The Student Room Group

Scroll to see replies

Original post by shadow99
Moving abroad is your only option, otherwise your taxes will go to the NHS.


Technically if you take back the same as what you're forced to put in it's irrelevant.
Original post by TulipFields
It does stink of hypocrisy, yes. You used the services, and you will probably use them again if thR need arises, and yet you choose to deny the system that provides it. Asthma is not covered by private insurance, so I guess that scrapping NHS would mean that you either drop dead or pay extortionate prices for treatment?
And don't give me bull**** about private insurance being better if a state healthcare wouldn't exist.

So if you think we should nationalise food, then it's hypocritical to eat?
Likewise with trains, I presume that if you think you should nationalise trains - it's hypocritical to use them?

There's nothing hypocritical in using the services I've paid for.

You'd also think that asthma would be treated in the private sector, you know, when you have multiple companies trying to get you to pick their health insurance. The whole dynamics of the sector are different when there is a free alternative - companies don't gain an advantage in offering asthma treatment currently, but they would (indeed, they'd gain all of the asthmatics - it'd be a fantastic business opportunity).

Don't give me bull**** about the fundamentals of economics not applying without giving any reasons why.
Original post by otester
It is if you have something between your ears. :wink:

Also I'd say it's semi-capitalist/socialist.


Plenty of people have something between their ears, and yet fail at starting a business. Running something viable doesn't only depend on your brains, of that was a case, there would be far less closed businesses.
Besides, there would still be a need of workforce, not everyone can be a boss and make big bucks by himself
Original post by isaqyi
I am considering getting private health insurance, but no longer wish to contribute to the NHS as it is the worst healthcare system in Western Europe. I do not see it as my responsibility to pay for other peoples' healthcare, when I am more than willing to pay for my own.

Is there any way I can stop the British public stealing my money to pay for their healthcare?


its part of tax so you can't stop paying. move out of the country if you want to stop paying
Original post by jesusandtequila
So if you think we should nationalise food, then it's hypocritical to eat?
Likewise with trains, I presume that if you think you should nationalise trains - it's hypocritical to use them?

There's nothing hypocritical in using the services I've paid for.

You'd also think that asthma would be treated in the private sector, you know, when you have multiple companies trying to get you to pick their health insurance. The whole dynamics of the sector are different when there is a free alternative - companies don't gain an advantage in offering asthma treatment currently, but they would (indeed, they'd gain all of the asthmatics - it'd be a fantastic business opportunity).

Don't give me bull**** about the fundamentals of economics not applying without giving any reasons why.

Don't compare healthcare to food. They are not the same, which you should undestand. If you don't fancy an expensive restaurant meal, you could go home and cook your own food, you won't treat yourself at home when you break your leg
State does not provide it's services for profit, whereas a business will ( which any insurance company will) and even with a limited choice, you will have to pay up, for the lack of an alternative.
Offering an insurance for asthma is not profitable, why do you think it's not covered? Why do you think some non-profitable treatments are only available on NHS? If you constantly need medical help, your insurance would be far higher, so it would run into the same amount as for NHS, if not more. Because, again, state does not seek to profit from you. Try and calculate how much your treatments over the years would cost and compare to what you pay. That assuming no injuries or traumas for the duration of your life.
Original post by TulipFields
Don't compare healthcare to food. They are not the same, which you should undestand. If you don't fancy an expensive restaurant meal, you could go home and cook your own food, you won't treat yourself at home when you break your leg
State does not provide it's services for profit, whereas a business will ( which any insurance company will) and even with a limited choice, you will have to pay up, for the lack of an alternative.
Offering an insurance for asthma is not profitable, why do you think it's not covered? Why do you think some non-profitable treatments are only available on NHS? If you constantly need medical help, your insurance would be far higher, so it would run into the same amount as for NHS, if not more. Because, again, state does not seek to profit from you. Try and calculate how much your treatments over the years would cost and compare to what you pay. That assuming no injuries or traumas for the duration of your life.

Did you ignore the section on risk equalisation in my healthcare proposal?
Original post by jesusandtequila
Did you ignore the section on risk equalisation in my healthcare proposal?


I didn't read it. Because we are not talking about implementing your proposal. We are talking about current situation, where people decide that thu cba paying taxes for services they don't use.
I'll read it when I have more free time though.
Original post by TulipFields
I didn't read it. Because we are not talking about implementing your proposal. We are talking about current situation, where people decide that thu cba paying taxes for services they don't use.
I'll read it when I have more free time though.

It's just that you keep making arguments against something which I'm not proposing as what I'd do, and it seems rather silly to carry on...
Original post by jesusandtequila
It's just that you keep making arguments against something which I'm not proposing as what I'd do, and it seems rather silly to carry on...


I believe my initial argument was that it's fair to be taxed and it's fair to expect vital services from it, and that NHS is a vital service. And I stand by it
Original post by isaqyi
There is no such thing as society. There are men, women, and families.
Margaret Thatcher

I think that that explains my position very well.


Try reading on the rest of the speech...

"There is no such thing as society. There is living tapestry of men and women and people and the beauty of that tapestry and the quality of our lives will depend upon how much each of us is prepared to take responsibility for ourselves and each of us prepared to turn round and help by our own efforts those who are unfortunate."
Original post by TulipFields
Plenty of people have something between their ears, and yet fail at starting a business. Running something viable doesn't only depend on your brains, of that was a case, there would be far less closed businesses.
Besides, there would still be a need of workforce, not everyone can be a boss and make big bucks by himself


You can't always win, I've done projects which turned out to be dead ends, and yes I generalized a bit, you have to work, but apply it correctly, hard work alone is nothing.

Not everyone will be worker/boss at the same time, same way the birth/death rate will never be exactly the same.

Original post by SoapyDish
Try reading on the rest of the speech...

"There is no such thing as society. There is living tapestry of men and women and people and the beauty of that tapestry and the quality of our lives will depend upon how much each of us is prepared to take responsibility for ourselves and each of us prepared to turn round and help by our own efforts those who are unfortunate."


PWNED, lol.
(edited 12 years ago)
Reply 331
Original post by SoapyDish
each of us prepared to turn round and help by our own efforts those who are unfortunate."


Of our own volition.

I, however, could not care less about these people. Why should I have my wages stolen to provide welfare for them?
Original post by otester
You can't always win, I've done projects which turned out to be dead ends, and yes I generalized a bit, you have to work, but apply it correctly, hard work alone is nothing.



PWNED, lol.


Obviously my failure is nothing to you, I was just saying that few have what it takes to be a successful businessman, and it's not as easy as saying "screw you" to your boss and then somehow becoming more successful
Reply 333
Original post by isaqyi
Of our own volition.

I, however, could not care less about these people. Why should I have my wages stolen to provide welfare for them?


Do you want to have the 'taxes are stealing' argument or the 'poor people don't deserve welfare' argument?

For the latter, which is more on topic, those poor people make up part of the economy that you rely on for your precious wages.
Reply 334
Original post by dring
Do you want to have the 'taxes are stealing' argument or the 'poor people don't deserve welfare' argument?

For the latter, which is more on topic, those poor people make up part of the economy that you rely on for your precious wages.


I somewhat doubt it, half of them don't even work. How do I rely on someone on incapacity benefit for suffering from IBS (basically having to **** a lot)?
Reply 335
Original post by isaqyi
I somewhat doubt it, half of them don't even work. How do I rely on someone on incapacity benefit for suffering from IBS (basically having to **** a lot)?


Of course you doubt it, you've already made up your mind, and supported your view by making up statistics. There's no way you can argue against that kind of delusion.
Original post by isaqyi
Various ramblings...


You know, it's not often that I wish illness on someone, but I have to say that I think if you ended up falling victim to a disease through no fault of your own that left you unable to work and pay for your cushty health insurance, your attitude would probably change and you'd be quite glad that other people's tax money was being used to fund your NHS treatment.
Original post by TulipFields
Obviously my failure is nothing to you, I was just saying that few have what it takes to be a successful businessman, and it's not as easy as saying "screw you" to your boss and then somehow becoming more successful


You haven't truly failed until you stop trying.

Starting your own business doesn't mean quitting the one you currently have, if you put all your eggs in one basket (risk everything) and fail, it's your own fault and deserve all you get.
I love how many Sh!tLADs this has got compared to GoodLADs.
Original post by isaqyi
That's one hospital out of hundreds of thousands.

My argument is that if you don't pay your insurance, then **** off. Harsh but fair.


You are ridiculous all you seem to think about is money, what about people that die because they can't afford insurance, that's a life what does money matter when people are dying.

Latest

Trending

Trending