Doctor Who - Discussion Thread II

And yet we foiled his plan with Amy the Ganger (well, at least Ape did)
I bet there would be even more questions after tomorrow- they would tease us wth some revelations and then create millions of other speculations

There are clips of Matt Smith on The One Show on BBC

http://www.bbc.co.uk/doctorwho/dw/news/bulletin_110603_01/Matt_Smith_on_The_One_Show

As always. I have too many questions and it seems like I'll never be satisfied. And it would be so like Moffat to end his era (whenever that happens) with more things to speculate about.

I didn't know about that. There's also the "the silence will fall" comment at the end of big bang 2. Maybe

I kinda like that- no-one wants a flat happy ending- there has to be a teasr for the next series to look forward to

But the Silent said that Amy will bring the silence (day of the moon), [and I just realised the silent also said her part will soon be over, never realised that].
And by the "silence will fall" comment heart throughout series 5, I always thought it meant that the silence will invade like a ..blanket convering the earth (!?wth.) [WORST.ANALOGY.EVER], rather than their downfall. Bearing in mind that for the whole of the first series, whenever it was said 'silence will fall' it was mainly by an enemy.

Anyway, I was watching the 'Peter Hoar introduces A Good Man Goes To War', and they played the clip of River asking Tennant who 'Please tell me you know who I am'' and he didn't recognise her and my heart just shattered into a million pieces so much so I've forgotten all use of commas and full stops :'(

But the Silent said that Amy will bring the silence (day of the moon), [and I just realised the silent also said her part will soon be over, never realised that].
And by the "silence will fall" comment heart throughout series 5, I always thought it meant that the silence will invade like a ..blanket convering the earth (!?wth.) [WORST.ANALOGY.EVER], rather than their downfall. Bearing in mind that for the whole of the first series, whenever it was said 'silence will fall' it was mainly by an enemy.

Anyway, I was watching the 'Peter Hoar introduces A Good Man Goes To War', and they played the clip of River asking Tennant!Who 'Please tell me you know who I am'' and he didn't recognise her and my heart just shattered into a million pieces so much so I've forgotten all use of commas and full stops :'(

I was rewatching that episode yesterday and I cried. I was thinking "Ohhhh, River!" and I had the same feeling when I saw her face after they kissed. I felt so depressed afterwards.

Yeah, I'm glad series 5 didn't end with all the loose ends nicely tied off like they were in RTD's time. Still love RTD but it's nice to have a change.

The Silence don't invade since they already lived here.
EDIT:5,000 post



I saw that two weeks ago in German subs lol Don't understand how some people say that in SitL/FotD that she doesn't seem upset that the Doctor doesn't recognize her. Must have skipped that scene.

I definitely agree! I liked RTD's episodes, but I also liked the change. Plus, it would be a bit silly to wrap the first season up like that, the new Doctors era is just starting.
Which is why I think that Amy and Rory would have to be changed as companions one day- otherwise it would be too samey. As much as I liked Rose, it would have been a lot more boring to have her all the time, and if Donna/Martha were not introduced as well.

The Silence don't invade since they already lived here.
EDIT:5,000 post



I saw that two weeks ago in German subs lol Don't understand how some people say that in SitL/FotD that she doesn't seem upset that the Doctor doesn't recognize her. Must have skipped that scene.

you know what I meant ok not invade, but like start being recognised... I don't know I what I'm talking about. I never do, but I make the mistake of putting my thoughts on the internet and it all goes downhill from there.

Yeah, I know what you mean. There's got to be change. The fact that they went on and on about Rose through pretty much all of series 3 bugged the hell out of me. I was thinking "Let go!!!". So yeah, I'd say Amy and Rory should go either the end of this series or end of the next (Probably this one, more than 2 series is milking it somewhat) because otherwise they'll get boring and it'll end with everyone hating them. Which would be a shame.

BUT THE GANGER FELT THE PREGNANCY!

So...

Yeah, I know what you mean. There's got to be change. The fact that they went on and on about Rose through pretty much all of series 3 bugged the hell out of me. I was thinking "Let go!!!". So yeah, I'd say Amy and Rory should go either the end of this series or end of the next (Probably this one, more than 2 series is milking it somewhat) because otherwise they'll get boring and it'll end with everyone hating them. Which would be a shame.

I kind of want them for another series (but that's coz I really hate change! ) especially if