Newton's law?
A bottle on a table is stationary
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
A student wrote this incorrect explanation
The force of gravity pulls the bottle down.
The bottle pushes down on the table, so by Newton’s first law,
the table pushes up with an equal and opposite force.
According to Newton’s third law, if the forces are balanced,
nothing can move
why this is incorrect? everything he said makes a perfect sense
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
A student wrote this incorrect explanation
The force of gravity pulls the bottle down.
The bottle pushes down on the table, so by Newton’s first law,
the table pushes up with an equal and opposite force.
According to Newton’s third law, if the forces are balanced,
nothing can move
why this is incorrect? everything he said makes a perfect sense
Original post by reb0xx
A bottle on a table is stationary
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
A student wrote this incorrect explanation
The force of gravity pulls the bottle down.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
A student wrote this incorrect explanation
The force of gravity pulls the bottle down.
The bottle pushes down on the table, so by Newton’s
the table pushes up with an equal and opposite force. On the bottle.
According to Newton’s third law, if the forces are balanced,
nothing can move
Newton's 3rd Law doesn't say that.
why this is incorrect? everything he said makes a perfect sense
Newton's 3rd law states that the action and reaction are on different objects.
The earth pulls down on the bottle and the bottle pulls up on the earth. These are the action and reaction pair for gravity.
The bottle pushes down on the table and the table pushes up on the bottle.
These are the action/reaction pair for the bottle and table.
How many forces act on the bottle? If the bottle doesn't move, then the forces on it are balanced. There is gravity pulling it downwards and the table pushing upwards. These are not action and reaction in the Newton 3 sense.
The student is getting confused with "normal reaction".
Original post by reb0xx
Original post by reb0xx
A bottle on a table is stationary
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
A student wrote this incorrect explanation
The force of gravity pulls the bottle down.
The bottle pushes down on the table, so by Newton’s first law,
the table pushes up with an equal and opposite force.
According to Newton’s third law, if the forces are balanced,
nothing can move
why this is incorrect? everything he said makes a perfect sense
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
A student wrote this incorrect explanation
The force of gravity pulls the bottle down.
The bottle pushes down on the table, so by Newton’s first law,
the table pushes up with an equal and opposite force.
According to Newton’s third law, if the forces are balanced,
nothing can move
why this is incorrect? everything he said makes a perfect sense
I would correct the "force of gravity" by saying it's the "force of weight"
Original post by gozatron
I would correct the "force of gravity" by saying it's the "force of weight"
Well, actually weight has the dimension of , and is a force. So there's no need to say something like "force of a force".
Original post by jaroc
Original post by jaroc
Well, actually weight has the dimension of , and is a force. So there's no need to say something like "force of a force".
Yes saying "force of weight" is just defining which force your talking about, surely?
Original post by gozatron
Yes saying "force of weight" is just defining which force your talking about, surely?
Well, I'm certainly not an expert on English language, but I suspect that as you would say 'thrust', not 'force of thrust', or 'drag', not 'force of drag', you would say 'weight', not 'force of weight' alike.
Quick Reply
Related discussions
- Physics question
- A level physics MCQ
- A level physics
- Rotational dynamics (A level physics) question
- don't understand force exerted by A on B
- Mechanics Help!!!
- Physics
- As mechanics question
- acceleration on an angle
- Direction of Force on the Wire (A2 Edexcel)
- Help with dimensional analysis....
- pulley
- Physics question- man in lift
- A-level maths question
- Electric Fields Help
- MATHS Mathswatch homework help
- Time to move on from Poirot and Miss Marple
- GCSE Diary
- Newton's Law of Cooling
- newtons first law
