Join TSR now and get all your career questions answeredSign up now

Master's in Management vs Finance Watch

    • Thread Starter
    Offline

    0
    ReputationRep:
    Originally posted this in the "Postgraduate" section, but I wanted to hear more opinions, especially from anyone currently working:

    From the several offers I received I have narrowed it down to Durham's Master in Finance and EM Lyon's Master in Management. I am torn between these two. I have explored almost every single aspect of these programs and have no idea which one to choose.

    Given my complete lack of relevant experience as well as my goal of eventually finding a job in IB or CorpFin (no location preference), which one would be a better choice?

    Durham's MSc.Finance:
    -1 year (not a good thing in my case since less time to find an internship)
    -Closer to London (+)
    -English language spoken everywhere (+)
    -More specialized degree (+)

    EM Lyon's MSc.Management:
    -2 to 3 years with 6 months abroad and 12 months of in-company internships (bad and good)
    -Ranked fairly well (+)
    -Further away from London (-)
    -Lack of French will hinder my progress in just about every single way (-)
    -Has a Finance track, but still might be too broad of a degree

    I don't have any internships under my belt so taking on a Master's degree can quickly become pointless if I graduate without changing that. At the same time though, I have no idea how investment banks in England see someone holding a MSc. in Management from a French school outside the top-3. Nor am I intuned to how Durham's Master's students are viewed. From speaking with a couple EM Lyon's students, some BBs do give interviews and there is certainly some type of representation in London from Durham, but I'm pretty sure all of those graduates already had an internship before taking on a Master's degree, which snowballed into getting further opportunities and finally resulted in a FT offer.

    Just to get this out there: I realize this will be nearly impossible to pull off, so I'm being realistic. I'll be focusing on boutiques and MM firms as well as the Big4,CorpFin and so on, but my endgoal is IB.

    Any thoughts on this?
    Offline

    2
    ReputationRep:
    (Original post by realdeal87)
    Originally posted this in the "Postgraduate" section, but I wanted to hear more opinions, especially from anyone currently working:

    From the several offers I received I have narrowed it down to Durham's Master in Finance and EM Lyon's Master in Management. I am torn between these two. I have explored almost every single aspect of these programs and have no idea which one to choose.

    Given my complete lack of relevant experience as well as my goal of eventually finding a job in IB or CorpFin (no location preference), which one would be a better choice?

    Durham's MSc.Finance:
    -1 year (not a good thing in my case since less time to find an internship)
    -Closer to London (+)
    -English language spoken everywhere (+)
    -More specialized degree (+)

    EM Lyon's MSc.Management:
    -2 to 3 years with 6 months abroad and 12 months of in-company internships (bad and good)
    -Ranked fairly well (+)
    -Further away from London (-)
    -Lack of French will hinder my progress in just about every single way (-)
    -Has a Finance track, but still might be too broad of a degree

    I don't have any internships under my belt so taking on a Master's degree can quickly become pointless if I graduate without changing that. At the same time though, I have no idea how investment banks in England see someone holding a MSc. in Management from a French school outside the top-3. Nor am I intuned to how Durham's Master's students are viewed. From speaking with a couple EM Lyon's students, some BBs do give interviews and there is certainly some type of representation in London from Durham, but I'm pretty sure all of those graduates already had an internship before taking on a Master's degree, which snowballed into getting further opportunities and finally resulted in a FT offer.

    Just to get this out there: I realize this will be nearly impossible to pull off, so I'm being realistic. I'll be focusing on boutiques and MM firms as well as the Big4,CorpFin and so on, but my endgoal is IB.

    Any thoughts on this?
    You can still get into Investment Banking from lower uni's than top 3. They aren't that narrow minded, it just so happens though that many people who are suitable for IB go to great uni's.

    If you want a career in finance, more specifically IB then you need to show you're intelligent, logical and can work with numbers, that's why they take many Maths students etc. I would vote you take Finance at Durham.

    Management can involve other aspects such as marketing, hr etc, that isn't going to give you a great grounding for an IB interview.

    Go with your heart though, finance may seem attractive with the salaries, but some people who started at big 4, for example, sometimes realise after a couple of years that they don't actually like finance.
    • Thread Starter
    Offline

    0
    ReputationRep:
    I forgot to mention that I hold a Bachelor's in Economics with a minor in Finance as well as have some decent ECs (small business, finance club, athlete, and others)
    Offline

    2
    ReputationRep:
    Go with EM Lyon. They're a top ranked grande ecole and will give you more time to get the right work experience.
    Durham is still pretty far from London and while somewhat respected, probably not by far as much as any decently ranked grande ecole. A 1 year programe won't give you the time to fix your itnernship situation. Also, Durham is not well known internationally.
    EM Lyon will give you more plan B options.
 
 
 
Poll
Is GoT overrated?
Useful resources

Articles:

Guide to investment bankingGuide to consultancy

Featured recruiter profiles:

Deutsche Bank logo

Deutsche Bank is recruiting

"Thrive in an international banking environment"

Quick link:

Unanswered investment banking and consultancy threads

Groups associated with this forum:

View associated groups

The Student Room, Get Revising and Marked by Teachers are trading names of The Student Room Group Ltd.

Register Number: 04666380 (England and Wales), VAT No. 806 8067 22 Registered Office: International House, Queens Road, Brighton, BN1 3XE

Quick reply
Reputation gems: You get these gems as you gain rep from other members for making good contributions and giving helpful advice.