The Student Room Group

Partial Fractions



Can anyone tell me why doing two different methods yields two different answers? Thanks


Posted from TSR Mobile
Original post by Namige

Can anyone tell me why doing two different methods yields two different answers? Thanks


Because your partial fractions break down is incomplete, and should be:

x24x(x2)(x+1)2Ax2+B(x+1)2+Cx+1\displaystyle\frac{x^2-4x}{(x-2)(x+1)^2}\equiv\frac{A}{x-2}+\frac{B}{(x+1)^2}+\frac{C}{x+1}
Reply 2
Original post by ghostwalker
Because your partial fractions break down is incomplete, and should be:

x24x(x2)(x+1)2Ax2+B(x+1)2+Cx+1\displaystyle\frac{x^2-4x}{(x-2)(x+1)^2}\equiv\frac{A}{x-2}+\frac{B}{(x+1)^2}+\frac{C}{x+1}


Cheers but why was my method wrong? It seems right :/


Posted from TSR Mobile
Original post by Namige
Cheers but why was my method wrong? It seems right :/


If you plug in only two values, you'll get a solution as there are only two unknowns, when you use just A and B. It's when you try a third value, that the problem shows up.
Reply 4
Original post by ghostwalker
If you plug in only two values, you'll get a solution as there are only two unknowns, when you use just A and B. It's when you try a third value, that the problem shows up.


So I have used your method an have got this :

When I plug in x=4, it gives me 3x10^-5 but how can this be, as plugging it into the original formula clearly gives you zero. All other numbers work though...


Posted from TSR Mobile
Reply 5
Original post by ghostwalker
If you plug in only two values, you'll get a solution as there are only two unknowns, when you use just A and B. It's when you try a third value, that the problem shows up.


I know, but why is that?


Posted from TSR Mobile
Original post by Namige

When I plug in x=4, it gives me 3x10^-5 but how can this be, as plugging it into the original formula clearly gives you zero. All other numbers work though...


How on earth do you get 3x1o^-5?

I get 0.
Original post by Namige
I know, but why is that?


Posted from TSR Mobile


With just A and B.

Because your values of A,B are wrong. They can never be right, because there are only two of them.

If you plug in 2 values for x, you will get values for A and B.

If you use different values for x, you will get different values for A and B.

Only when you try 3 values for x, is the problem hightlighted.
Reply 8
Original post by ghostwalker
How on earth do you get 3x1o^-5?

I get 0.


For the partial fractions one I get that. Every other number works fine.


Posted from TSR Mobile
Original post by Namige
For the partial fractions one I get that. Every other number works fine.


Posted from TSR Mobile


Post your working then.
Reply 10
Original post by ghostwalker
Post your working then.




This is for x=4.


Posted from TSR Mobile
Original post by Namige

This is for x=4.


Should have guessed it was a calculator.

3e-15.

Well it's a problem with the accuracy of the calculator. It's stored the numbers as decimals, and all it can do is approximate the last digit.
If you can get it to work in fractions, it should come out correctly.
Original post by ghostwalker
Should have guessed it was a calculator.

3e-15.

Well it's a problem with the accuracy of the calculator. It's stored the numbers as decimals, and all it can do is approximate the last digit.
If you can get it to work in fractions, it should come out correctly.


Oh blimey. PRSOM.
Reply 13
Original post by ghostwalker
Should have guessed it was a calculator.

3e-15.

Well it's a problem with the accuracy of the calculator. It's stored the numbers as decimals, and all it can do is approximate the last digit.
If you can get it to work in fractions, it should come out correctly.


Doing it by Fraction in a single calculation still doesnt work, but by hand does. Very Strange.


Posted from TSR Mobile
Reply 14
Original post by Namige
...


Well the problem is the calculator, or how you're using it, and not having one of that model myself, I can't help.

But the maths, by hand, is correct, 0.
Original post by Namige
Very Strange.


"Never trust a machine you can carry." Dusty Rivers
Reply 17
Original post by ghostwalker
Well the problem is the calculator, or how you're using it, and not having one of that model myself, I can't help.

But the maths, by hand, is correct, 0.
Thank you for your help:smile:

Quick Reply

Latest