Doctor Who - Discussion Thread II

I thought them feeling sick was because they'd just seen and forgotten a Silence...

Either way, I'm a firm believer in the Doctor and River have a kid theory. River is human with Time Lord DNA. I don't think she's even half and half. Human Ten (half and half) couldn't regenerate so that makes me think River can't either. Which is why I believe in them having a child :smile:

(Plus the fact that River can't remember being held captive by the Silence - ignoring the fact that she'd forget them anyway -she'd remember escaping to New York and probably would be able to put 2 and 2 together when she's an adult... :smile:

)

(edited 12 years ago)

Reply 5442

Urmmm... this would mean that she kills her dad... starting to doubt this theory! Plus I'm still convinced the Doctor faked his death so Amy etc would do something about it.

Something I'm still confused about: Who was that man in TIA who had the no. 4 invitation?

Reply 5443

Original post by Stargatecrazy

)

Not sure, they definately thought that, but funny how no-one else said that they felt sick...

Reply 5444

Gemini92

Original post by emzieee

Something I'm still confused about: Who was that man in TIA who had the no. 4 invitation?

It was the FBI agent (Canton Delaware?) that helped them fight the Silence, just quite a bit older.

Reply 5445

Rascacielos

I'm guessing this has already been speculated about but there was an update on my Facebook about something "exciting" happening during the break and that the clue was: "there's 11 of them." Ideas?

Reply 5446

Original post by Gemini92

It was the FBI agent (Canton Delaware?) that helped them fight the Silence, just quite a bit older.

Oh right.

Surely the Doctor trusted someone else more than him though?

Reply 5447

Original post by emzieee

Oh right.

Surely the Doctor trusted someone else more than him though?

I thinks it more that he was involved with the silence rather than that he trusted him? Also at some point he would have to tell him to bring the petrol

Reply 5448

Original post by emzieee

So, there's a huge theory that River kills Rory (her dad)...if River was made to be a weapon, how do we know they don't steal her kid to do the same? It's all about killing the Doctor :smile:

The kid might not know who her parents are :smile:

The Doctor wouldn't do that. He probably invited them so they couldn't do anything about it (without interfering with and messing up their timelines).

Canton Everate Delaware III. He's the guy that helped them in 1969 :smile:

Reply 5449

Original post by Stargatecrazy

So, there's a huge theory that River kills Rory (her dad)...if River was made to be a weapon, how do we know they don't steal her kid to do the same? It's all about killing the Doctor :smile:

The kid might not know who her parents are :smile:

The Doctor wouldn't do that. He probably invited them so they couldn't do anything about it (without interfering with and messing up their timelines).
Canton Everate Delaware III. He's the guy that helped them in 1969 :smile:

Sorry to sound thick but how does this work? :confused:

Reply 5450

Original post by Stargatecrazy

So, there's a huge theory that River kills Rory (her dad)...if River was made to be a weapon, how do we know they don't steal her kid to do the same? It's all about killing the Doctor :smile:

The kid might not know who her parents are :smile:

have i missed something? since when has river had a kid? :confused:

Reply 5451

green chica

all i have to say it i'm SO GLAD they've not been using the daleks lately. those things were so damn annoying and i couldn't take them seriously.

Reply 5452

Original post by green chica

all i have to say it i'm SO GLAD they've not been using the daleks lately. those things were so damn annoying and i couldn't take them seriously.

I like the episodes with them in but i'd have to agree. I always thought it was unfair that lots of daleks kept appearing after somehow managing to escape the time war but the time lords couldn't!!!

Reply 5453

forestfruits

all i have to say it i'm SO GLAD they've not been using the daleks lately. those things were so damn annoying and i couldn't take them seriously.

the new daleks do look like teletubbies.

anyway i also don't understand how river could be a weapon? but it all adds up that she kills the doctor - as she is going to be 'a weapon', the astronaught killed him plus she said that she was younger when she killed 'the best of men'. how does rory come into it? :s-smilie:

Reply 5454

Lantana

Original post by bluepolicebox

have i missed something? since when has river had a kid? :confused:

We're just speculating. We don't know if she has or has not.

Original post by emzieee

Sorry to sound thick but how does this work? :confused:

Supposedly if you meet yourself, you cause a paradox and rip a hole in time and space

Reply 5455

Original post by emzieee

Sorry to sound thick but how does this work? :confused:

Because they can't go back to that time to stop it because they're already there. And they can't stop it as then it wouldn't happen and they wouldn't know to go and stop it.

Original post by bluepolicebox

have i missed something? since when has river had a kid? :confused:

She doesn't, it's the theory that her and the Doctor are going to have a kid and that it's that kid that the Silence have :smile:

Original post by forestfruits

We don't know it was her that killed the Doctor. The little girl escaped in 1969 and the Doctor died in 2011...so it could be the girl, but it might not :smile:

Reply 5456

forestfruits

[QUOTEKazran met himself and even touched himself.

Don't. ] heehee.

iv heard people talking about the 11 as well. who are they? iv never heard of them!?

Reply 5457

Original post by Ape Gone Insane

Father's Day was very different to normally meeting yourself. You can meet yourself fine and not have any devastating effects, at least in Doctor Who. Well to be honest, they seem to bend the rules when they want. Kazran met himself and even touched himself.

Don't. :colonhash:

Yeah but there's also the fact that because they were there that they know how he dies. And so if they try and change it, he won't die and they won't know to change it... PARADOX :eek:

Reply 5458

forestfruits

We don't know it was her that killed the Doctor. The little girl escaped in 1969 and the Doctor died in 2011...so it could be the girl, but it might not

yeah i guess so... but she could regenerate like a time lord - what if she can somehow time travel as well?

Reply 5459