Original post by electricjonExcellent point. I am forgetting that a community setting is completely different and I am in no means well placed to make such judgements about the competency of dentists. And I look forward to dental school and seeing how much emergency training you receive. In fact, I imagine that you do get more exposure than medics. Certainly on my course I didn't do that much, as previously alluded to.
I still maintain my opinion that the general public's understanding of the title doctor connects it exclusively to medical graduates. Maybe not on the emergency argument. Perhaps it is more that medics study a much broader curriculum of human disease and therefore have more translatable skills and knowledge for the general public to appreciate. Dentists, whilst sharing a lot of the medical curriculum initially, quickly begin to specialise and advance much more rapidly to senior level than their medical counterparts. With that comes greater responsibility and arguably justifies the inflated pay structure. Medics on the other hand graduate with a very basic and broad knowledge base, before spending the next 10-20 years of their career training in their chosen specialty before getting to the same level as dentists in terms of experience, responsibility and pay. But then again, to me, that is what being a doctor is all about - serving, helping and healing people and society, lifelong learning, personal and professional development, and a lot of other values that I'm sure are shared by dentists. All of them? Maybe some have alternative agendas but do they really do what a "doctor" should?
And I, like most of my medical colleagues, use the title doctor. Sometimes I'll say "I'm Jon, one of the doctors," some people say "I'm Dr so-and-so," but regardless of how - each and every time we do introduce ourselves to a patient, we have to say what our name is and what our job is. We can't just say "Hi I'm Steve" and get on with it - not only would that be unprofessional, we might be confused for a nurse, paramedic, porter, or worst of all... a student. Dentists can get away with it, because you're entirely surrounded by dental equipment and it's sort of implied as soon as the patient walks through the door.
Ultimately, medical doctors can lose the title by becoming surgeons. Then they go back to being Mr/Mrs/Miss. Some surgeons regard that as a mark of respect and superiority, trumped only by Professor/Sir/Lord. If you call a surgeon Dr it is considered seriously bad form. Yet dentists are surgeons, or at least, their degree does say Bachelor of Dental Surgery, so why are we squabbling about the title doctor when you could call yourself Mr/Mrs/Miss and then claim the moral high ground over doctors?
Personally I'm going for the title Duke, though Earl will be fine.