ May 23rd 2012 ~ AS Chemistry
started by: Sorro10
forum: Chemistry Exams
replies: 2512
last post: 1 Minute Ago
OCR F297 Strategic Management Case Study Thread 2012
started by: Onion man
forum: Economics, Business and Management Exams
replies: 132
last post: 1 Minute Ago
Psychology AQA A PSYA1 23rd May 2012!
started by: chelsey
forum: Psychology
replies: 698
last post: 1 Minute Ago
GCSE english poetry CONFLICT
started by: Kabanza
forum: GCSEs
replies: 0
last post: 1 Minute Ago
The Arsenal Thread XII
started by: In2deep
forum: Football
replies: 3402
last post: 1 Minute Ago
OCR AS Salters Chemistry F332 - Wednesday 23rd May 2012 1:30pm
started by: EstebanK0
forum: Chemistry Exams
replies: 905
last post: 1 Minute Ago
Best Halls of Residence? (The Big Accommodation Choices Thread Mark II)
started by: Ana
forum: University of Manchester
replies: 1803
last post: 1 Minute Ago
How are carboxylic acids not esters?
started by: When you see it...
forum: Chemistry
replies: 5
last post: 1 Minute Ago
Books for self-study
started by: kostis12345
forum: Maths Exams
replies: 4
last post: 1 Minute Ago
Sociology AS unit 2 MAY 2012!! (AQA)
started by: ChooChooCherry
forum: Sociology
replies: 256
last post: 1 Minute Ago
Article Updates Edit