Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows: Part 1 & 2

Scroll to see replies

This may have been mentioned (most likely has) but this thread is so long, and I don't have time to trawl through all of it so...

In the books Sirius gives Harry that mirror so that they can communicate with each other, I'm fairly sure this isn't shown in the 5th film, and yet it's brought back in the most recent one with no explanation? Or was there an explanation?

The vast majority have read the books, so it's of little importance I suppose, however it seems odd not to give even one line in the script to explain it.

There was no explanation in the film

One of my friends said to me "Well surely it's a shard from the mirror or erised so it's showing him dumbledore's eye cos that's what he desires!" i nearly burst a blood vessel that's how shocked i was!!

Original post by Luceria

Yeah.

I love the scene actually. Dan and Emma do have good chemistry, I think.
But it wasn't meant like that (even if Yates and Kloves made some strange comments about it).. It was Harry trying to cheer up his sad bestfriend. That was the main purpose of it. The dorky dancing and all was cute. But in the end of it she goes back to being depressed about Ron. Like "Thanks, but I still miss Ron." Harry wasn't making a move. He had a girlfriend and he has never viewed Hermione that way (and likewise).

I totally get that is how it was MEANT to come across, but I don't think it fully achieved that...

Reply 901

greenpeas

This is a little off-topic but can anyone tell me what song is playing whilst harry and hermione were dancing? there may well be rep involved :biggrin:

Reply 902

greeneyedgirl

Original post by greenpeas

This is a little off-topic but can anyone tell me what song is playing whilst harry and hermione were dancing? there may well be rep involved :biggrin:

O children - Nick Cave

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mKWydA69o9E

Reply 903

Kawa

Original post by greenpeas

This is a little off-topic but can anyone tell me what song is playing whilst harry and hermione were dancing? there may well be rep involved :biggrin:

'O Children' by Nick Cave I think.

Beat me to it ^^ :smile:

Reply 904

ipixie

Part 1 is amazing! I've seen it twice in cinema haha XD
Cannot wait for part 2!

Reply 905

satisfactionatlast

Original post by ipixie

Part 1 is amazing! I've seen it twice in cinema haha XD
Cannot wait for part 2!

I'm planning for my fourth soon :biggrin:

Reply 906

satisfactionatlast

Original post by greenpeas

This is a little off-topic but can anyone tell me what song is playing whilst harry and hermione were dancing? there may well be rep involved :biggrin:

wow I'm late! :tongue:

anyway it's been on my shuffle ever since I watched the movie :smile:

Reply 907

Fuzzpig

Knock Knock

Who's there?

You know

YOU KNOW WHO?

/tumblr_lcnd96bt931qa827q.gif

Reply 908

cz100

I find it so cute the ways things turned out in the series. In the first when Ron first met Hermione he said whatever house he was in he hoped she wouldn't, and now look at them both :teehee:

They all looked so adorable before then hame the films now have one good looking girl surrounded by two not so good looking boys

Reply 909

ufo_01

Not impressed with the long wait between parts 1 and 2 !! :frown:

Reply 910

JAZZA007

Finally someone says something that makes sense :smile:

. Me too- what a rip off :angry:

Reply 911

greeneyedgirl

Off to see it for a 3rd time tonight =D

Reply 912

satisfactionatlast

Original post by greeneyedgirl

Off to see it for a 3rd time tonight =D

been there, done that ... hoping for a fourth time :tongue:

Reply 913

greeneyedgirl

Original post by satisfactionatlast

been there, done that ... hoping for a fourth time :tongue:

nice =D
i love harry potter =D
(actually i love ron weasley!)

Reply 914

Loonylottie

Original post by greeneyedgirl

nice =D
i love harry potter =D
(actually i love ron weasley!)

Get in line, my friend is convinced she's going to marry him, even today she said, 'I'm soon the become Mrs Weasley' xx

Reply 915

greeneyedgirl

Original post by Loonylottie

Get in line, my friend is convinced she's going to marry him, even today she said, 'I'm soon the become Mrs Weasley' xx

Don't want to marry him...my heart is set on Frank Turner <3 <3 :love:

Reply 916

ShayCamp

T'was soooo goooood! Can't wait for the second part. I'm reading the books from the beginning again.

Reply 917

Ape Gone Insane

Original post by ShayCamp

T'was soooo goooood! Can't wait for the second part. I'm reading the books from the beginning again.

Listening to the audiobooks. I'm going to let Stephen Fry read for me. :proud:

Reply 918

greeneyedgirl

Original post by Ape Gone Insane

Listening to the audiobooks. I'm going to let Stephen Fry read for me. :proud:

I have Stephen Fry reading them for me when I sleep :colondollar:

Then when I wake up in the morning I got back to the point where I fell asleep and carry on listening.

Reply 919

Piece

Original post by kaus123

I absolutely loved the film :biggrin:

Although I would like to mention a few things:

- lastly, i think scabior was really hot in the movie (like an odd mix between tim minchin and johnny depp)

I thought this too!! Well, not quite exactly. Scabior is the first person I've actually thought is hot in the harry films... guess im too obsessed with the book characters to actually fall in love with them. But yes, Scabior actually got me thinking of the type of men i seem to like and tim minchin came up in my thoughts... i am now a litle obsessed with him :smile:

but yes, just wanted to say *high 5* on the connection haha