Doctor Who - Discussion Thread I

if amy pond dies im never watching doctor who again

I thought two and five were the strongest, and three the weakest (Martha )



This. So much. I thought Donna was funny, it was nice to have a companion where there wasn't any romance with the Doctor! With Rose it was okay since he loved her back (although they ruined it when they brought her back and gave her the second Doctor ) but Martha was just moping around after him the whole time. Plus she seemed really thick - I didn't believe she was a doctor for a minute, Rose worked in a shop and still had more common sense than her!

Amy Pond is a **** companion, though that can change I never cared about her in the last series.

Amy Pond is a **** companion, though that can change I never cared about her in the last series.

That's intriguing. It can't be the Doctor, it can't be Amy because she's been confirmed for the next few series, it can't really be Rory again because that would be stupid, so it has to be River. Although I highly doubted that as well! Oh God!

I'm interested: why have they all got tally charts on their arms?

Can't be River either because we've already seen her death.

...We have? Is this a spoiler, or something I've just blindly missed?

It obviously can't be River, right? She died in the library episode? I'm guessing it's the Doctor but in a roundabout way ie they/we think he dies but he's actually held somewhere as prisoner or perhaps even Amy but can't be Rory again?

But it also says one of them dies in the series opener ie in the first episode? So I'm guessing whoever it is comes back again at some point so either River or Amy regenerates into Idris but that doesn't seem likely.

In the library? First time the doctor meets her.

This month's DWM covers:

WARNING: THEY ARE VERY SPOILERISH

It obviously can't be River, right? She died in the library episode? I'm guessing it's the Doctor but in a roundabout way ie they/we think he dies but he's actually held somewhere as prisoner or perhaps even Amy but can't be Rory again?

But it also says one of them dies in the series opener ie in the first episode? So I'm guessing whoever it is comes back again at some point so either River or Amy regenerates into Idris but that doesn't seem likely.

I swear the number of people posting here has increased dramatically.

Since the 4 main, current iterations of the characters can't die for obvious reasons. I'm guessing it's

Either



or



My theories, will see if they are right.

He's emphasising that a character will properly die. But you have to take into account that he's extremely good at misdirection.

...We have? Is this a spoiler, or something I've just blindly missed?

The Library episode, remember? Vashta Narada? Flesh eating shadows? Anything....?


--- oh sorry saw the replies - twas a good episode though!!

It's going to be River killing the best man she's ever known.

So yno...rule out women. Probably.

EDIT: And there are previews tonight for media and competition winners and people who sneak in or whatever, so prepare for spoilers all over the internet tonight.

It's going to be River killing the best man she's ever known.

So yno...rule out women. Probably.

EDIT: And there are previews tonight for media and competition winners and people who sneak in or whatever, so prepare for spoilers all over the internet tonight.