STEP I 1997 question 14 solution - The Student Room
The Student Room

STEP I 1997 question 14 solution

TSR Wiki > Study Help > Subjects and Revision > Mathematics > STEP > STEP 1997 Solutions > STEP I 1997 question 14 solution


f(x) and T(x) are the probability (density) of the maximum height being x, and the cost if the maximum heigh becomes x, respectively. The expected cost, say, C, is then given by

\displaystyle C = \int_0^\infty f(x)T(x)dx

\displaystyle C = \int_0^y e^{-x}ydx + \int_y^\infty e^{-x}(y + r + s(x-y))dx

\displaystyle C = \int_0^\infty ye^{-x}dx + \int_y^\infty e^{-x}(r + sx - sy)dx

\displaystyle C = \int_0^\infty ye^{-x}dx + \int_y^\infty e^{-x}(r - sy)dx + \int_y^\infty sxe^{-x}dx

\displaystyle C = \int_0^\infty ye^{-x}dx + \int_y^\infty e^{-x}(r - sy)dx + \left[-sxe^{-x}\right]_y^\infty + \int_y^\infty se^{-x}dx

\displaystyle C = \left[-ye^{-x}\right]_0^\infty + \left[-(r-sy)e^{-x}\right]_y^\infty + \left[-sxe^{-x}\right]_y^\infty + \left[-se^{-x}\right]_y^\infty

(Note that \displaystyle \lim_{x\rightarrow\infty} xe^{-x} = 0, since \displaystyle e^x grows faster than \displaystyle x)

\displaystyle C = y + (r-sy)e^{-y} + sye^{-y} + se^{-y}

\displaystyle C = y + (r+s)e^{-y}

Differentiating:

\displaystyle C' = 1 - (r+s)e^{-y}

which is strictly increasing. Setting \displaystyle C' = 0

\displaystyle 1 = (r + s)e^{-y}

\displaystyle e^y = (r + s)

we get the minimum at

\displaystyle \displaytyle y = \ln (r + s)

as required.

If \displaystyle (r + s) < 1, the minimum will still be at \displaystyle y = \ln (r + s), only that since \displaystyle \ln (r + s) < 0, the probability that this happens anyway is zero. If y < 0, they won't actually gain anything by lowering the prepared height (it is sensible to assume that they don't get any money back if they prepare for a negative height); the only thing that will happen is that if the actual water height is larger than zero, they will lose out more, because the (X-y) part of the cost is larger. So instead, they should aim at having y = 0. If y becomes larger than that, the derivative of the expected cost,

\displaystyle C' = 1 - (r + s)e^{-y}

will always be positive for y>=0. The expected cost is thus increasing for y >= 0, and so the lowest cost they can get is at y = 0. Thus the authorities shouldn't prepare at all when r + s < 1.

Solution by ukgea

Discussions Toggle
Step II 2002 Q3
started by: safmaster
forum: Maths
replies: 6
last post: 1 Minute Ago
LNAT results thread 2012
started by: christinasrose
forum: Law
replies: 532
last post: 1 Minute Ago
"BAGSY THAT FLAVOUR!!" The food and drink you call dibs on!
started by: TotoMimo
forum: Food and Drink
replies: 201
last post: 1 Minute Ago
Peacock (also, I got published!)
started by: cat observing butterfly
forum: Creative Corner
replies: 5
last post: 1 Minute Ago
Rate the track above you!
started by: keepoffthelawn
forum: Music
replies: 3782
last post: 1 Minute Ago
Private halls in manchester
started by: Beth Naomi
forum: Manchester Unis
replies: 16
last post: 1 Minute Ago
The "waiting for news is driving me crazy" uberthread 2011-12
started by: Minerva
forum: Applications and UCAS
replies: 4000
last post: 2 Minutes Ago
Yuck or Yum
started by: RainbowDoll
forum: Food and Drink
replies: 5881
last post: 3 Minutes Ago
Healthy New You: Your Change For Life #2
started by: xoxAngel_Kxox
forum: Fitness
replies: 116
last post: 3 Minutes Ago
Physiotherapy: 2012 entry
started by: MissLightyear
forum: Healthcare and Nursing
replies: 1137
last post: 3 Minutes Ago
The Barbelles Society: Ladies Who Lift
started by: Sorani
forum: Fitness Blogs
replies: 3582
last post: 4 Minutes Ago
Exeter, Sheffield, Queen Mary or Gap Year?
started by: aj1994
forum: Law
replies: 3
last post: 4 Minutes Ago
Tottenham Hotspur Society II
started by: jermaindefoe
forum: Football
replies: 1314
last post: 4 Minutes Ago
Food and Drink you can still get, but used to be SO much better.
started by: TotoMimo
forum: Food and Drink
replies: 388
last post: 4 Minutes Ago
Your views on meal replacement protein shakes?
started by: emilymay
forum: Nutrition and Supplements
replies: 2
last post: 4 Minutes Ago
Food and Drink: Slay This, Save This!
started by: TotoMimo
forum: Food and Drink
replies: 374
last post: 5 Minutes Ago
Southampton Uni chat thread
started by: marcusmerehay
forum: Southampton Unis
replies: 6792
last post: 5 Minutes Ago
Halls of residence - closeness to department or ensuite?
started by: Marchmallow
forum: University of Manchester
replies: 7
last post: 6 Minutes Ago
Wine at 14% is never bad?
started by: GunnerBill
forum: Food and Drink
replies: 17
last post: 6 Minutes Ago
FA say Capello resigns
started by: lazy smurf
forum: Football
replies: 395
last post: 7 Minutes Ago
Article Updates Toggle
Contact Us | Site Rules | Staying Safe on TSR | Advertising | Staff Blog | Essays & Coursework | Terms & Conditions | Top
Customise your TSR | Life Advice | Hobbies and Interests | Debate and Current Affairs | Study Help | University and University courses
Universities and HE Colleges | Careers, Employment and Gap Years | General Discussion

Customise your TSR