Seen a few Newcastle games and Sol's been a car wreck. He wouldn't have been any better. Squillaci was brought on as cover and the injury to Vermaelen's hit us hard...although with Wenger in charge we have to accept we're going to concede a bucketload. No matter what defenders are out there, our defensive record will be cack.
That's why the 8 changes become important. Because we can't defend, every line-up we name has to have a lot of goals in them. We might've had 'enough' but the manager has to pick the XI that gives us the best possible chance of winning. If you're telling me Van Persie, Walcott, Nasri, Wilshere, Song, Rosicky/Arshavin wouldn't have offered us a better chance of scoring more than Bendtner, Chamakh, Arshavin, Diaby, Denilson, Rosicky -- I just can't agree with that.
You're saying that Champions would've fielded a 2nd string and got a result -- that's not true. Champions wouldn't have fannied about with the line-up so much in the first place. Man City, Tottenham, Man Utd, Chelsea -- none of them made anywhere close to 8 changes. What makes us so special that we can afford to do that?
Especially with Fabregas missing, we needed to show more respect to Wigan. A better line-up would've seen us out of sight by half-time.