This discussion is now closed.

Check out other Related discussions

Doctor Who - Discussion Thread II

The thing with Amy is she was brought up with a 'crack in the skin of the universe' in her bedroom, that could make her have some timey-wimey stuff in her that would affect her child?

EDIT: grr Sleekchic literally just posted that as I was typing!

Reply 4641

sleekchic

18

Original post by Ape Gone Insane

And they have bunk beds. I thought the implication was that sex did not happen in the TARDIS. :awesome:

It's not like bunk beds make sex impossible. I thought that just implied that the Doctor could be a bit clueless at times not that sex did not happen.

(edited 12 years ago)

Reply 4642

emi_sarb

10

A weird idea but what if;

Spoiler

Just an idea that randomly came to me but is probably completely wrong.

Reply 4643

cambo211

19

Original post by Ape Gone Insane

Bunch of perverts. The whole lot of them. :awesome:

Of course they are.

They can go anywhere they like with no worry of being seen because as soon as they leave the room everyone entirely forgets what happens. There must be some of them who 'abuse' this :tongue:

Reply 4644

Undulipodia

Original post by cambo211

Of course they are.

They can go anywhere they like with no worry of being seen because as soon as they leave the room everyone entirely forgets what happens. There must be some of them who 'abuse' this :tongue:

Wonderful - creepy suit-men who are everywhere and have built-in rohipnol. Isn't that a pleasant thought?

Reply 4645

Interrobang

20

Original post by emi_sarb

A weird idea but what if;

Spoiler

Just an idea that randomly came to me but is probably completely wrong.

Spoiler

As for the 'why Amy?' I think it links back to the crack in her wall and her 'bringing the silence' as others have said. As for the length of time, it wouldn't necessarily be 9 months, as if the baby is even part alien species, that could affect the pregnancy (My Hero, for those who remember that show?)

Reply 4646

Becka-la

Original post by cambo211

That's exactly what he said :lolwut:

The ganger wasn't pregnant therefore it must've been more than nine months.

Or, as Sawwah said, she was cloned when she was pregnant and the clone amy was kidnapped by the silents and they took the clone baby out of her. Hence the quote 'I was pregnant, but not anymore, i mean i was wrong.' or similar words. :P

Reply 4647

Becka-la

Original post by Ape Gone Insane

Pregnant Amy? He mentions 3 separate people...

Not a spoiler, large images:

Spoiler

Pond 1, Pond 2 and then after some back and forth he then acknowledges Rory 'And Rory the Roman'.

Alternatively, he could be talking about the ganger. Bear in mind, this is the Future Doctor and so he already knows about things.

Pond 1 and Pond 2 = Amy +baby???

Reply 4648

Mr Ben

14

Original post by emi_sarb

A weird idea but what if;

Spoiler

Just an idea that randomly came to me but is probably completely wrong.

The problem with that idea is the alternate ending to Journey's End where...

Spoiler

(edited 12 years ago)

Reply 4649

spacepirate-James

18

Don't know if anyone has posted this but a Doctor Who anime:

:awesome:

Reply 4650

cambo211

19

Original post by spacepirate-James

Don't know if anyone has posted this but a Doctor Who anime:

:awesome:

Someone posted it earlier :tongue:

Reply 4651

emi_sarb

10

Original post by Mr Ben

The problem with that idea is the alternate ending to Journey's End where...

Spoiler

I didn't know about that. There's also the "the silence will fall" comment at the end of big bang 2. Maybe

Spoiler

Reply 4652

Becka-la

Original post by Ape Gone Insane

That was my line of thought too.

Coupled with the line 'And you've put on a few pounds...'

*Gasp* That's kind of mean... Even if it's true you should never say that to anybody. Sigh, the Doctor's naivety is cute. :rolleyes:

Reply 4653

Oncoming Storm

1

Original post by Ape Gone Insane

That was my line of thought too.

Coupled with the line 'And you've put on a few pounds...'

Well that's how everyone knew she was going to say she was pregnant before she said it, because the Doctor was making those comments.

Reply 4654

sheep_go_baa

1

Original post by Ape Gone Insane

It will ~~probably~~ be explained tomorrow.

We must keep faith!

Reply 4655

Oncoming Storm

1

Original post by Ape Gone Insane

Well mean if you're actually putting on a few pounds by getting a bit ... chubbier. :awesome:

But not so mean if it's a sly reference to pregnancy.

Yes, but the point trying to be made is discerning which is pregnant Amy and at which point. And she was forced to say she was pregnant. Not whether she was actually pregnant.

This coupled with the Doctor explicitly saying 'Pond 1 and Pond 2 and Rory the Roman'.

You know what? I don't know why we bother.

It will probably be explained tomorrow.

We shouldn't speculate against the genius of Moffat. He always foils us.

*shakes fist*
Mofaaaaaat!

Reply 4656

Becka-la

Original post by Ape Gone Insane

Well mean if you're actually putting on a few pounds by getting a bit ... chubbier. :awesome:

But not so mean if it's a sly reference to pregnancy.

Yes, but the point trying to be made is discerning which is pregnant Amy and at which point. And she was forced to say she was pregnant. Not whether she was actually pregnant.

This coupled with the Doctor explicitly saying 'Pond 1 and Pond 2 and Rory the Roman'.

You know what? I don't know why we bother.

It will probably be explained tomorrow.

Very true. :cool: