Doctor Who - Discussion Thread II

Why does he have to rewrite anything? All he had to have done was to write the Amy character before she appeared on screen...

How many episodes are left for this series ?

How many episodes are left for this series ?

Hmmm though I suppose it could have always been the plan from the start...

Really?

I've got a few questions about Amy:
1) At what point do we assume she became a ganger?
2) Where is she now?
3) How long has the Doctor known?
4) Does her being a ganger explain why her pregnancy was fluctuating or...?



In this episode, yes. Although it obviously isn't.

I've got a few questions about Amy:
1) At what point do we assume she became a ganger?
2) Where is she now?
3) How long has the Doctor known?
4) Does her being a ganger explain why her pregnancy was fluctuating or...?
5) Why does eye patch lady still pop up?
6) What on earth do they want Amy for? If she were pregnant, why couldn't the pregnancy just run naturally?





In this episode, yes. Although it obviously isn't.

1) It has to be before episode 2. As in episode 2 we first see her encounter with kovarian, the eye-patch lady. Some people are speculating that it was between the three month gap between Impossible Astronaut and Day of the Moon. Some think that it's even before TIA

2) We don't know yet.

3) This is under speculation too. It's possible he knew at the end of episode 2, it's possible that he didn't know until episode 5. I can't remember the quote that evidenced the theory he might have known in episode 2, but it was a convincing one. Was posted a couple of pages back.

4) Yes, as real Amy is pregnant, but ganger Amy isn't. Which also means she must have become pregnant after her ganger was made.

Referencing the above post: If anyone posts spoilers of the identity of River, please state explicitly that that is what's in the spoiler!

4- Not necessarily. The Silence could have taken the baby out of the clone Amy.

DT did 4 series (if you count the specials as a series), MS has done 2 now. But wait a minute, of course MS should have done 4 series by now, DT did after all didn't he?

How do you reckon that DT would have saved everyone then? A few of the characters sacrificed themselves last night.

DT would have made sure they all realsied he was in charge the electric volt thing would have been put down first ganger of buzzer isnt killed all of them leave in the tardis

A DT "Almost People" would just involve lots more running, and snarling angry face occasionally

I'm also going with this because it would explain why she saw Madam Kovarian in the orphanage because she had already been kidnapped but that doesn't explain why the Silence kidnapped her again?