Doctor Who - Discussion Thread II

Scroll to see replies

Reply 400

Circadian_Rhythm

Original post by Ape Gone Insane

So The Doctor isn't real or ? :tongue:

Just this version, there could be about 3 Doctor's flying around at the moment :colonhash:

Reply 401

spacepirate-James

Original post by Don'tNod

Yes, I did. The Doctor did mention that they should each keep an eye on them, so maybe one pair of eyes is sufficient? Reminds me of the Angels quite a lot. :s-smilie:

Nah cause in the White House's toilets Amy was still looking at the Silent but the american woman kept forgetting.

I dunno.....

Reply 402

Ape Gone Insane

Original post by ??????????????????

Why did the Silence need Amy for their fake TARDIS.
Looks like their plans involve Time Lords. Time Lord child and fake TARDIS.

Good point. They said Amy would bring the Silence.

Reply 403

sleekchic

Original post by Madjackismad

The girl wouldn't be his murderer now that she's out of the suit.

Timey wimey? Does she kill the Doctor in 2011, absorb his regeneration energy and then travel back to 1969?

Original post by Circadian_Rhythm

What happened in the 'still dreaming' scene? I realise who the woman is, but how did she get there.

In that PM it said her whole life was a 'spoiler', could this be it? Could her whole life be fabricated, hence she is still dreaming?

Who is the woman?

Reply 404

Madjackismad

David Lynch is writing an episode for the next series. :shock:

Spoiler

Reply 405

Rascacielos

Original post by Circadian_Rhythm

What happened in the 'still dreaming' scene? I realise who the woman is, but how did she get there.

?

Who was the woman, then?

Original post by Circadian_Rhythm

In that PM it said her whole life was a 'spoiler', could this be it? Could her whole life be fabricated, hence she is still dreaming?

Which scene?

Reply 406

Aleeece123

I am SO confused right now...

Reply 407

Madjackismad

Original post by sleekchic

Timey wimey? Does she kill the Doctor in 2011, absorb his regeneration energy and then travel back to 1969?

Who is the woman?

Oh, maybe, I don't know. Did we see the regeneration energy go over to the astronaut in the last episode?

Reply 408

spacepirate-James

Original post by Ape Gone Insane

http://www.bbc.co.uk/i/b010y5l3/?t=17m45s

Well I totally forgot about that. Maybe I saw a Silent or something.

That is one weird scene...Now I'm totally confused.

Reply 409

Ape Gone Insane

I think he just means her name, not who she actually is. Madame Kovarian. Takes care of the little girl.

Reply 410

Rascacielos

Original post by Circadian_Rhythm

The Doctor has been known to lie before..

True, but that would be a huge disappointment. The idea of his life being in Amy's hands was a nice twist.

Original post by Don'tNod

Yes, I did. The Doctor did mention that they should each keep an eye on them, so maybe one pair of eyes is sufficient? Reminds me of the Angels quite a lot. :s-smilie:

I think each person has to be looking at the Silence to remember it. If you remember the scene with the woman in the toilet (near the Oval Office), when she turned around she forgot completely, even though Amy was still looking at the Silence.

Reply 411

??????????????????

When Amy saw the picture of her with a baby, and then the girl coming from behind, I remembered, 'Are you my mummy?' :laugh:

Also, the spaceman ate her?

(edited 12 years ago)

Reply 412

Circadian_Rhythm

Original post by Rascacielos

?

Who was the woman, then?

Look below.

Which scene?

The one where Amy is walking through the orphanage, and she sees the woman through the hatch, and then the hatch disappears etc.

(edited 12 years ago)

Reply 413

Circadian_Rhythm

Original post by Ape Gone Insane

I think he just means her name, not who she actually is. Madame Kovarian. Takes care of the little girl.

Original post by sleekchic

Timey wimey? Does she kill the Doctor in 2011, absorb his regeneration energy and then travel back to 1969?

Who is the woman?

Indeed.

Reply 414

Madjackismad

Original post by ??????????????????

When Amy saw the picture of her with a baby, and then the girl coming from behind, I remembered, 'Are you my mummy?' :laugh:

I thought she was going to say that! Considering that Stephen Moffat wrote those episodes. :p:

Reply 415

sleekchic

The TARDIS from The Lodger definitely hasn't been resolved. If it was one of the Silents', then why was it abandoned especially if they've been there for centuries and why did The Lodger TARDIS need a pilot if the Silents already existed?

Reply 416

spacepirate-James

This Madame person looks quite like River Song :ninja:

Original post by sleekchic

ehy did The Lodger TARDIS need a pilot if the Silents already existed?

The same reason they need Amy's child perhaps...Maybe only a Time Lord could pilot a Tardis?

(edited 12 years ago)

Reply 417

Don'tNod

Original post by sleekchic

I think that scene is really important but I think it was Amy and not the girl that was 'dreaming'. I honestly don't know but it's really confusing not knowing.

I think so too, watching the scene once more has made me realize she doesn't seem to be addressing Amy. :confused:

Reply 418

maxcartwright

im so confused re Doctor and River Song relationship. how is it that he doesnt know her a lot if he met her when she was young?
plus how is aimees kid a time lord

and i now luurve canton everett delaware the 3rd

Reply 419

Rascacielos

Original post by sleekchic

Timey wimey? Does she kill the Doctor in 2011, absorb his regeneration energy and then travel back to 1969?

Who is the woman?

I said last week, when the visor was lifted up at the edge of the lake it definitely didn't look like the little girl underneath (you can see the very bottom part of the face if you look closely). It looked similar to a Sontaran, although I'm sure it wasn't.