Two points on a wave can be any number of wavelengths apart, and phi can be any value.
I think what you are thinking of is the fact that, as the cycle just repeats itself, a phase difference of 1.5 wavelengths amounts to the same displacement as a difference of 0.5
But a point at a phase difference of just pi would not be at the same place on the graph/wave as Y, though it is at the same distance below the axis, as will be the points at 2.5, 3.5 4.5 etc.