The Student Room Group

Vegetarians...

Scroll to see replies

Reply 100
A lot, and do you think I'm proud of that? Because I'm not. The point is I have made much more of an effort than than most have or ever will, no one is perfect and on our own no one can change anything completely.

Can I also ask why you're getting so aggressive about this, why not go and politely persuade someone against cruelty to animals that we see every day, than lambasting someone who does love and care for animals very much already? Because attacking me with such aggression and comparing me to Hitler isn't going to sway anyone to your cause, believe me.
My Gran came from a veggie family. She used to buy bacon on the way home from school and eat it.

Raw bacon.
*shrugs* didn't make her ill. Maybe she was just lucky though.

Anyway.. Do remember that humans have been cooking food for an incredibly long time. Enough to drastically affect our species. So it may well be that we are less suited to raw meat than other animals now. In the same way that we have small teeth so can't be grinding tough veg all day.
(edited 13 years ago)
Original post by lightburns
My Gran came from a veggie family. She used to buy bacon on the way home from school and eat it.

Raw bacon.
*shrugs* didn't make her ill. Maybe she was just lucky though.

Anyway.. Do remember that humans have been cooking food for an incredibly long time. Enough to drastically affect our species. So it may well be that we are less suited to raw meat than other animals now. In the same way that we have small teeth so can't be grinding tough veg all day.


Evolution is a slow process.
Reply 103
Well unless you're 100% vegan and don't take any drugs whatsoever, don't do anything at all that has any impact on animals whatsoever then you too are exploiting animals, all I was trying to do was minimise my impact, not trying to claim I'm perfect here.

What would you have me do then? Eat no meat, any animal product, any medicines that contain or have been tested on animals, and a whole host of other things? Everything we do exploits animals to a certain extent, don't try and twist it as though it's solely my fault.
Reply 104
Original post by -Invidious-
Saw an episode of Come dine with me earlier and it got me thinking; anyone else notice the majority of "vegetarians" our age (17-23) are usually females just merely trying to be hip/cool/different? With completely retarded reasons for being vegetarian, such as "we don't have a necessary enzyme that digests meat" and "killing animals is wrong", all the while wearing leather and more often that not eating fish "because they're not as smart".


Yes. All the time.

'Oh yeah, I don't eat meat. Like oh my god. What? well yeah, fish. And ok ok ok ok, Chicken'. Honestly, loads of them just dont like red meat. They should either admit that, or their parents should have been a little less accommodating. One of my good friends now has anemia. :rolleyes:

_Kar.
Reply 105
Original post by ProFail
A lot, and do you think I'm proud of that? Because I'm not. The point is I have made much more of an effort than than most have or ever will, no one is perfect and on our own no one can change anything completely.

Can I also ask why you're getting so aggressive about this, why not go and politely persuade someone against cruelty to animals that we see every day, than lambasting someone who does love and care for animals very much already? Because attacking me with such aggression and comparing me to Hitler isn't going to sway anyone to your cause, believe me.


I agree . I think if someone wants to help animals through their actions in their daily lives, perfection is very very hard to achieve as animal products are used in so many ways, some of them very far from obvious. Personally, I don't eat meat but I do eat fish. I'm not proud of eating fish as I believe they probably suffer when caught and are killed but I hope that in a very small way I'm helping those animals which aren't that much different than human beings in intelligence and emotional sensitivity.
If I had to choose between starving to death and eating meat I suppose I'd have to eat the meat to survive, but I don't have to make that choice just yet and probably will never have to .
Also it's much more efficient to feed grain directly to humans rather than feed it to animals to produce meat that will feed a tenth of the people the original grain would have fed.
With growing populations in India and China together with a desire for richer diets, the world is going to be very short of grain - in fact there are shortages right now and prices are rising.
Call me a hypocrite for eating fish if you like, but at least I'm doing part of what I believe in.
(edited 13 years ago)
Reply 106
Original post by buzzicon
I agree . I think if someone wants to help animals through their actions in their daily lives, perfection is very very hard to achieve as animal products are used in so many ways, some of them very far from obvious. Personally, I don't eat meat but I do eat fish. I'm not proud of eating fish as I believe they probably suffer when caught and are killed but I hope that in a very small way I'm helping those animals which aren't that much different than human beings in intelligence and emotional sensitivity.
If I had to choose between starving to death and eating meat I suppose I'd have to eat the meat to survive, but I don't have to make that choice just yet and probably will never have to .
Also it's much more efficient to feed grain directly to humans rather than feed it to animals to produce meat that will feed a tenth of the people the original grain would have fed.
With growing populations in India and China together with a desire for richer diets, the world is going to be very short of grain - in fact there are shortages right now and prices are rising.
Call me a hypocrite for eating fish if you like, but at least I'm doing part of what I believe in.


I couldn't agree more, that is exactly my point, and is exactly what There's Too Much Love seems to be hating on me for...
Original post by Simplicity
Evolution is a slow process.


And we've been cooking our food for a very long time.
Original post by tillytots
been a veggie all my life. Never tried meat and never had the desire too. So no, I'm not trying to be cool or different


Me too! Only met a very few outside my family the same! Do you constantly get questioned...
"How do you know you don't like it if you've never tried it?"
"But have you never just wanted bacon?"
"What if theres no good veggie options at a restaurant?"
"So what you've NEVER eaten meat? Don't believe you"
Reply 109
I agree with your point about fish. I'm going to try to stop eating fish.
Original post by lightburns
My Gran came from a veggie family. She used to buy bacon on the way home from school and eat it.

Raw bacon.
*shrugs* didn't make her ill. Maybe she was just lucky though.

Anyway.. Do remember that humans have been cooking food for an incredibly long time. Enough to drastically affect our species. So it may well be that we are less suited to raw meat than other animals now. In the same way that we have small teeth so can't be grinding tough veg all day.


That's impressive.

I think the raw issue comes down to freshness really.

Why did she do it though? I mean, I can understand that she wants to eat meat, but why raw bacon? That sounds crazy.
Reply 111
Original post by tillytots
Haha, everytime someone shows me meat or asks if I'd like to try it, I just can't bring myself to try it.

Slightly off topic, but out of curiosity do you eat 'fake meat' (quorn chicken etc ) ? I know a lot of 'new' vegetarians as such who seem to live on it, but I've noticed it seems to be not as common in us life longs....


I'm not a 'life-long' and I eat quorn- it's actually quite nice, doesnt hugely taste of meat. Full of protein too :]
Reply 112
I'm a lacto-vegetarian because I want to be. that's it. not trying to impress anyone but myself
Original post by Harrifer
That's impressive.

I think the raw issue comes down to freshness really.

Why did she do it though? I mean, I can understand that she wants to eat meat, but why raw bacon? That sounds crazy.


This was when she was a kid - veggie family and she had to find a way to sneakily eat meat. Couldn't exactly cook it. And this was some time ago, so you couldn't so easily go and buy cooked meat. So she got the next best thing. Raw meat. She probably had no idea that anything from a pig is mightily more dangerous than other meats.

She should have just talked to her parents though.. They eventually found out and immediately switched to being a meat-eating family.
Original post by -Invidious-
"we don't have a necessary enzyme that digests meat"


If anyone thinks that, they must have been asleep in biology lessons
Original post by lightburns
This was when she was a kid - veggie family and she had to find a way to sneakily eat meat. Couldn't exactly cook it. And this was some time ago, so you couldn't so easily go and buy cooked meat. So she got the next best thing. Raw meat. She probably had no idea that anything from a pig is mightily more dangerous than other meats.

She should have just talked to her parents though.. They eventually found out and immediately switched to being a meat-eating family.


It must have been pretty unusual for them to be vegetarians back then. I'm guessing this was some time between around 1950 or earlier. Obviously there always have been vegetarians, but I think after the war they were a very small number.
-If people did not eat meat, those animals would not be bred at all, i.e. they would have no life
-Just because you are not eating meat doesn't mean that any difference has been made to the meat industry and therefore your mini-protest is pointless
-Many vegetarians will still wear leather coats and shoes and use products that have been tested on animals? what's the difference?
-Whilst we're on the subject of animal testing, it is absolutely necessary for drugs and also, it's the law, but i suppose you still take your paracetamol or antibiotics when you're ill so in this sense you're being a hypocrite
-Meat provides essential amino acids for your diet, why else do they need to take supplements all the time?
-Many vegetarians are deficient in vitamin K which means they they tend to get ill more often, and then have to take more drugs that have been tested on animals
-You cause a large inconvenience for any host and generally feel the need to preach or make comments about other people eating meat, which is annoying
-The body craves meat, I know a girl who has been brought up vegetarian (she is 4) and begs her grandmother for it
-People have been eating meat for thousands of years, it's bound up in our biology to eat it, you wouldn't stop breathing because you felt bad for the air?
-Also, vegetarians who eat fish bear no logic.
^I admire those who have the courage to reply to your ..."arguments".
Reply 118
Original post by Alison1992
-If people did not eat meat, those animals would not be bred at all, i.e. they would have no life


So your argument here is, "instead of letting them die out or evolve as nature dictates, we should breed them to kill them, cause that's the nicer thing to do"? Bull****. If they can't survive without us, we have three choices: set them free and let them die out; reduce their numbers and turn them into pets, etc. or give them to specialist animal sanctuaries.

I personally have no issue with letting them die out, if that's what nature dictates, just so you know. At least then they've had a chance of a real life, not the slavery they're in now.

Original post by Alison1992
-Just because you are not eating meat doesn't mean that any difference has been made to the meat industry and therefore your mini-protest is pointless


Oh, please, the whole "one vote won't make a difference" argument? No. Bull****. If everyone felt that way, nothing would ever change. Of course the meat industry isn't going to notice just one stopping, but that one influences friends and family and the amount of vegetarians and vegans grow. So there is a point.


Original post by Alison1992
-Many vegetarians will still wear leather coats and shoes and use products that have been tested on animals? what's the difference?


Many vegetarians aren't vegetarian for ethical reasons. Others wear leather shoes due to medical reasons. It's different for each person.

You're right though, they should, and I include myself in this cause I wear leather boots, should stop using all animal related products which involve the suffering of animals. However, that's not possible for everything.


Original post by Alison1992
-Whilst we're on the subject of animal testing, it is absolutely necessary for drugs and also, it's the law, but i suppose you still take your paracetamol or antibiotics when you're ill so in this sense you're being a hypocrite


It's not necessary. We could test on humans if we really wanted, we just refuse to because it'd be called "abuse of power" or there'd be accusations of coercion or forcing the poor into tests beause they need the money badly.


Original post by Alison1992
-Meat provides essential amino acids for your diet, why else do they need to take supplements all the time?


As I have shown elsewhere, all amino acids can be found outside of animal products, including the essential ones.


Original post by Alison1992
-Many vegetarians are deficient in vitamin K which means they they tend to get ill more often, and then have to take more drugs that have been tested on animals


Source? Many vegetarians have a bad diet, that doesn't make vegetarianism bad. When they eat a proper diet, vegetarians need no supplements, have a better immune system and have a 10% higher life expectancy.

This may be anecdotal, but it works: every meat eater I know gets ill more often than me.


Original post by Alison1992
-You cause a large inconvenience for any host and generally feel the need to preach or make comments about other people eating meat, which is annoying


Not every vegetarian preaches, I rarely do and only when the topic is brought up by others. Don't tar us all with the same brush.


Original post by Alison1992
-The body craves meat, I know a girl who has been brought up vegetarian (she is 4) and begs her grandmother for it


The body doesn't crave meat. I grew up eating very little other than meat. I used to devour 14oz steaks without any vegetables for dinner, etc. I haven't missed meat once in the 8 years that I've been vegetarian, nor have I ever craved it.

People I know who aren't vegetarian but often go for long stretches without meat always complain that after eating meat, their mucus production has increased, they feel more tired and sluggish and have less energy in general. If meat is so good for us, it wouldn't cause that kind of reaction in our bodies.

Children beg for sweets and crisps and toys, are you going to argue that this proves they need those things?


Original post by Alison1992
-People have been eating meat for thousands of years, it's bound up in our biology to eat it, you wouldn't stop breathing because you felt bad for the air?


Oh, please. We've been eating cooked meat for years, which is not the same thing as any other omnivore or carnivore in this world. Humans are very good at adapting and at doing things bad for us. Meat is one of those things.

Do you want to argue that doing drugs and drinking beer or caffeine is also bound up in our biology? We've been doing those things for thousands of years too.


Original post by Alison1992
-Also, vegetarians who eat fish bear no logic.


That's why they're not vegetarians, they're called "pescetarians".'


Original post by Cybele
We can eat meat/fish raw to an extent. Ever heard of steak tartar? Sushi? True carnivores have high levels of enzymes/acids which effectively kill off all nasty bacteria which is sometimes found on raw meat, humans learned that they were less likely to fall ill if they cooked their meat first. There are some people who will eat raw meat - inuits will often eat raw flesh/organs of animals they've hunted. I highly suspect that because most people are so used to eating cooked meat, suddenly switching to raw won't do us any good. But yes, we can eat raw meat, but it's hard to know which meat is free from harmful bacteria and which isn't.


Okay, I'll amend my statement, why do we need to cook it to be properly digestable? Inuits, for example, tend to be very unhealthy people with digestive tract problems. That we eat it raw doesn't mean we can digest it properly or that it's good for us.

For instance, consumption of meat has been traced to colon cancer, because it gets stuck down there and starts rotting because we can't digest it properly.




I disagree, torture for me means the deliberate mistreatment of anyone where it is not necessary and is done for any kind of gain.



I reckon we could, if we put the money into it, which we aren't. I am okay with dairy farming, though I'd prefer it to be without the whole rape and taking away of calves. Dairy farming can be ethical and I look on it as a prototype of "work for stay". The cows get looked after, they give something in return. Obviously we need to change the system, and utterly remove the meat industry, but dairy farming is not necessarily that bad. At the moment, however, it is.



I disagree. My mother was a farm-vet for a while, and she did it to help all animals, regardless of what the farmer thought.
(edited 13 years ago)
If they're not bred then they don't live, i thought you wanted animals to live?
people are never going to stop eating meat
If there's no difference then it's complete hypocrisy
Surely the fact that you have to take unnatural supplements prove that you're supposed to eat meat?
Why should people go out of their way to accommodate you?
I'm merely saying that it clearly hasn't harmed people for thousands of years, it's clearly what we're evolutionarily supposed to do
Pescatarians that think fish are less worthy, i've even heard a claim about no CNS,

basically, they're only animals, they serve no other real purpose, we may as well eat them, get off your self-righteous vegetarian high horse

Quick Reply

Latest

Trending

Trending