Revision:The Russian Revolutions of 1917 - The Student Room
The Student Room

Revision:The Russian Revolutions of 1917

TSR Wiki > Study Help > Subjects and Revision > Revision Notes > History > The Russian Revolutions of 1917


Contents

Reasons for Rev. of March 1917

  • Defeat of Russia following entry in WWI
  • Some argue that Rev. was inevitable regardless of WWI (terrible living standards)
  • Incompetence of the Czar
  • Corrupt and inefficient Gov.
  • Weak ruler (Nicholas II)
  • Rasputin damage the reputation of the royal family in the eyes of other nobles (he was seen to be the de facto ruler of the country)
  • Food shortages
  • Army losses in 1916 (the army morale declined)
  • The Czar assumed command of the army and was associated with military defeat
  • Formation of the Provisional Gov.
  • Established by the Duma
  • A soviet committee was established
  • Causes of the October (Bolshevik) Rev.
  • Weaknesses/mistakes of Prov. Gov: failed to decisively - didn't satisfy demands for change/the power of the Soviets/allowed opposition to form/kept Russia in the war/handicapped by internal divisions (not efficient and united)
  • The power of the Bolsheviks
  • The return of Lenin
  • The Mensheviks supported the Prov. Gov. and opposition sided with the Bolsheviks as a result
  • Lenin adapted Marxist doctrine to fit revolutionary needs
  • The simple message of Bolshevism: "Peace, bread and land"
  • The Bolsheviks strengthened power in the cities as opposed to the countryside which meant success in elections.
  • They gained a military force (the Red Guards) which other political parties did not have
  • Benefited from divisions amongst their opponents
  • The Bolshevik Revolution
  • Timing was a result of Lenin's belief that war with Germany must be ended at any costs.
  • Were the 1917 Revolutions inevitable?
  • Improvement in living standards meant chances of revolution might fade: the establishment of a middle peasant class / improvements in working conditions/lack of incentive in revolutionary parties
  • BUT The Czar had failed to carry out his promised reforms (the situation was deteriorating before WWI)
    • Stolypin's reforms failed to match a growing peasant pop.
    • Little relaxation of secret police activities
    • The royal family was discredited
  • Growing agitation amongst the workers/combined with the fact that the army was not loyal to the Czar following Russian defeat in war.


Russia: 1905-1917 Timeline

19th Century: -Russia was backward in the 19th Century compared with Western European states like Britain, France and Germany.

Start of 20th Century: -Because Russia industrialised too quickly, its two main cities, St. Petersburg (Later became Petrograd because it sounded less German) and Moscow, became crowded with industrial workers.

1903: The Social Democrats (political parties were illegal at this time) split between the Mensheviks and the BOLSHEVIKS. SD split.

1905: -Nicholas II, the Tsar, just survived a revolution and agreed to introduce a parliament (Duma) and legalise political parties. This agreement was called the "October Manifesto".

1905 - 1913: The Tsar's government would go back on their promises made in 1905. The Tsar would arrest memers of the St. Petersburg Soviet and send fifteen of them into exile. An army would also be sent to crush the Soviet and thousands died in street fighting between revolutionaries and soldiers.

In 1906, the Tsar would issue a set of "Fundamental Laws", essentially stating that Russia would remain an autocratic country, even with the Duma having been set up. When the first Duma would demand a share of power, it would be split up. The second Duma would contain SD and SR members, so it too was broken up in 1907. The third Duma remained in place for five years as the Tsar would not allow revolutionaries to be voted into it; it consisted mainly of conservative politicians.

1914: World War One starts.

1917: The Tsar is forced to abdicate in March of 1917 due to military and economic disasters which were accelerated due to the First World War. The Duma has a vote of no confidence.

Dual Authority is set up in Parliament  The Provisional Government and the Soviet of Soldiers, Sailors and Workers.

APRIL

Lenin’s return to Petrograd was funded by the Germans because both Lenin and the Germans wanted Russia out of the war. Lenin returns 3 April.

Lenin delivers his April Theses ("All power to the Soviets!") on 4 April.

JUNE

The Russian army fails in a major attack on Austria, and turns into a retreat. Many soldiers go to Petrograd to join up with the Bolsheviks and demand an end to the Provisional Government and therefore an end to the war.

JULY

3-6 July – Failure of the “July Days”, which consisted of three days of rioting. Bolsheviks are rounded up and imprisoned, Lenin flees to Finland. Bolshevik support drops.

8 July – Alexander Kerensky appointed Prime Minister.

18 July – Kornilov becomes Commander-in-Chief.

SEPTEMBER

1 September – Kornilov’s march on Petrograd is abandoned because his soldiers refused to fight against fellow workers. The Prov. Gov. release and arm the Bolsheviks to defend Petrograd. Bolsheviks seen as protectors of the people. Kornilov affair highlighted the weakness of the Prov. Gov., it’s inability to defend itself and defend Russia. Now more than 25,000 Bolsheviks are armed and in the street.

12 September – “HISTORY WILL NOT FORGIVE US IF WE DO NOT ASSUME POWER” Lenin.

25 September – Bolsheviks gain a majority in Petrograd Soviet.

OCTOBER

7 October – Lenin returns to Petrograd.

9 October – Military Revolutionary Committee (MRC) set up, Trotsky in charge (later becomes the Red Army).

23 October – Zinoview and Kamenev warn the Prov. Gov. of the revolution and Kerensky moves to shut down Pravda and Izvestiya.

25-27 October – The revolution takes place with very little fighting. Cossacks (a female unit known as the “Amazons”) walked off when confronted by the Red Guard (which was comprised mainly of 10,000 elderly men). Kerensky flees. Bolsheviks take the Winter Palace and take power.

Reasons for Bolshevik Success in the October Revolution of 1917

Provisional Government Weaknesses:

- Failure to defend itself (Kornilov affair)

- Failure to solve the Land Question (many Prov. Gov. members owned land); peasants killed their landlords on over 2000 farms and divided the land amongst themselves because of lack of action

- Failure to act on the problems that Russia was facing; unemployment, starvation, kept itself in the war needlessly

The Weakness of the non-Bolshevik parties:

- Most parties were pro-war, but the Bolsheviks were consistently anti-war.

- Russia’s lack of party-political tradition (they were so used to Tsarist Russia, most parties were unable to negotiate properly and this was advantageous for the ruthless Bolsheviks)

Bolshevik advantages:

- The Bolsheviks were ruthless and determined. They were a new breed of politician, utterly self-confident and loyal to their leader.

- The Bolsheviks had an answer to the Land Question. They stole the SR slogan “Land to the peasants”. This meant that the Bolsheviks viewed the land-seizures as legimiate, thus gaining large amounts of support in the countryside. This move also made a lot of left SRs align with the Bolsheviks. Their political platform spoke to the majority.

- The Bolsheviks were in control of the only military force in Petrograd, the Military Revolutionary Committee (MRC).

Comments

Discussions  
OCR Chemistry A F322 Chains, Energy and Resources Wed 23 May 2012
started by: kickasskaz01
forum: Chemistry Exams
replies: 1900
last post: 1 Minute Ago
Winter or Summer clothing?
started by: cathyhe
forum: Clothes, Shoes and Accessories
replies: 2
last post: 1 Minute Ago
What A levels for BA Education Studies?
started by: GrantG
forum: A-Levels, ASs, A2s, VCEs
replies: 10
last post: 1 Minute Ago
Higher Biology 2012 Discussion
started by: SQA
forum: Scottish Qualifications
replies: 170
last post: 1 Minute Ago
AQA CHEM2 ~ May 23rd 2012 ~ AS Chemistry
started by: Sorro10
forum: Chemistry Exams
replies: 2532
last post: 1 Minute Ago
Gcse p.e short course 23/5/12
started by: Obey
forum: Social Science and Social Care Academic Help
replies: 9
last post: 1 Minute Ago
Why does the British accent sound so good?
started by: thomaskurian89
forum: International Lounge
replies: 18
last post: 1 Minute Ago
Pgce qub 2012
started by: RebeccaS_
forum: Northern Ireland Unis
replies: 66
last post: 1 Minute Ago
The Edexcel C4 (21/06/12 - PM) Revision Thread
started by: Jasmine_777
forum: Maths Exams
replies: 61
last post: 1 Minute Ago
AQA GCSE Biology 2H Unofficial Mark Scheme
started by: R.P.Everything.
forum: Biology
replies: 238
last post: 1 Minute Ago
AQA chemistry unit 2, 23/05/2012, raw mark POLL
started by: iAre Teh Lejend
forum: Chemistry Exams
replies: 5
last post: 1 Minute Ago
AQA GCSE English Literature Exam 24th May 2012
started by: OllieWolly
forum: English
replies: 10
last post: 1 Minute Ago
So which MMORPG should I play?
started by: beepbeeprichie
forum: Gaming
replies: 90
last post: 1 Minute Ago
Advanced Higher Biology
started by: Armaros
forum: Scottish Qualifications
replies: 14
last post: 1 Minute Ago
AS AQA Geography Unit 1 and 2 May 2012
started by: Natalie21
forum: Geography and Geology
replies: 219
last post: 1 Minute Ago
The Uni Study Thread Mk II
started by: Aemiliana
forum: Student Life
replies: 2980
last post: 1 Minute Ago
AQA English lit exam 24th May- Poetry
started by: Zozzy
forum: English
replies: 3
last post: 1 Minute Ago
Lose Weight/ better body shape
started by: Sun!
forum: Fitness
replies: 11
last post: 1 Minute Ago
OCR AS Salters Chemistry F332 - Wednesday 23rd May 2012 1:30pm
started by: EstebanK0
forum: Chemistry Exams
replies: 916
last post: 1 Minute Ago
UCA - Fashion Promotion or Fashion Promotion with Imaging
started by: sildoroftei
forum: Creative Arts
replies: 0
last post: 1 Minute Ago
Article Updates Edit