The Student Room Group
Uni students - Complete our survey >>
Uni students - Complete our survey >>
Uni students - Complete our survey >>

The Libertarian Society of TSR.

Scroll to see replies

Original post by turn and fall
Yes - well inheritance does not



F.A.Hayek



Assuming the price signalling mechanism has not been corrupted then yes. To suppose otherwise would likely be demagoguery.


Argument from authority FAIL
Circular reasoning FAIL


You're not very good at this are you.
Original post by Kibalchich
Yeah, the freedom to starve. I demolished that already. Try again.

No you didn't. I am very comfortable with the notion that freedom has nothing to do with food. It is to do with the actions you are able to take. Not the commodities you have.
Original post by turn and fall
No you didn't. I am very comfortable with the notion that freedom has nothing to do with food. It is to do with the actions you are able to take. Not the commodities you have.


You can't take any action if you're dead of starvation. Action is contingent on food.

You fail. AGAIN.
Can a law be passed to enable me to **** in public?

Aren't you people all for that kind of thing?
Original post by Kibalchich
Argument from authority FAIL
Circular reasoning FAIL


You're not very good at this are you.


But you do not understand basic economics though do you?
Original post by turn and fall
But you do not understand basic economics though do you?


FAIL.
Original post by Kibalchich
Yeah, the freedom to starve. I demolished that already. Try again.



What? :confused:


Freedom to choose to act (or omit) for yourself ....

And people can choose to starve ...
Original post by Lord Hysteria
Freedom to choose to act (or omit) for yourself ....

And people can choose to starve ...


Yes, people can choose to starve. So? What about all those with not enough to eat who don't choose to starve?

You FAIL at this :biggrin:
Original post by Kibalchich
Yes, people can choose to starve. So? What about all those with not enough to eat who don't choose to starve?

You FAIL at this :biggrin:


As I wrote on a blog:

[INDENT]It is a conflation of the very definition of coercion. Being denied something, for whatever reason, has nothing to do with being coerced. Coercion is being denied the freedom to choose for ownself - and not the fact that one's options are limited.[/INDENT]

So, your real problem is not about freedom - but reality and its condition.
Original post by Lord Hysteria
As I wrote on a blog:

[INDENT]It is a conflation of the very definition of coercion. Being denied something, for whatever reason, has nothing to do with being coerced. Coercion is being denied the freedom to choose for ownself - and not the fact that one's options are limited.[/INDENT]

So, your real problem is not about freedom - but reality and its condition.


You're defining freedom as having no application to reality? :eek:

MASSIVE FAIL
you look like a right **** btw :biggrin:
Original post by Kibalchich
FAIL.


Okay then, explain to me why I am wrong.
Original post by turn and fall
Okay then, explain to me why I am wrong.



Care to respond to my points, rather than attempting to change the subject?
Reply 493
Avatar for Planar
Planar
15
I'm libertarian(ish - I have doubts)
Original post by Kibalchich
Care to respond to my points, rather than attempting to change the subject?


I have responded to them with which you have just argued I have used fallacies, which in some cases was true but I was just using them for efficiency.

I am not changing the subject, prove to me why my conjecture is false.

Why is the market not the best voting machine?
man up ffs!
Original post by turn and fall
I have responded to them with which you have just argued I have used fallacies, which in some cases was true but I was just using them for efficiency.

I am not changing the subject, prove to me why my conjecture is false.

Why is the market not the best voting machine?


I've just demolished all your arguments. At least have the balls to admit it, then we can move on :biggrin:
Original post by Kibalchich
I've just demolished all your arguments. At least have the balls to admit it, then we can move on :biggrin:


I am ever so sorry, could you explain it to me in one go, I am not smart enough to deal with all the fractal arguments :frown:
man the **** up, pussy
Original post by Kibalchich
man the **** up, pussy


Thought as much.

Quick Reply

Related discussions

Latest

Trending

Trending

Articles for you