The Student Room Group

This discussion is now closed.

Check out other Related discussions

Who Was The Greatest British Prime Minister?

I personally believe it was Winston Churchill. His exceptional leadership during WWII shall never be surpassed. But to be fair, he was not necessarily as great on the domestic front. So I was thinking I would also ask another question: if Winston Churchill (although not everyone may agree) was the greatest wartime Prime Minister, who was the greatest Prime Minister domestically?

Scroll to see replies

For me it would have to be Clement Attlee! Welfare state bitches! I also liked Stanley Baldwin because of reasons.
John Major.
Reply 3
Avatar for The Dictator
The Dictator
OP
2
Original post by bobbieare
For me it would have to be Clement Attlee! Welfare state bitches! I also liked Stanley Baldwin because of reasons.


In my opinion Attlee started well but got bogged down with economic slowdown and the unavoidable fact that Britain was very dependent on America at that time. I respect him for expanding the welfare state (though he didn't create it, Lloyd George did) and for starting the process of decolonisation, but apart from that, idk what else he did. Idk if Churchill would have done much better.
Reply 4
Avatar for The Dictator
The Dictator
OP
2
Original post by CJG21
John Major.


Why is that?
Original post by The Dictator
Why is that?


I was being sarcastic.
Clement Atlee really? I'd argue the Labour Reforms were a direct result of William Beveridge, not him.
Original post by The Dictator
In my opinion Attlee started well but got bogged down with economic slowdown and the unavoidable fact that Britain was very dependent on America at that time. I respect him for expanding the welfare state (though he didn't create it, Lloyd George did) and for starting the process of decolonisation, but apart from that, idk what else he did. Idk if Churchill would have done much better.


I couldn't pick my favourite overall but domestically I'd have to go for Attlee, I think there were different ones who would be perceived the best under different circumstances. I mean Ramsay MacDonald sucked during 1929-31 but he then handled the economic crisis pretty well which was carried on by Baldwin. I am a fine of Churchill though, can't deny that!
Got to give a shoutout to Sir Walpole who kicked it all off.
Reply 9
Avatar for The Dictator
The Dictator
OP
2
Original post by bobbieare
I couldn't pick my favourite overall but domestically I'd have to go for Attlee, I think there were different ones who would be perceived the best under different circumstances. I mean Ramsay MacDonald sucked during 1929-31 but he then handled the economic crisis pretty well which was carried on by Baldwin. I am a fine of Churchill though, can't deny that!


Attlee was not too successful in foreign policy though. As the history books show, Bevin exhausted himself, America was treated us like a puppet, and we couldn't afford to argue because after winning the war we were stone broke and America, which had a booming economy even after the war, naturally took the credit and was happy to dictate to us. I admire MacDonald for putting aside tribal political loyalties and leading a National Government even though his own party in the event labelled him a traitor.
Even as a free market libertarian I'd probably say Clement Attlee. Britain had spent 1/4 of it's national wealth on the war, debt was up threefold, economy reliant on the lend-lease agreement with the USA. Despite all this he still managed to expand (not create) the welfare state, and found the mixed economy. In the 21st century when our welfare state and public sector are now thanks to New Labour unsustainably big, his socialist policies would be ****. But at a time when the richest 1% owned 60% of the wealth he was the right man for the job.
Churchill obviously. Any of the other candidates in 1940 would have lead us to defeat or surrender.
Gordon Brown, lots of love for him


Posted from TSR Mobile
Benjamin Disraeli, without a doubt.
Original post by Miracle Day
Clement Atlee really? I'd argue the Labour Reforms were a direct result of William Beveridge, not him.


The welfare state may have been Beveridge's idea, but Attlee implemented it.
Churchill was a warmongering sociopath. So were the rest of them.
Original post by TheTranshumanist
The welfare state may have been Beveridge's idea, but Attlee implemented it.


I really don't think he had a choice, and any labour prime minister would have done the same.
Original post by Miracle Day
I really don't think he had a choice, and any labour prime minister would have done the same.


What makes you say he had no choice? I'm sure he never opposed it. He definitely deserves credit for how he implemented it.

Additionally, he had a role in the decolonisation of the British Empire.
Original post by The Dictator
In my opinion Attlee started well but got bogged down with economic slowdown and the unavoidable fact that Britain was very dependent on America at that time. I respect him for expanding the welfare state (though he didn't create it, Lloyd George did) and for starting the process of decolonisation, but apart from that, idk what else he did. Idk if Churchill would have done much better.


It is not the fault of Atlee that post-war Britain was dependent on the United States; this had been the case for just under a decade. The brilliance of Eden was, as you said, the expansion of Britain’s welfare state to be the biggest in world at the time. So great were his initiatives that the Conservatives had to realign themselves to them to remain a credible opposition (One of very few times an opposition has been forced to do this). Personally I think that the best British Prime Minister was Tony Blair but I'd rather not get into that!

Also, just a quick correction, it was not Lloyd George who created the Welfare State it was Campbell-Bannerman and Asquith (Although I grant you that Lloyd George was part of those governments and did do a reasonable job of extending the Welfare State himself in 1918-21).
IMO

Blair
Attlee
Thatcher
MacMillan

Related discussions

Latest

Trending

Trending

Articles for you